The teen told the NYPost that she wasn’t sure if Buscemi was actually Buscemi and that he even played a little game with them: “He told us that we couldn’t take a photo with him unless we guessed who he was supposed to be, so we guessed … and then three of my friends got a picture.”

Suffice to say, if you’re not a Buscemi fan at this point, then your heart is an iceberg.