Mom Won't Be Jailed For Son's Jaywalking Death

Illustration for article titled Mom Wont Be Jailed For Sons Jaywalking Death

In April 2010, Raquel Nelson's 4-year-old son A.J. was killed when he darted into traffic as they were crossing a busy road. Unbelievably, Nelson was convicted of misdemeanor jaywalking charges that could have put her behind bars for three years, longer than the time served by the hit-and-run driver who killed her son. Thankfully, at her sentencing today a judge acted with the sanity and compassion that other law enforcement officials lacked.

Advertisement

Nelson says that while heading home with her three children one night, she decided to cross the five-lane street where the bus let them off rather than walking three-tenths of a mile to the nearest crosswalk. The family made it to the meridian, but then A.J. and her daughter ran out into the street. The Associated Press reports:

The driver, Jerry Guy, pleaded guilty to hit-and-run. According to court records, he had been drinking earlier in the day while taking pain medication, was partially blind in one eye, and had two previous hit-and-run convictions from 1997.

Advertisement

Guy was sentenced to five months in prison, but only wound up serving six months. Meanwhile, Nelson was charged with misdemeanor vehicular homicide, failing to cross at a crosswalk, and reckless conduct.

It's highly unusual for prosecutors to charge a grieving parent for a child's accidental death, but apparently they felt they needed to make an example of Nelson, because losing a child isn't quite horrible enough. Nelson could have been sentenced to 36 months in jail, one year for each charge, though prosecutors didn't recommend jail time — just probation on top of a harrowing trial.

The case provoked outrage around the country, and several groups, including the Georgia NAACP branch, defended Nelson. Today Judge Kathryn Tanksley sided with Nelson's many supporters, sentencing her to only a year of probation and 40 hours of community service, and making the unusual offer of a new trial. After the verdict Nelson told reporters, "I'm ready to go home, I'm walking out of here. I don't feel like I can be more satisfied." Her lawyer said later that she plans to accept the judge's offer for a new trial.

Sally Flocks, founder of the Atlanta pedestrian advocacy group PEDS, says the entire case was,

"really cruel and a big waste of taxpayer money. What is anybody going to learn from this? Raquel lost her precious son. The lesson she learned already is quit using transit and buy a car to get around. It's too dangerous to cross the streets here."

Advertisement

Of course, plenty of citizens can't afford a car, but maybe that's the only practical solution. Officials could have used A.J.'s tragic death to push to make roads safer for pedestrians, but instead they chose to punish his mom even more.

Ga. Mom Is Spared Prison In Son's Jaywalking Death [AP]
Mom Spared Jail Time After Driver Hits, Kills Boy [CNN]
Ga. Mom Opts For New Trial In Son's Death [AP]

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

arischwartz
Ari Schwartz: Dark Lord of the Snark

I freakin' hate people who say, "Oh, the streets are dangerous for pedestrians? STOOPID PEOPLE BUY MOAR CARS!"

Instead of turning off the spigot, let's just buy more mops! That's the right path, eh guyz?

Jeez. One thing I've learned is just how much walkability in a city matters. When I moved to NY, I first lived in White Plains, which is moderately walkable depending on location. Then I moved to Tarrytown/Sleepy Hollow (hi stalkers!) and discovered TRUE WALKABILITY. It's a joy. I get to walk to restaurants, bars, the pet store, little boutiques, and even (shock, gasp!) the supermarket! I can walk to the supermarket!

But no, the happy motorist car club supporters would instead say, "You un-American commie a-hole! We drive in this country! Wait, you say that it's safe to cross the street in your town? You sure you don't live in Commieville?"

Or at least that's how I imagine it. Anyway, I love my car and I'd never give it up, but I'll be damned if I won't look for another walkable neighborhood if/when I move again. Not only is it more fun living in a walkable neighborhood, it feels safer. I'm not exactly afraid of crossing the street, but I had plenty of close calls with jackwagon drivers in White Plains drivin' like they were out for a leisurely drive in Manhattan. Buttholes.