Last week Amber Tamblyn told the world that she, Alexis Bledel and America Ferrera were all godmothers to Blake Lively’s daughter. “It’s a fact,” Tamblyn told Nick Lachey on his VH1 show. Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants fans squealed with delight. Their lifelong friendship is real!

Amber Tamblyn is a liar.

Blake Lively told E! “I never named them my godmothers. They’re my dear friends. I would say my baby has a lot of fairy godmothers.” Rough.

The real, non-fairy godmother is Lively’s sister, Robyn Lively, who you might know better as the redhead in Karate Kid III or star of the late-80s Teen Witch.

Image via Getty.