Yes, Andrew Goldman Has Made Creepy Sexual Comments Before

Illustration for article titled Yes, Andrew Goldman Has Made Creepy Sexual Comments Before

Writer Andrew Goldman was suspended from his position at the New York Times yesterday, but the incident — a Twitter kerfuffle with author Jennifer Weiner — wasn't the first time he'd offended with sexualized comments. A friend reminded us about a 2009 interview Goldman did for Elle with Glee star Matthew Morrison. The interview starts out with Goldman questioning Morrison's sexual orientation:

ELLE: So, Matt, you're a musical theater star who's been interviewed by The Advocate and much discussed on Manhunt.com, and you star in Glee, a program that's referred to as "the gayest show on TV." You must feel particularly proud being the first gay man to grace this page.

MATTHEW MORRISON: I'm not gay.

ELLE: I had indeed read in various places that you're straight, but in light of the circumstantial evidence, I wasn't sure.

MM: I grew up singing and dancing, so people have been calling me gay since fifth grade. I've heard everything you could possibly hear about it. But I do love gay people, so I'm not going to act like I was insulted or angry about it.

Advertisement

Goldman pressed on, determined to, uh, penetrate Morrison's sexual core:

ELLE: What was the first moment you realized you were a heterosexual being?

MM: I was really sexual from an early age. My first kiss was actually with two girls at the same time. One girl would be behind the bush with me for a minute and the other girl would be timing us. Then they'd switch.

ELLE: Dirty! Who was your first sexual obsession from popular culture?

MM: Tiffani-Amber Thiessen from Saved by the Bell. I loved her.

Morrison went on to say how much he admired Salma Hayek, and Goldman tried to turn that into something sexual as well:

ELLE: How long before I pick up US Weekly and read about you two shacking up?

MM: Oh, come on. She's married to a billionaire! And she just had a kid.

ELLE: But her billionaire husband lives in Europe. Don't you need a man in every continent?

MM: I don't need a man in every continent.

The line of questioning continued, with Goldman asking, "Imagine you had the ability to see the number of a woman's sexual partners on her forehead. What's the highest number you could see and still take her seriously?"

Apparently this interview did not sit well with Morrisson; in 2010, he declared of the Goldman piece:

That was, like, the worst interview I've ever done, and it kind of turned me off from doing interviews completely, because that guy was such a d**k… It just turned into like a verbal sparring match and I was trying to be polite to him, but just right off the bat he came out with all these crazy accusations and stuff. So I was like, 'Ok, buddy... .' I was completely caught off-guard.

There's no doubt that to be a good reporter, you have to ask challenging questions. Sometimes that means pushing buttons, making the subject uncomfortable. With celebrities, who have media training and canned responses, getting something new, different and exciting can mean going where other reporters haven't gone. But there is a line, somewhere. And everyone can tell when it's been crossed. And going after women and those you presume to be gay… not cool.

Meanwhile, Jennifer Weiner, who was the recipient of Goldman's sexually charged tweets earlier this week, has accepted his apology and tells the Atlantic Wire: "Suspending Andrew Goldman wasn't anything I sought or asked for, but I believe it sends a message ... and it's a good starting place for addressing the overarching problem that allowed Andrew Goldman to tweet what he did in the first place."

Advertisement

During the Weiner exchange, Goldman felt the need to tweet: "I feel like my record of asking direct questions to men is ignored in order to trump up misogyny charge." Noted!

Matthew Morrison: The music man has moves to make Timberlake blush [Elle]
Matthew Morrison not 'Glee'-ful about Elle interview [Zap2It]
Jennifer Weiner on Andrew Goldman's Suspension [Atlantic Wire]

Advertisement

Earlier: New York Times's Andrew Goldman Temporarily Suspended for Sexist Comments

DISCUSSION

ProfessorProfessorson
ProfessorProfessorson

Ew, this sounds exactly like an interview ELLE did with Ricky Gervais a while back, it was so inappropriate I couldn't believe they published it: http://www.elle.com/pop-culture/celebrities/ricky-gervais-339288

They don't say who the interviewer is, but I think it's the same guy because he also asked Gervais "If you were single and could see on women's heads the number of partners they'd had, what's the highest number you'd consider when seeking a serious relationship?" (Very similar to the question he asked Morrison.)

Some other journalistic gems from the interview:

- If your life depended on having sex with an animal, which would you choose?

- If your life depended on either making love with your writing partner, Stephen Merchant, or a random, similarly aged man, whom would you choose?

- I understand you are a great lover of art. What painting—from the nineteenth century or earlier—is most arousing?

I loved the part where Ricky told the interviewer off:

Oh, God! Really? Some of my favorite paintings were by [J.M.W.] Turner, who painted the ship on fire. I've heard of fetishes, but going down to the docks with a pack of matches has never been one of mine. I imagine your next question is going to start off, "Now Ricky, I've heard one of your heroes is Winston Churchill. Would you like to shove his cigar up your ass? Or pour his brandy over your nipples?" You've let yourself down, you've let ELLE down, and in a way, you've let America down. Is this really for ELLE, or has a serial killer taken your family hostage and told you you have to ask people these sorts of questions?