Gif via Judge Judy

How do you make a dispute between grown men over Yu-Gi-Oh! cards even more surreal? Give Amy Schumer a ringside seat to it.

As spotted by Boy Culture, the actor/comedian popped up in the audience of Judge Judy today. It was previously reported that she had visited the set in May, where she took a series of the exact kind of photos Instagram is made for:

Amy looked on expressively, sometimes with pronounced suspicion during the Yu-Gi-Oh! row, which kicked off with Judy proudly pronouncing how out of touch she is, as usual: “I know I come from another century, but I’ve never heard of those cards.”

It was weird! Here’s a clip:

During the first part of the case, before the commercial break, Judy said that she was very hungry a few times and announced they’d recess for lunch before resuming. When they came back from lunch, Schumer was nowhere to be found. Spooky.

On Instagram today, Schumer posted a screenshot of herself in the audience with the caption: “Hell yeah! You know I was in the audience on #judgejudy My sister and I sat in on the cases for the day because we love her!!!!!”