What Would It Take for Trump-Loving Louisiana Voters to Elect a Democrat to the Senate?

Screenshot via fostercampbell2016.com.
Screenshot via fostercampbell2016.com.

Tomorrow, Louisiana Public Service Commissioner Foster Campbell, a gun-totin’ pro-life economic populist who’s been billed as the Democrats’ last hope, will vie against Republican State Treasurer John Kennedy for a seat in the Senate in Louisiana’s runoff election. In the unlikely event of Campbell’s win, Senate Republicans would be knocked down to an extremely slim 51-49 majority, giving Democrats a boost in the apparently uphill battle to keep our democracy intact.


In Louisiana, what’s known as a jungle primary system requires all candidates from all parties compete against each other on November 8—you might recall that one of Campbell’s opponents was David Duke, who eventually received only three percent of the vote and spent an earlier debate shrieking about Jews—and the top two contenders, Campbell (with 17.5 percent of the vote) and Kennedy (with 25 percent of the vote), compete in a runoff a month later.

Trump’s shocking ascent has called any and all conventional political wisdom, including polling, into question, and Democrats around the country have rallied behind Campbell with fundraisers and phone banking efforts despite the fact that he’s polling double-digits behind his well-liked opponent. Why can’t Democrats win a long-shot race, too? And hey—maybe! If you’re a Democrat in Louisiana, it is absolutely imperative that you vote tomorrow! But the messaging challenges faced by Foster Campbell’s campaign in some ways mirror issues the Democratic party is going to need to confront, particularly in red and purple states: how do you win back angry white voters without losing your base?

Campbell, 69, is a former state senator and was elected to the Public Service Commission in 2002. He takes a folksy, common-sense stance on environmental issues, insisting that the state’s oil and gas industry take financial responsibility for the restoration of Louisiana’s wetlands: “If you tear something up, put it back,” he told the Times-Picayune last month.

From the Times-Picayune report:

Running in the age of Trump, Campbell has tried to find common ground with the average Louisiana voter, most of whom voted for Trump. He said he would support Trump’s call for term limits on Congress. He favors a 10-year ban on former members and top staffers becoming lobbyists. He is anti-abortion and reticent to support gun control measures. And he has channeled an anti-Washington sentiment similar to Kennedy’s.

But Campbell also favors raising the minimum wage and ensuring women are paid equal to men for doing the same jobs. He supports Obamacare, though he says it’s in need of legislative repair. He considers climate change a man-made phenomenon in need of intervention, earning him the endorsements of environmental groups.

President-elect Donald Trump’s appearance on Kennedy’s behalf at a “get out the vote” rally in Baton Rouge today, as well as Mike Pence’s cameo at a local rally last week, underlines the air of impossibility coloring Campbell’s position—there are no equivalent Democratic figures whose star power would help his campaign in the way that Trump is helping Kennedy, because the Democratic brand in Louisiana is fairly toxic right now.

“You gotta make the argument that you’re not a Nancy Pelosi Democrat, because that’s the kiss of death in Louisiana,” University of Louisiana political science professor Pearson Cross told Jezebel in a phone interview last week. “There’s a great deal of anger against the federal government, and most of that anger is focused on the Democrats in Washington.”


With his proud pro-life record and a much-touted collection of over 20 shotguns, Campbell has distanced himself somewhat from the national party line. He also doesn’t appear to have generated much enthusiasm amongst the minority voters that make up the traditional Democratic base; the Baton Rouge Advocate reports that black voters accounted for just 24 percent of the total turnout during the early voting period, falling short of the 30 percent generally understood to be needed for a Democrat to win. Arlanda Williams, Councilwoman for Terrebonne Parish in southern Louisiana, wrote a scathing op-ed for the Hill in October accusing Campbell of neglecting the interests of black voters: “It’s an old game you’re playing, and we’ve all been here before,” she wrote. “Politicians of a certain era have become accustomed to using the African-American community.”

Although Campbell has Governor Edwards’ endorsement, the national party has not taken an enormous amount of interest in helping him out—particularly the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, which, the state party griped to Jezebel and a number of other news outlets, has not contributed to Campbell’s campaign. (The DSCC did not respond to repeated requests for comment.)


But “our relationship with the DNC is incredibly tight,” Louisiana Democratic Party executive director Stephen Handwerk told Jezebel, going so far as to refer to interim DNC Chair Donna Brazile as his “homegirl.” A DNC representative forwarded Jezebel a few emails they’ve sent out on Campbell’s behalf, but as NBC News points out, the DNC’s website does not mention the Louisiana race. “It’ll be nice to see the DNC when I see them,” Campbell told NBC. “I’ll say, ‘It’s nice to meet you fellas. Where you been, man?” (A DNC representative declined to comment.)

A last-minute outpouring of support from frantic Democrats gave Campbell a huge fundraising boost, to the tune of $2.5 million (significantly more than Kennedy’s $1.6 million haul). But this doesn’t change the fundamental issue that Campbell is running as a Democrat in a deep-red state, one that that elected Trump by 20 points and tends to only pick Democrats—such as, for example, Louisiana’s Democratic Governor John Bel Edwards—when their Republican opponents are somehow damaged (by, say, a prostitution scandal and an epically terrible predecessor). It’s possible, although is not by any means certain, that Louisiana Republicans will eventually realize they’ve been conned within an inch of their lives by Donald Trump—but would that automatically turn them against other Republican candidates?


“I don’t think they will turn on the party specifically, I think they might turn on Donald Trump,” Cross told Jezebel in a follow-up conversation. But people don’t take lightly the decision to support the opposing team.

“The national Republican party has done a great job of having a generation of white voters look to the Republican party as the party they identify with,” he said. “And those kinds of things are not broken up overnight.”

Ellie is a freelance writer and former senior writer at Jezebel. She is pursuing a master's degree in science journalism at Columbia University in the fall.


Molly with the Mediocre Hair

WHERE ARE THE DEMOCRATS ON THIS RACE?! I’ve donated money to his campaign, and there are grassroots people calling and knocking on doors, but it’s been radio silence from high-profile Dems. Pence and Trump are both a little busy, but they’ve managed to take time out of their schedules to go give a speech. Where the hell are Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders and Joe Biden the Obamas?! This article makes it seem like the Democratic Party is dead in Louisiana, but they have a Democratic governor! It is absolutely insane to me that Democrats are barely lifting a finger to win this race.