Filmmaker Makes a Compelling Case in Favor of NYC Soda Ban

Illustration for article titled Filmmaker Makes a Compelling Case in Favor of NYC Soda Ban

Filmmaker Casey Neistat made a little documentary for the New York Times about Mayor Bloomberg's infamous soda ban, which, Neistat explains, doesn't really ban as much as people who are super-covetous of their freedom to drink as much liquified sugar in a single gulp seem to think.


To start - the proposed ban on large, sugary drinks isn't really a ban on anything. Even if the New York City Board of Health passes the ban this coming Thursday, 7-Eleven, the ubiquitous convenience-store chain, will still be able to serve its 50-ounce Orange Explosion Slurpee, which contains 107 grams of sugar, the equivalent of nearly four full-size Snickers bars. Dunkin' Donuts could still sell its large Vanilla Bean Coolatta (174 grams of sugar, or nearly six Snickers bars, in its 32 ounces). And if you can find a place with unlimited refills, you can still drink as much soda as you like.

Not just that, but the ban has nothing at all to do with alcoholic drinks, "fruit" drinks or diet soda. Iced coffee and other drinks that let customers choose their own sugar adventure are still free of Bloomberg's regulatory iron grip — there simply won't be any more 20 oz. refreshing sugar pools waiting for people to dive straw-first into at the end of a long line at McDonald's.

Neistat further argues that, since obesity is a real public health menace in New York (where 58 percent of adults are overweight or obese and 5,800 deaths each year are related to obesity) and that some New Yorkers simply "aren't responsible enough to feed themselves," taking away the 20 oz. option is really just an exercise in common sense. I mean, who needs 100-plus grams of sugar in a sitting? Especially, Neistat concludes, when the soda ban might have an immediate and quantifiable impact:

If New Yorkers reduced portion size to 16 ounces from 20 ounces for one sugary drink every two weeks, it would collectively save approximately 2.3 million pounds over one year. This proposal could be the catalyst the city needs.

It's hard not to see the logic in Neistat's argument — his documentary is jaunty and his supplementary op-ed piece is concise and cogent. He discusses obesity as a public health problem without really shaming people who are overweight, but people get awfully defensive when their personal freedom — or the personal freedom they think they have — is threatened. Even though it happens to everyone everyday, nobody wants to be told a) what to do, and b) that they're wrong. So, sensible as Neistat's op-ed may be, for anyone who's riled up by Bloomberg's ban, any contrary opinion most likely creates a does-not-compute situation. Hooray for dialogue!

‘Soda Ban Explained' [NY Times]



Hello, patronizing much? Just speaking for myself now, PLEASE don't tell me no one needs 100-plus grams of sugar in a sitting. Seriously, SOMETIMES I DO! I'm pretty small, and some days I can just feel my blood sugar drop and as soon as I get a chance to eat I'm grabbing the biggest most sugary drink I can ASAP (and I don't even like soda, not to mention anything carbonated, or sweet things) before I pass out. And it's gonna be really lame if the closest place I go robs me blind and makes me juggle 3 containers down the street, because I kinda wanted to like the soda ban in theory but I'm having such a hard time getting on board...after all this suggests that I'm just as irresponsible an eater as any obese sugar-swilling New Yorker every time that I forget to bring my Ensure (360-plus calories of sugar and fat to help keep weight on, a few times a day) to the office and need a quick sugar injection. But basically I just want a size appropriate for me available when and where I need it, because I'm and adult and sometimes my sugar consumption is more than ok - it's actually good for me! Stop treating sugar like such an arch-villain.

Oh yeah, and if Bloomberg DOES want to do anything for my health I'd be for exercise incentives - because unless that somehow becomes a financial burden or bonus that's (I'm) going nowhere fast...