[New York, February 13. Image via Getty.]
The face she's making leads me to imagine that she was just the star of a Makeovers For Charity! show and they pushed her out onto the red carpet to see the BIG REVEAL in the mirror. Just the right level of utter shock and be-nice-to-the-producers-grimace. Also, that way I don't have to think she did any of this to herself.
I think the tattoos are new since Idol, though, and that's unexpected in a better way.