The Real People Behind Famous Fictional Characters

What, you thought Lolita and Norman Bates came out of thin air?

Illustration for article titled The Real People Behind Famous Fictional Characters
Advertisement

Alice in Wonderland. Perhaps the most famous literary muse in history, Alice Liddell was a child when she first charmed family friend Charles Lutwidge Dodgson and inspired him to tell - and then write - his classic story of a little girl's adventures in Wonderland. Although the relationship is steeped in controversy, it's thought that Liddell's parents put the kibbosh on a friendship that seemed to be getting questionable; there's also some evidence that Dodson proposed to the adult Alice. As an older woman, Liddell (whose married name was Alice Hargreaves) enjoyed the association and accepted several medals in commemoration of her role.

Illustration for article titled The Real People Behind Famous Fictional Characters
Advertisement

Dolores Haze, Lolita While it's by no means certain (Nabokov had been playing with the idea of a pedophiliac subject for some years) some critics - most notably, Alexander Dolinin - have argued that Nabokov derived inspiration for his iconic nymphet from the case of Sally Horner, a twelve-year-old New Jersey girl who was abducted by "a middle-aged morals offender" and kept for 21 months as his "cross-country slave." Like Humbert Humbert - who references the case in his narrative - Horner's captor posed as her father. And like Lolita, Horner came to a tragic and premature end: she died in a car accident in 1952, aged only fifteen.


Illustration for article titled The Real People Behind Famous Fictional Characters

Lady Macbeth, Macbeth. The actual wife of Macbeth was one Gruoch of Scotland, but in crafting his villainous helpmate, Shakespeare is believed to have drawn on another queen found in the 1587 book Holinshed's Chronicles. The wife of King Duff is said to have exhorted her husband to regicide. "Specially his wife lay sore upon him to attempt the thing, as she was very ambitious, burning with an unquenchable desire to bear the name of a queen."


Illustration for article titled The Real People Behind Famous Fictional Characters
Advertisement

Dill, To Kill a Mockingbird. While Harper Lee has stated that her classic novel is not autobiographical, she admitted that the character of Dill, the Finches' imaginative, "little but old" neighbor was based on childhood friend Truman Capote, who spent time with his aunts in Monroeville, Alabama. Their friendship continued into adulthood.


Illustration for article titled The Real People Behind Famous Fictional Characters
Advertisement

Molly Bloom, Ulysses. Leopold Bloom's unfaithful wife, Molly, was based partially on the Odyssey's Penelope, but more directly on Joyce's own wife, Nora Barnacle (the novel takes place on the date of the couple's first outing - now known as Bloomsday.) Others point to a student of Joyce's, Amalia Popper (pictured), with whom the author had an affair: like Molly, Popper was Jewish, and corresponds more closely to physical descriptions of the character.


Advertisement
Illustration for article titled The Real People Behind Famous Fictional Characters

Norman Bates, Psycho AND Buffalo Bill, Silence of the Lambs Robert Bloch based his 1959 novel - later immortalized by Hitchcock - on the crimes of Wisconsin serial killer Ed Gein. Gein, who lived in isolation with a domineering mother until her death, was accused of the muder of two women in Wisconsin; later, he was also discovered to have robbed numerous graves - including those of women he felt resembled his dead mother - and made objects from their skin and bones. Gein said he desired a sex-change operation and had made the "hides" of his murder victims into a "woman suit." Gein died of cancer in a Wisconsin mental institution in 1984.


Advertisement
Illustration for article titled The Real People Behind Famous Fictional Characters

Sethe, Beloved. Toni Morrison based her fifth novel on the famous case of Margaret Garner, an escaped slave who in 1856 stabbed her two-year-old daughter to death rather than allow her to be returned to slavery. The case was a sensational one that engaged the abolitionist cause, but Garner and her husband were ultimately returned to slavery. Margaret Garner died in 1858, of typhoid. Garner was a popular subject of sentimental poetry and paintings after her death; Morrison was inspired not only to base her character of Sethe on Garner, but wrote the libretto for the opera Margaret Garner.


Advertisement
Illustration for article titled The Real People Behind Famous Fictional Characters

Dollanganger Family, Flowers in the Attic. While many assume that V.C. Andrews' tale of incest and captivity is simply too lurid to have any basis in fact, the V.C. Andrews website states otherwise: first, there's the author's (pictured) original pitch letter, in which she describes the novel as the fictionalized version of a true story." Then, the webmaster claims that an Andrews relative wrote her, "Flowers in the Attic WAS based on a true story. Virginia [V.C.] was a young lady when my dad made arrangements to take Virginia to the University of Virginia hospital for treatment. While she was there, she developed a crush on her young doctor. He and his siblings had been locked away in the attic for over 6 years to preserve the family wealth. Obviously she cut the time back [in her novel] to be more believable. That area of the country has a lot of very wealthy people. I do not know who they were...Virginia herself told me that her story was based on a true one from UVA Hospital."

Advertisement

Works Cited:
Bjork, Cristina. The Other Alice: The Story of Alice Liddell and Alice in Wonderland
Cohen, Morton. Lewis Carroll: A Biography
Ckarke, Gerald. Too Brief a Treat: The Letters of Truman Capote
Maddox, Brenda. NORA: The Real Life of Molly Bloom

Advertisement


What Happened To Sally Horner?: A Real-Life Source Of Nabokov's Lolita [libraries.psu.edu]
Florence Sally Horner [Wikipedia]
Holinshed's Chronicles [KCL.ac.uk]
Will The Real Lady Macbeth Please Stand Up [Word Wenches]
Truman Capote [BNet]
Truman Capote Is Dead at 59; Novelist of Style and Clarity [NYT]
The Blooming Of Molly [Brighthub.com]
Ed Gein: The Inspiration For Buffalo Bill And Psycho [Crime Library]
A Historical Margaret Garner [MOTOPERA]

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

thebestueverhad
TheBestUEverHad

I think the pedophile allegations against Lewis Carroll have become too widespread. Pedophilia is one of those things (like Nazism and killing your spouse) that once brought against someone basically ruins their historical reputation in the eyes of everyone who hears about it.

It's okay to speculate, but this story has become so widespread everyone just assumes it's true. Which isn't really the case; there's little strong evidence Caroll ever molested anyone. He was certainly eccentric in some ways, but a lot of things that would be creepy today weren't in the Victorian era. Photographing nude children was okay because children were not sexualized as much. Photographing corpses was also very common.

There's more evidence for Michael Jackson than for Lewis Carroll, but M.J. was able to defend and explain himself and had fans and supporters to help him. And then his tragic death made it seem unkind to continue with the allegations. I don't think Michael Jackson molested children either, but it's a relevant example.

I have no problem with speculation, but one should be careful when talking about something as horrific (and damning) as pedophilia.