ICE 'Used Due Process as Bait,' Arresting North Carolina Man Moments After He Left a Sanctuary Church

Illustration for article titled ICE 'Used Due Process as Bait,' Arresting North Carolina Man Moments After He Left a Sanctuary Church
Image: Getty

Samuel Oliver-Bruno, an undocumented 20-year resident of North Carolina who had been living in a Durham church for 11 months, was arrested alongside faith leaders and supporters at an appointment with immigration officials to discuss a petition to delay his deportation, according to CNN.  

Oliver-Bruno was told the meeting was to provide fingerprints and discuss the petition at the offices of US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). About 20 minutes into the appointment, Oliver-Bruno was arrested by plainclothes officers. For two hours, dozens of the supporters who had accompanied him surrounded the van set to take him to detention. They were arrested as well, CNN reports:

Faith leaders and church members quickly formed a human wall around the vehicle taking him to detention, and would not leave. They locked arms around the agents’ unmarked gold-colored van and prayed for about two hours. They sang “Amazing Grace” and other worship songs. “Let him stay!” they yelled. “Let your people go!”


Oliver-Bruno, who was born in Veracruz, Mexico but had lived in the states for over twenty years, moved into the CityWell United Methodist Church in Durham, North Carolina 11 months ago to avoid deportation, since traditionally, ICE doesn’t make arrests in “sensitive locations.” However, according to Pastor Cleve May, Oliver-Bruno was baited out of the sanctuary church:

“It was presented as a legitimate appointment but ICE utilized due process as bait,” May said. “So we went to the appointment with him, to offer protection, knowing that ICE could not be trusted. We were thinking we would be in and out in 30 minutes.”

ICE spokesman Bryan Cox is calling the move “targeted enforcement action.”

“Mr. Oliver-Bruno is a convicted criminal who has received all appropriate legal process under federal law, has no outstanding appeals, and has no legal basis to remain in the US,” Cox said.


In 2014, Oliver-Bruno was arrested in El Paso, Texas for using a forged birth certificate to enter the US. As the case moved through the appeals process, Oliver-Bruno left his son and wife, who has lupus, for the safety of the Methodist church, where he played guitar and read for services. He continued studying at Duke University’s Divinity School after classmates agreed to move lessons to the church.

North Carolina Congressmen David Price and G.K. Butterfield are “extremely alarmed” by the coordinated efforts of ICE and USCIS to lure Oliver-Bruno out of the church and into an arrest.


“At best, Mr. Oliver-Bruno was presented with a catch-22 dilemma; at worst, he was entrapped,” their joint statement said.

Oliver-Bruno will remain in detention until his case is adjudicated.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter


Hello Emily, My name is Susan, I was one the arrested and am also a volunteer with Alerta Migratoria NC, one of the immigrant advocacy groups working with Samuel. Thank you for this well-written article. I would like to add the reason Samuel had forged documents was because he had reentered the country to be with his wife, who needed to have emergency open-heart surgery to save her life. She has advanced lupus with multiple organ involvement. Samuel had returned to Mexico for a family emergency and needed to return to the United States to be with her during surgery. Given the extenuating circumstances surrounding his re-entry, he was released by ICE fairly quickly in 2014 so he could be with his wife. Additionally, we have heard from at least one national media outlet that USCIS is insinuating Samuel did not have a biometrics appointment. You are welcome to use the photograph of his appointment letter from our facebook page, if USCIS also insinuated them same to you. Also worth mentioned is that Samuel is being held at the Wake County Detention Center. The county police have a 287(g) program in place. Ultimately, this was a collaboration between at least three groups : ISCIS, ICE, and the Wake County Sheriff’s Department. The tax dollars spent to detain a single human being who is caring for his sick wife must have been a large investment. The current Wake County Sheriff Donnie Harrison lost his re-election by a landslide. He lost primarily because voters wanted him to stop using 287(g)and Gerald R. Baker is committed to not using 287(g). Harrison’s last day is December 3 - we think he also used Samuel has one last “hurrah” before his exit.