Cherie Blair's Sister Defends Her Much-Maligned Conversion To Islam

Illustration for article titled Cherie Blair's Sister Defends Her Much-Maligned Conversion To Islam

Tony Blair's sister-in-law, journalist Lauren Booth, made waves when she announced she was converting to Islam. Now, she explains that decision — and her frustration at having to.

Advertisement

Here's the thing: other people's conversion narratives are always tricky: at the end of the day, someone else's faith can't be explained. We can respect someone's decision, be glad they've found a system of belief that brings them peace and happiness, but more than that is difficult — particularly in the course of one Guardian article.

Booth's other point, though, is that many of her friends and acquaintances aren't even doing that. Instead, they fall back on cliche and stereotype that reveals them, for all their sophistication, to be in some ways deeply parochial. (See this article to get an idea of the backlash.) Writes Booth with understandable exasperation,

This week's screams of faux horror from fellow columnists on hearing of my conversion to Islam prove that this remains the stereotypical view regarding half a billion women currently practising Islam...Believe it or not, Muslim women can be educated, work the same deadly hours we do, and even boss their husbands about in front of his friends until he leaves the room in a huff to go and finish making the dinner. Is this patronising enough for you? I do hope so, because my conversion to Islam has been an excuse for sarcastic commentators to heap such patronising points of view on to Muslim women everywhere

Booth goes on to enumerate the varieties of Muslims she's (naturally) encountered, and reiterates the central, peaceful message of her new faith — what she calls "the gap between what had been drip-fed to me about all Muslim life – and the reality." The reality, of course, is complex. And the distinction must be made between Islam and how it's misinterpreted: "Women who are being abused by male relatives are being abused by men, not God."

It's no exaggeration to say that Booth writes with the zeal of the convert — and why not? She is one. It's impossible to defend one's faith, and one shouldn't have to. Her choices, too, should not need defending — that they do is telling.

Lauren Booth: I'm Now A Muslim. Why All The Shock And Horror? [Guardian]

DISCUSSION

knightgee
knightgee

I'm an atheist. I also don't have anything against religious people, nor do I respect them any less as intelligent caring individuals based solely on their faith. It annoys me that I have to say that, because far too many supposedly progressive, worldly, well-informed people think their lack of faith is synonymous with treating those who do have some religious adherence (or a specific religious adherence) as if they are all mouth-breathing evangelists armed with their holy book and a 4th grade education. Some of the best, most inclusive, kindest, most caring individuals in my life have been religious in some way or another. Meanwhile some of the worst individuals have been lacking in any kind of religion. It takes an extreme lack of critical thinking skills to think that with all the variations, sects, diversions etc. that exist within even just one religion that a handful of individuals claiming to be devout while they screw you over are somehow representative of the beliefs and intentions of other people. To paint them all with the same brush is not enlightened, it's snobbery. It's close-minded. It's the exact opposite of progressive.

So to individuals regurgitating islamophobic nonsense under the guys of equal opportunity anti-religious sentiments *coughBillMaheruncough*:

No matter what think you sound like when you talk about how Islam is full of backwards savages whose inclusion will inevitably turn us all into woman-haters under Sharia Law, your words are utterly indistinguishable from the bigotted vitriol that the racists and xenophobes spew about purity and wanting their country back. It mixes with it perfectly; it aids and abets it and no amount of telling yourself that your position is somehow more enlightened is going to change that.

Rant over.