Black Friday Is Almost Here!
The Inventory team is rounding up deals you don’t want to miss, now through Cyber Monday. Click here to browse!

Baby Dies After Mother Chokes Her With Bible Pages

Illustration for article titled Baby Dies After Mother Chokes Her With Bible Pages

Six-week-old Faith Lovemore died after her mother, Julia, stuffed bits of Bible pages into the baby's mouth and sat on her. A judge says she was "profoundly mentally disordered and suffering from religious delusions at the time." Yeah.

Advertisement

Julia Lovemore, 41, has been detained indefinitely under the mental health act after admitting the manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility after her lawyer described her as being in "a florid state of psychoses" at the time. She suffers from bi-polar effective disorder and has suffered at least three psychotic episodes; the judge ruled that this caused "grandiose delusions of special powers, religious delusions of identity and auditory hallucinations." The day of the killing, both a social worker and a psychiatric nurse had visited the home because, authorities had been concerned about the behavior of Lovemore's husband David, 39 - "also a mentally-ill religious fanatic", the court heard." There had been previous reports of Julia hitting her elder daughter with a hairbrush, and the children were on the "at risk" register. In February 2009, a psychiatrist described Julias as "at high risk" of another psychotic episode.

When social workers arrived, they found the father "praying loudly and shouting 'Take the devil out of Julia.'" Feeling they were making the man more agitated, (and presumably concerned for the older daughter) they apparently went to get backup - and a few hours later, David carried the baby's body into a surgery. It's thought Faith was already dead in the other room at the time of the visit.

Advertisement

The prosecution has suggested that the couples' extreme religious beliefs, in combination with their mental illness, made for an especially dangerous atmosphere, saying, 'With hindsight it was judged both parents were deteriorating sharply. Profound mental ill health and engagement with religious beliefs turned out to be an explosive cocktail." The social workers had been considering an order of protection when they visited the home; tragically, the intervention came too late. An independent probe has found that social workers "underestimated" the parents' illness and that "the link between [mental illness and religious extremism] was not sufficiently articulated." However,the Cambridgeshire Local Safeguarding Children Board Vice Chairman defends their social workers, saying it was an exceptional situation with a tragic outcome. "The circumstances around this death were exceptional. There were complex issues within the family around mental health, and the practice of their religious beliefs."

While it would be a mistake to ascribe the tragedy to religion rather than mental illness, it's interesting that authorities are applying special scrutiny to the intersection of mental illness and religious fervor: in combination, these things can indeed be a red flag. According to the Daily Telegraph, when social workers initially met with David Lovemore for assessment in 2009, "when he was asked what he would do if Faith or her sister got into difficulty he said he would pray first. He never said yes or no to calling a doctor." Additionally, Julia's aunt told authorities that her niece's "religious fervor" had distanced her from her family, whom she denounced as "heathens." In combination, these things cannot be dismissed as "the practice of religious beliefs" - at least not where children's welfare is concerned.

We Underestimated Danger To Baby Faith, Say Social Services [Cambridge News]
Milton Mother Who Killed Baby Detained Indefinitely [BBC]
Social Services 'Failed To Monitor Religious Fanatic Who Smothered Her Baby To Death' [Telegraph]

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

I am almost afraid to peruse the comments here. I have already read a few that have upset me on this first page.

As a former sufferer of post-partum psychosis (eleven years ago my PPD went unchecked and moved into PPP for a short while, e.g., had visions, heard voices, etc.), my heart hurts for every single actor in this horrible story. Oh. My. God.

Until you've woken up one morning and everything's mentally different, and you're no longer in control of your mind or your thoughts; you're hearing voices that are plain as day but you know aren't there, you're seeing things that cannot possibly be true, you cannot possibly know what this person went through to go through with such a horrible act.

I'm not saying forgive her, but I'm saying my heart hurts for her and for the child. This should never have happened; she was let down by a system that should have protected the child and the mother. (The same way I was let down and sent home alone after telling my OB/GYN I was feeling sucidal. Thank goodness my family member came over to be with me or I might not be here today all these years later.)

PPD/PPP is real, and these kinds of things are going to keep happening until we address the problem and put maternal health (physical AND mental) at the forefront of prenatal and postpartum care.

Damn. Tragic that this system failed that child and this family so horribly.