Body of Sheila Abdus-Salaam, First U.S. Female Muslim Judge Found in Hudson River

The body of Sheila Abdus-Salaam, the first female Muslim judge in the United States, was found floating in the Hudson River Wednesday afternoon.


The New York Post reports that Abdus-Salaam was discovered by witnesses who called 911. Abdus-Salaam, who was an associate judge on the Court of Appeals, had been reported missing from her Harlem home earlier Wednesday.

Abdus-Salaam was not only the first female Muslim judge in the county; she was also the first black woman to be appointed to the Court of Appeals. She graduated from Columbia Law School and started her career as a staff attorney at East Brooklyn Legal Services and was elected to the Supreme Court in 1993. In 2013, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo appointed her to the Court of Appeals in 2013.

Her law school classmate former US Attorney General Eric Holder was present at her swearing in ceremony and made note of how Abdus-Salaam had “defined herself by her relentless pursuit of excellence.” Per Holder at the time, she was also a fantastic dancer.

From the Post:

“Sheila could boogie,” Holder joked at the time. ‘She was a witty and a great deal of fun to spend time with.”

Abdus-Salaam went on to note how unlikely her and Holder’s professional achievements in law would have been four decades ago.

“Who knew that we would both attain such high positions, and that you would be the first black United States attorney general, and I would be the first black woman on the New York Court of Appeals?” she told him with a big smile.

Jonathan Lippman, chief judge of the state Court of Appeals from 2009-2015 during part of Abdus-Salaam’s tenure, told the Post how “deeply saddened” he was at the news of her death, saying that she was a “superb jurist and an even more superb human being.”

“It’s just so shocking,” he told the Post. “She was a very genteel, lovely lady and judge If you ask anyone about her, people would say only the most wonderful things. That’s why it makes it even more difficult to understand.”


Sources said to the Post that there appeared to be no signs of foul play and that her death was likely a suicide.

Senior Writer, Jezebel


The New York legal community is in shock. Colleagues of mine who have argued before her said that she was an excellent judge.

If indeed a suicide, it’s a reminder that you can’t know what struggles someone is having from outward appearances — she ascended to the top of her profession and was by all means successful, but mental health issues don’t discriminate.