The Trump Administration Is Using DUIs and Other Low-Level Offenses to Keep Families Separated

Illustration for article titled The Trump Administration Is Using DUIs and Other Low-Level Offenses to Keep Families Separated
Image: Getty

Last week, when the Trump administration missed a deadline to reunite all children under the age of 5 that it had forcibly separated from their families at the U.S.-Mexico border, it claimed that for some of the children, the delay occurred because their parents had serious criminal histories.


Yet as Talking Points Memo reported on Monday, a cursory examination of the administration’s claims shows that it’s using even low-level criminal convictions, such as DUI convictions, and vague claims that they are “wanted” back in their home country to stall the reunification of families.

These are neither legal nor morally defensible reasons to separate families to begin with. (Incidentally, most DUIs are typically misdemeanors.) As the ACLU’s Lee Gelernt told TPM: “Just because you have a conviction, that doesn’t mean the government can take away your child forever. The conviction has to bear on your fitness to be a parent. If you stole a shirt 15 years ago, that has no bearing on your ability to parent. You are still entitled to get your child back. But if you’ve been convicted of child molestation, that is of course a different matter.”

Gelernt added that it’s impossible to verify the accuracy of the government’s claims, given that they have provided no proof of the parents’ alleged crimes.

All of this raises some serious concerns that officials will use similar excuses to prevent or delay the reunification of all the separated children by its court-ordered deadline of July 26. Last Friday night, the administration announced that it would streamline and expedite the process for all separated families moving forward.

As Politico reported:

Under an amended plan that the Trump administration said it began deploying on Friday, Immigration and Customs Enforcement will set up between six and eight locations where families can be reunified. HHS field teams will then interview prospective parents for 15 minutes to confirm parentage and a desire to reunite with the child; HHS also will review available records to determine criminal history or other factors that may pose a risk to the child.

When parentage can be confirmed, and officials determine that the child is not at risk, HHS will then bring the child to the adult’s location within 48 hours and turn custody over to ICE.


It remains to be seen whether the administration will meet its deadline later this month. Given the wild incompetence and cruelty exhibited during the process to date, it appears highly unlikely.

Senior reporter, Jezebel



Just to clarity; a DUI is not a “minor crime”. Let’s not reframe that; considering what a battle it was/is to get drunk drivers off the road killing people. Misdemeanor or not, you’re kind of a dick if you’re driving around under the influence. Get a fucking Uber.

It’s not necessarily a good reason that kids should be taken away from their kids either; but, the key here is there is a whole other process that would have to engage for the State to take kids away from parents. That’s the injustice here. That process wither did not happen then or now, obviously. I would focus on that and not diminish receiving a DUI as ‘no big deal’.