Colorado Woman Who Cut Stranger's Baby From Womb Convicted of Attempted Murder

Illustration for article titled Colorado Woman Who Cut Stranger's Baby From Womb Convicted of Attempted Murder

A Colorado woman who cut out a stranger’s baby has been convicted of attempted murder and unlawful termination of a pregnancy, among other charges. Dynel Lane attacked Michelle Wilkins after Wilkins, then 7 1/2 months pregnant, came to her home answering a Craigslist ad offering baby maternity clothes.


A judge ruled last week that the jury wouldn’t be allowed to hear the cause of death for Wilkins’ baby, who was well past the point of viability and who she’d planned to name Aurora. Lane, 35, beat and stabbed Wilkins, 27, and then used a kitchen knife to cut her open. Lane then carried the baby to a hospital and initially told doctors it was hers before admitting to police and medical staff she’d cut it out of Wilkins, who was lying on the floor of her home and who lost nearly half the blood in her body.

Lane’s boyfriend testified last week that she told him she was pregnant in April 2014, sending him ultrasound images and pictures of a distended belly, but refused to see a doctor with him and was hazy about her due date. After 10 months passed with no baby, the man, David Ridley, testified that he said he needed answers from a doctor “or he would leave her,” per ABC. On the day of the attack, they were supposed to attend a pre-natal appointment together; when he arrived, he testified, he found the baby in a bathtub. Lane told him she’d given birth there, he said.

Lane was convicted of four counts of assault, attempted murder, and unlawful termination of a pregnancy. She faces up to 140 years in jail when sentenced in April. Wilkins, meanwhile, read a statement saying she forgives Lane for the crime, 9 News reports, quoting Martin Luther King Jr.:

“There is nothing — in any way, shape or form — that can prepare you for something like this,” Wilkins said. “What has dominated my perspective consistently is disbelief, and words are not sufficient to describe it, though I may try. It had just never entered my world view that someone could be so cruel and value life so little.”

Wilkins decided during her statement to respond to the question she gets often: How she feels about Lane.

“Early on, I have said I have forgiven her,” Wilkins said. “It’s part of who I am as a human being, and Martin Luther King said it brilliantly: ‘We must develop and maintain the capacity to forgive. He who is devoid of the power to forgive is devoid of the power to love. There is some good in the worst of us and some evil in the best of us. When we discover this, we are less prone to hate our enemies.’ So, no, I do not hate Dynel [Lane,] but I am angry for all the pain she has caused, the deceit and her selfishness. And this element is hardly fathomable for me.”

In response to the crime, a Republican legislator has been pushing to introduce a new law making “fetal homicide” a crime in Colorado. State Democrats remain concerned that the bill could be a backdoor attempt to introduce personhood law making abortions harder to obtain.

Contact the author at
Public PGP key
PGP fingerprint: 67B5 5767 9D6F 652E 8EFD 76F5 3CF0 DAF2 79E5 1FB6


Lane’s mugshot. Photo via Longmont Police Department/AP Images



“Early on, I have said I have forgiven her,” Wilkins said.

Here’s a question I’ve always struggled with. Why is everyone so quick to forgive everyone in horrible situations like this? This other woman cut her open, presumably knowing it might kill her, or someone’s child or parent is randomly murdered by gun violence or someone is raped, etc. etc. and it seems the victim is so quick to say they forgive the other person. I know no one knows how they would act in certain situations, but I have a feeling I would be angry and hating for a long, long time.