Watchdog Group With Nothing Better to Do Sues the FDA For Not Declaring Salt A Menace to Society

Illustration for article titled Watchdog Group With Nothing Better to Do Sues the FDA For Not Declaring Salt A Menace to Society

We face many evils in society that government regulation would do a lot to help us avoid. Salt should be pretty low on that list—unless you’re the Center For Science in the Public Interest, apparently.


OK, fine, in the interest of fairness, let’s hear what CSPI has to say. From their website:

“For more than 35 years, FDA has dragged its feet and refused to do anything to protect Americans from excess sodium in the food supply,” said CSPI President Michael F. Jacobson. “The government’s inaction condemns hundreds of thousands of Americans to early deaths due to preventable strokes and heart attacks.”

Alright, eating too much salt can have long-term consequences—just like eating pretty much anything. And yes, we eat way, WAY too much salt. As a result, CSPI’s 2005 petition asked the FDA to revoke salt’s “generally recognized as safe” status, which seems comically overboard to me. The petition also wants the FDA to require health warnings on retail packages of at least one half-ounce of table salt, because salt is apparently as dangerous as cigarettes. As a result of the FDA dragging their heels on this petition (which makes sense, as it is somewhat silly, if well-intentioned), CSPI is suing, claiming it is breach of a law requiring federal agencies to respond to petitions in a timely manner. What, after only 10 years? With the speed of government, that actually sounds pretty reasonable.

Look, I’m sorry; I know too much sodium is bad for you, and we as Americans eat too much of it. This is true. It’s also true that the health care burden of excess sodium consumption is less than ideal.

But salt isn’t cigarettes. Hell, it isn’t even trans fats. Yes, we should reduce our salt intake, but surgeon general’s warnings and revoking a generally safe status should be reserved for things that are, y’know...actually legitimately dangerous.

Image via Jiri Hera/Shutterstock.

Contact the author at



On the other hand, the salt shaker on your table may be hell-bent on the extermination of all life in the universe that is not salt.