An At-Home DNA Testing Company Is Giving the FBI Access to Its Records

Illustration for article titled An At-Home DNA Testing Company Is Giving the FBI Access to Its Records
Image: Getty

For years, DNA testing conspiracy theorists have been saying those at-home DNA testing kits that help people figure out their ancestry and find relatives will also one day be stockpiled by the government to keep tabs on us, and it looks like that day is now.


According to Buzzfeed News, Family Tree DNA is letting the FBI peruse its database of 1,021,774 records in order to potentially catch killers, rapists, and identify remains.

“Without realizing it, [Family Tree DNA founder and CEO Bennett Greenspan] had inadvertently created a platform that, nearly two decades later, would help law enforcement agencies solve violent crimes faster than ever,” FamilyTree said in a statement to Buzzfeed.

Here’s how it works right now: Family Tree doesn’t have a contract with the FBI, but the firm will test DNA samples in its private lab and upload those profiles to its database. 

Buzzfeed reports that the company has worked with the FBI on fewer than 10 cases since fall. Family Tree is the first of these private DNA testing firms, which also include 23andMe or, to work directly with law enforcement to solve cases.

However, right now their access is limited to databases where users have voluntarily given their results, though those users ostensibly uploaded their information to find relatives and not to give their records to law enforcement.

In a statement to Rolling Stone, a spokesperson for Family Tree saidthe FBI’s access is limited to that of any ordinary user; if a DNA sample from a victim or potential perpetrator matches with any other profile in the database, ‘then law enforcement must provide FamilyTreeDNA with valid legal process, such as a subpoena or search warrant’ to obtain any additional information.”


In a recent survey, 85% of people questioned in the U.S. and Europe said they wouldn’t mind granting law enforcement access to their DNA in order to solve rape and murder cases. But some people who used Family Tree without knowing law enforcement would have access to their genetic information are, understandably, not happy, and ethics professors warn that this might just be the tip of the iceberg:

“We are nearing a de-facto national DNA database,” Natalie Ram, an assistant law professor at the University of Baltimore who specializes in bioethics and criminal justice, told BuzzFeed News. “We don’t choose our genetic relatives, and I cannot sever my genetic relation to them. There’s nothing voluntary about that.”


One of the most notable uses of DNA databases were in the hunt for the Golden State Killer, when Family Tree DNA was served with a federal subpoena to reveal the identity of an account sharing DNA with that found at a crime scene. Though the subpoena didn’t result in catching the GSK, a partial match found in a different database did.   

Family Tree was recently named the best kit for “research and privacy” by U.S. News. They still promise not to sell your DNA info to corporations, but we’ll see.


Mortal Dictata

DNA testing conspiracy theorists

I resent that description /s

But seriously from the get go there were never any solid answers provided about future usage of this data which many people (including myself) highlighted as a serious source of concern regarding these services.

The idea the government has access to this data in cases is a lesser concern to me than the one about what other for-profit companies with no oversight could get up to with it