Vote 2020 graphic
Everything you need to know about and expect during
the most important election of our lifetimes

In India, Parents Push Surgical Attempts To Turn Girls Into Boys

Illustration for article titled In India, Parents Push Surgical Attempts To Turn Girls Into Boys

There's already plenty of controversy surrounding India's strong preference for boys and high rate of sex-selective abortion. Now shocking new reports claim that some parents in the country are trying to choose their child's gender even after he or she is born.


The Indian state of Madhya Pradesh has launched an investigation in response to a Hindustan Times report that doctors have performed hundreds of operations on girls because their parents wanted boys instead. According to the paper, about 200 to 300 children ages five and under have been subjected to genitoplasty in the town of Indore. The children were also given hormonal treatments to complete the sex change operation. Supposedly parents from other areas are traveling to Indore to get the procedure because it's cheap (about $3,200) and fairly easy to obtain.

Though the practice is controversial, it's still common in the U.S. and around the world for children who are born intersex to undergo genital surgery at a young age. The seven pediatric surgeons who perform the operations in Indore say they're only done on children whose internal sex organs don't match their genitalia. However, the paper says the procedure is "allegedly being misused rampantly to promise parents a male child even though they have a female child."


Yesterday health organizations in India responded to the report, demanding that the doctors be investigated. The Medical Council of India also called for the formation of a board of medical experts to look at genitoplasty in children on a case-by-case basis. Professor Gautam Sen, a member of the group's board of governors, said:

"There should be a medical board to decide if the surgery is medically required. It has to be a responsible decision made by a panel and not a decision between a parent and a doctor."

Many intersex advocates say the procedure is almost never medically necessary. They argue that parents shouldn't choose between two sexes and force a baby to undergo a procedure that could leave them sterile. It seems medical groups in India are mainly concerned about parents trying to turn clearly female children into boys by abusing the system, not the ethics involved when children are born with ambiguous genitals.


According to The Telegraph, India's National Commission for the Protection of Child Rights has ordered the government in Madhya Pradesh to investigate whether or not parents are really lying about children being intersex. In the meantime, Ranjana Kumari of the Centre for Social Research, who's a leading campaigner against sex-selective abortion, is already condemning parents. Though her claim that this is all the fault of the "greedy middle classes running after money" sounds dubious, we agree with the general sentiment behind this comment:

"In India we say God resides in that house where there's a woman but that has evaporated because of all this greed. We need to emphasise the spiritual wealth a girl brings to a family, but we also need to support them with financial subsidies and jobs."


Assuming girls really are undergoing forced gender reassignment, it's an extreme and very disturbing sign of what happens when women are undervalued.

Docs Turn Baby Girls Into Boys [Hindustan Times]
Call For Checks On Sex Surgeries [Hindustan Times]
Indians Pay Surgeons To Turn Girls Into Boys [The Telegraph]


Earlier: Improving Conditions In India Lead To More Sex Selective Abortions
Intersex Advocates Work Against Infant Surgery


Image via absolute-india/Shutterstock.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter


Kat Callahan

Uhm. And. How exactly will these new genitals work? If the issue is in part one of passing on the family line... that's not going to happen here. I can't imagine those testes being viable.

This is precisely why our view of gender as tied to sex is so terrible. And when we get children who are intersexed, and can't be shoved into a box, we conduct a procedure that sends a message they are not wanted as is.

This is all so incredibly disturbing.