Leaked Savita Halappanavar Report Makes the Hospital Look Really, Really Bad

Illustration for article titled Leaked Savita Halappanavar Report Makes the Hospital Look Really, Really Bad

Savita Halappanavar died in an Irish hospital last October, a full week after the 31-year-old dentist came in with back pain and was found to be miscarrying, because doctors refused to remove the fetus until its heartbeat officially stopped. Abortions are illegal in Ireland except in cases where the mother's life might be at risk; why wouldn't the hospital save her?


The Independent has a leaked draft report of her death which gives us some jumping off points:

  • Tests showing possible blood infection on the day Savita was admitted were never followed up by staff.
  • Doctors were often too busy caring for other patients to deal immediately with the mum-to-be, whose condition grew progressively worse as time went on.
  • To prevent the spread of infection, staff should have considered performing an abortion – even before the couple requested it.

Savita and her husband Praveen were told that a miscarriage was inevitable on the very first day she was admitted at the hospital. But staff denied their repeated requests for an abortion, saying their "hands were tied" because of the law. What a tragic waste.

"If what was published today were extracts from the report then all they do is, in some ways, vindicate what my client said from the outset as to the way his wife was treated at University Hospital Galway," Praveen's solicitor Gerard O'Donnell told the Irish Times.

The hospital won't comment because the report still has to go through "rigorous fact checking and verification process." It this point, it's hard to imagine any facts that would render their actions defensible. Obviously the larger issue here is that abortion should be safe and legal for all Irish women, not just those who might die, but staffers can't claim the Catholics are totally to blame in this case.




There is no greater love than for a mother to lay down her life for her unborn or born child. It is one of the joys of being a mother. My wife would gladly give up her own life for the baby's life. A baby should never be aborted for any reason! That precious baby had a life at the moment of conception. That baby was a living being until the moment it passed on. That baby is in heaven this very second. The baby's mom, as sad as it is, is probably not in heaven because of her initial choice to want any kind of abortion regardless of what it could do to her own life.