ps, i can't wait to find out how you can 'innoculate your daughter against [oral sex]." hopefully merck will come up with something.
and for the record, this woman he has in the first clip is a canadian documentary filmmaker/tabloid journalist. and the movie that she made to which she refers is about girls in CANADA. this fraud made the talkshow rounds a few months ago under the "oral sex is the new goodnight kiss" line and it was just as much bullshit then as it is now.
For all the people concerned that the girls aren't getting anything in return, I'll offer my own story.
When I was 15, my boyfriend was 17. He went down on my all the time, and I never returned the favor. I was scared to death of his penis! And he never made me feel guilty about it. I think he got a lot of pleasure from making me happy. And the one time we almost had sex, I said no after the condom was on and he was ready to go, and he didn't give me any attitude or hassle.
I wonder how he's doing now, and I bet his girlfriend or wife is a very satisfied. I was very grateful to have such a good guy be the one to introduce me to sexuality, and he certainly earned some good karma.
@portia_sue: That is awesome! More guys need to subscribe to that sort of maturity when in dating situations (hell, I'd love for men my age to be at that level). I cannot tell you the number of times I get caught up in some kissing and all of a sudden they try and pull a damned guilt trip on me because they got too horny. Nowadays, that's my sign to just end things ASAP and go the hell home, but when I was younger, I would actually bother arguing with them.
@wednesdayam: Yeah, I was really lucky with that one. He was also the first person I had ever kissed, and he taught me how very patiently. This sounds pervy, but I think he had a sense of..helping me bloom? That sounds weird. Like grooming, which it wasn't at all. He just knew that there was a difference in experience levels there, and respected me.
It's funny that you mention men our age, because what I miss most about being in high school, even once I had had sex, was the way that making out for hours was an acceptable thing. Now, it's like, "Oh, my dick is hard, let's do something about that! Right now." No. I would like to make out for hours again. I think it would make sex more exciting, too.
@portia_sue: I was like that with my high school girlfriend. I wasn't very much more experienced than her—she'd never kissed anyone and I'd kissed a little—but at the time it seemed like a massive gap. I knew I was gonna be her first everything and I worked really hard to make her comfortable, because I never wanted to be a bad memory. The first day that I got her relaxed enough to walk around the room naked, by pointing out that everyone looks silly with their clothes off, was a particular triumph.
If you are not still with her (probably not, since it seemed like you were speaking in the past tense) know that she probably remembers you with a lot of affection and gratitude for being so great.
You just made my day! It's so nice to hear from the good guys.
@portia_sue: I had a high school boyfriend like that. I was 14 and scared of the penis, so I never returned the favor. Of course he wanted sex, but I wasn't ready and he never made me feel bad, and he'd just go down on me for hours. I know 2 other girls who went out with him and they all said the same thing, "even if we were only hanging out for an hour, he'd still go down on me" and we all felt so lucky.
After barely seeing him for years we reconnected on his 18th birthday and I took his virginity. It just didn't seem right that a guy who'd done so much for the pleasure of girls never got much in return. But he was so big I almost cried, so I understand why we were all so scared of the penis.
Those stats, 55% and 54% of boys and girls 15-19 are involved in oral sex? That's it? Seeing that 18 is the oldest age of consent in the US, and most people are sexually active by then, why are only half having oral sex?
Sorry to be the annoying one in this comment section, but I do remember feeling pressured sexually in junior high and high school. I was very curious, but also very not ready. I thought I would be able to keep my dreamy boyfriend if I just did what he wanted. Maybe I'm just some freak of nature.
People have different reasons for doing what they do, and being honest about those reasons can be rare when it comes to things like sex. People might think they wont seem as sophisticated if they admit their alterior motives and not just express a love for the dick.
@razzle dazzle: I don't think you're being annoying, I think that what you're saying is actually the point of this post. Everyone deals with sexuality in their own time and their own way, and characterizing all girls as being whores or virgins doesn't help any person, male or female, navigate the complex world of adolescent sex. Open dialogue about the pressures that you felt would go much further towards alleviating those pressures than the "protect our girls" mantra ever, ever could.
Sigh, I just had a flashback to Oprah's mighty expose on teen sex trends where she taught the world about "tossed salads" and how "rainbow parties" work.
I am (embarassed to admit that I am a) member of a pregnancy message board and one of the women over there caught this episode and has everyone up in arms over the world they are bearing daughters into. I may no longer be welcome after posting a reminder that a) their sons will be receiving these blowjobs (and possibly selfishly not reciprocating) and b) I engaged in my first act of oral sex at 14, because I **gasp** wanted to, and I hope that my yet-to-be-born daughter one day feels in love and/or confident enough to explore that side of herself as well. I'm guessing that threats to call children's services are forthcoming.
@mesmerelda: Hahaha. I bet heads exploded. Did they ask you what your "DH" thinks about all of this? (I am also an embarrassed member of one of these boards.)
@awinoforever: "I engaged in my first act of oral sex at 14....I hope that my yet-to-be-born daughter one day feels in love and/or confident enough to explore that side of herself as well."
Couldn't be clearer. Wouldn't say that about my son. Wouldn't say that about my daughter. Wouldn't think of it either. Why 14? Why not 10? Because she's a baby, that's why. Just because my baby wants to have a cookie before dinner doesn't mean she should have one. Just because she stole one when I wasn't looking and did not explode doesn't mean she was educated about healthy eating, respect for herself and others (say, table manners), and diabetes.
I'm curious as to what other commentator's thoughts are on this point.
@hilikusopus: There is a huge difference between 10 and 14 and it is disingenuous to pretend otherwise. As long as it is with an age appropriate partner and not coerced, I do not think it shows a lack of respect for oneself. Or table manners? Pretending your teen children are babies who should not/will not be engaging in any type of sexual activity just does them a disservice in the long term. My parents' realistic and sex-positive approach taught me to love myself and make good choices.
@hilikusopus: You want to know what other commenters' thoughts are on this? Okay.
I sure am glad I'm not your kid. Personally, I think that equating teenagers being raised in a sex-positive environment with children stealing cookies from the cookie jar is pretty telling - and scary. I'm glad there are moms like mesmerelda out there to raise kids who have a better chance of not developing issues with sex, self image, etc.
@dokuchan: A couple things. We're not entirely in disagreement; you just happen to be making my points for me, under the belief that it supports mesmerelda's comment.
At the age of 14, there's a big difference four years in either direction. This is because the little person is a child. Children should not be having sex. A 10yo is a child. A 14yo is a child. I used "babies" to emphasize the fact that these are children we're talking about, not adults.
It's not about being in denial that a very young teenager has hormones or their own desires, or peer pressures; it's about having the wisdom of experience, that comes with life into adult, to steer that child into adulthood. I'd want my kid to be studying her school books, not how to give the best hand job on the block.
I do not suggest that the 14yo was disrespecting her parents or herself -- although that may have been the case; I argue that children need to be taught to respect themselves and (for boys in particular) to respect others, as well. Just because a 14yo, as mesmerelda puts it, "feels in love and/or confident enough" to have sex does not mean that she is putting herself in a smart or safe situation. Consider a boy who isn't satisfied with oral sex and coerces, not necessarily physically, the child to go even further, or to not use any protection. These are adult situations because of the serious consequences that can result from personal decisions. Children are not especially equiped to deal them. Not to mention the statistical likely that some of these girls would become pregnant, and be unable to pursue their education past the legally mandated age.
@hilikusopus: You missed the point. By a large margin. All she's saying is that she hopes her future children have the same positive experience with discovering their sexuality that she had. She's expressing hope that for them this will take place in a loving environment with a partner they trust, and that it's fun and something they do because they want to, not because they're feeling pressured. Age is not the point; some teens (girls in particular) are very mature by the time they reach 14 or 15. I know I was.
@Breamworthy: Maybe I miscommunicated my thoughts, but try not to take a metaphor so literally. It is a metaphor, after all. Maybe my second comment sheds some light on my view. I would never teach that sex is bad. I do think it's an inappropriate and an unnecessary activity for a 14yo though. Again, otherwise I'd have to believe that you're suggesting it's okay for a 10yo or younger to be having oral sex. What skills does a 14 yo have that a 10 yo doesn't, with respect to sex? Just because I don't want my 10 or 14 yo driving until they're a bit older doesn't mean that I'm teaching them that driving is bad. They're just too young, and that's okay. That's not shaming anyone, it's my view of parenting.
@hilikusopus: I do think it's an inappropriate and an unnecessary activity for a 14yo though. Again, otherwise I'd have to believe that you're suggesting it's okay for a 10yo or younger to be having oral sex.
What? So anyone who says that some 14-year-olds might be mature enough to engage in some sexual activities is automatically saying that 10-year-olds should be having oral sex? I don't follow this logic and I'm not sure I want to.
@argle-bargle? or fou-ferraw?: First, I want to say that I respect others' opinions on this -- that's why I asked. Maybe I missed mesmerelda's point, although Breamworthy seems to take the view the I, perhaps falsely, attributed to mesmerelda.
I would hope the same as you say. I just don't think it should start so soon. I appreciate that kids mature at different rates; but you were mature for what? For pregnancy? For rape? For VD? These issues are hard enough for an adult to deal with, that's why we protect our children from them.
@Breamworthy: I can tell you're upset. Forget my logic. See my comment to "argle-bargle? or fou-ferraw?" regarding maturity.
Listen, I'm not saying that a girl or boy who has oral sex or plain old sex at 14yo should be ashamed of theirself, or that they are bad children. I'm also not saying that their parents would be bad parents, either.
I'm 27; I don't have kids. Maybe, like theonlybirdleftintheaviary, it is partly the uncomfortable idea of my child engaging in sexual activity, but it also has to do with the way I was raised. I became sexually active at 16 with my girlfriend. We were in love, and as committed as high school sweethearts could have been. I was an extremely mature boy. But I also know now, as an adult, that I was in no way ready to deal with the responsibility of fatherhood and other realities at that age. I know that girls have the added, and constant, pressure of date rape. I have several ladyfriends who've went through such an awful experience because they perhaps thought they were mature girls at 14. My girlfriend at 16, herself, went through it at 14. I'd not want my future daughter to go through the same hardship, even if they're stronger women for it now.
@hilikusopus: If you look back at argle-bargle's excellent comment, she said that She's expressing hope that for them this will take place in a loving environment with a partner they trust, and that it's fun and something they do because they want to, not because they're feeling pressured. In other words, she's talking about helping girls avoid exactly the kind of exploitive situations you mention. I think the issue here may be that many of us believe that raising kids in a sex-positive environment is the best way to help them avoid painful situations like the ones your ladyfriends experienced.
@Breamworthy: I agree. I have to say, I do believe in raising children in a sex positive environment. Just not one that encourages sex, at the expense of responsible safe behavior. I don't believe any of the people who responded to my question would either, so maybe I have my answer now.
@Her Grace: Don't have kids because.....? What? You'd think I was proposing universal female circumcision. That's pretty mean, considering the conversation and resolution above. All it took was constructive dialogue, and it's clear to me that we're all on the same page. I was curious what your thoughts might be. You don't know me so I won't take it personally. Have a nice night, though.
@hilikusopus: @theonlybirdleftintheaviary: To explain myself a bit further...First off I was offended at the radical and fallacious correllary between a 10 year old and someone who is 14. To me it seemed the same as the "if we let the gays marry then bestiality is next" trope. There are tons of changes between 10 and 14, including development of secondary sex characteristics and puberty.
It's not surprising to me that the thought of your children having sex is icky, but to avoid dealing with it and talking to them about good choices and outcomes until way after they may be having sex does them a disservice and doesn't protect them at all. I was told where babies came from as soon as I asked (at age 4) via the fabulous picture book, and given a copy of Our Bodies Ourselves at age 12. I knew my parents had sex and enjoyed it, I was taught it was something fun/awesome/special you did with someone you loved. The religion I was raised in is pretty sex-positive and fairly liberal, which certainly helped.
And I think as a result of all that I was able to make good choices, and explore sexuality at a level I was comfortable with. My best friend's father died of AIDS before I ever had sex, so that really sold me on the necessity of condom usage. I didn't lose my virginity till I was almost 17, long after most of my friends, and it was a sweet clumsy experience with someone I really cared about. But I was certainly exploring other options long before then.
Educating me about sex (even when it made them feel uncomfortable) helped me avoid many of the pitfalls and pressures my female friends experienced..those friends who were told "don't have sex it's evil before marriage and that's all you need to know". It also has a lot to do with why I've never had a pregnancy scare or gnarly STDs. My dad certainly felt uncomfortable at the thought of me having sex, when my senior year boyfriend came to visit from boarding school for a week, my dad asked me not to have sex in the house because the thought of it freaked him out. And because he was so honest and upfront about his feelings, I didn't.
tl;dr summary : a 10 year old is not a 14 year old, pretending your children will never have oral sex/p-v sex puts them at much greater risk.
He is a buffoon. In 1978 when I was in 8th grade, blow jobs started for a few kids. By high school, some girls advised them as an "alternative" to sex. luckily, I was raised in very pro-sex, feminist household and schools. We were educated that whatever we were doing, it should be because we WANTED to, not to "keep" a boy, or stay a virgin.
Are these girls getting head too? I hope so!!
@hollygirl: I'm so fucking late to the party here, but when I was a teen, both girls AND guys gave head like nobody's business. My high school boyfriend went downtown ALL THE TIME- is that somehow not the norm? I hope to high heaven that these girls are getting head, too. I swear that was the best part of high school.
As long as we're not talking about freakishly low ages (under 15 I think it's a terrible idea), hey, better oral sex than actual unprotected sex that can get you pregnant or even sick. But they need to understand the right reasons first. It should always be because you want to enjoy yourself.
@ninles: Oral sex can get you sick. STDs such as herpes can be transfered that way.
I think the important thing is to make sure teens are armed with all of the information and are getting checked out by a physician on a regular basis and understand the responsibilities involved with a sexual relationship, rather than just hearing that it's bad and Dr. Phil says no!
@Bunsen Honeydew: Let's get off the 'everything is OK' bandwagon (as long as they're using protection). These girls are whoring themselves at
early ages when they should be building themselves up and gaining an education, learning to be strong, growing persons ,not consumers via sex pathways.
@1wish2fish: Gee, it's totally realistic that teenager girls won't want to experiment sexually and won't go behind your back, or do it anyway even when they are ignorant to their own safety. Have fun with that as a parent someday.
And why is developing and educating yourself exclusive to having sexual relationships? I had boyfriends in high school and college. I also graduated with honors and obtained a bachelor's degree in a field that interested me. It's not an either or. Get over yourself.
@kyleeCT: Yes, but how many of these cases were there in actuality?
Shows of this ilk love taking one or two extreme examples (which probably had a variety of factors leading into them, such as childhood abuse) and extrapolating them into "The kids these days!"
Notice how his "teen girls" category ranges from 14 to 19. Even sex alarmists usually understand that 18 makes you legal - and that includes giving head.
Hell, I've been sucking dick since I was 13. Oh cause guess what? I like doing it! I'm human, I'm sexual, it was fun. It was with boys I had a thing with and I always made the first move because I was horny as fuck and wanted it so badly.
Looking back I feel sorry for those boys. It was probably the toothiest head ever. Hah!
And this educator they featured really needs to pull her head out of her ass. Teens are bursting with hormones and bad judgment, and have been since we developed oppose-able thumbs, and yet these examples surprise you?
@Jack_Burton: i like how she pretends the time of the hustle was a simpler, purer time... uh wasn't disco known as a hotbed for sex and coke? middle schoolers and high schoolers of this generation didn't invent oral sex... its been around quite a while
@BuffyBot: My own mother was a self-proclaimed Disco Queen and I knew she had to be a super freak back in the day (my Dad was a musician 8 years older than her, of course she had to be a little wild!). It's part of why I think my Mom's so awesome! It was easier to be open with her about my sexy activities as a teen, although I was really nonchalant about everything, so I'm sure some of what came out of my mouth was shocking.
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
and for the record, this woman he has in the first clip is a canadian documentary filmmaker/tabloid journalist. and the movie that she made to which she refers is about girls in CANADA. this fraud made the talkshow rounds a few months ago under the "oral sex is the new goodnight kiss" line and it was just as much bullshit then as it is now.
10/08/09
10/08/09
When I was 15, my boyfriend was 17. He went down on my all the time, and I never returned the favor. I was scared to death of his penis! And he never made me feel guilty about it. I think he got a lot of pleasure from making me happy. And the one time we almost had sex, I said no after the condom was on and he was ready to go, and he didn't give me any attitude or hassle.
I wonder how he's doing now, and I bet his girlfriend or wife is a very satisfied. I was very grateful to have such a good guy be the one to introduce me to sexuality, and he certainly earned some good karma.
There are good guys out there!
10/08/09
10/08/09
It's funny that you mention men our age, because what I miss most about being in high school, even once I had had sex, was the way that making out for hours was an acceptable thing. Now, it's like, "Oh, my dick is hard, let's do something about that! Right now." No. I would like to make out for hours again. I think it would make sex more exciting, too.
10/08/09
Some guys get off on feeling like a nice guy.
10/08/09
If you are not still with her (probably not, since it seemed like you were speaking in the past tense) know that she probably remembers you with a lot of affection and gratitude for being so great.
You just made my day! It's so nice to hear from the good guys.
10/08/09
10/08/09
After barely seeing him for years we reconnected on his 18th birthday and I took his virginity. It just didn't seem right that a guy who'd done so much for the pleasure of girls never got much in return. But he was so big I almost cried, so I understand why we were all so scared of the penis.
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
People have different reasons for doing what they do, and being honest about those reasons can be rare when it comes to things like sex. People might think they wont seem as sophisticated if they admit their alterior motives and not just express a love for the dick.
Just sayin'.
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
Couldn't be clearer. Wouldn't say that about my son. Wouldn't say that about my daughter. Wouldn't think of it either. Why 14? Why not 10? Because she's a baby, that's why. Just because my baby wants to have a cookie before dinner doesn't mean she should have one. Just because she stole one when I wasn't looking and did not explode doesn't mean she was educated about healthy eating, respect for herself and others (say, table manners), and diabetes.
I'm curious as to what other commentator's thoughts are on this point.
10/08/09
10/08/09
I sure am glad I'm not your kid. Personally, I think that equating teenagers being raised in a sex-positive environment with children stealing cookies from the cookie jar is pretty telling - and scary. I'm glad there are moms like mesmerelda out there to raise kids who have a better chance of not developing issues with sex, self image, etc.
10/08/09
At the age of 14, there's a big difference four years in either direction. This is because the little person is a child. Children should not be having sex. A 10yo is a child. A 14yo is a child. I used "babies" to emphasize the fact that these are children we're talking about, not adults.
It's not about being in denial that a very young teenager has hormones or their own desires, or peer pressures; it's about having the wisdom of experience, that comes with life into adult, to steer that child into adulthood. I'd want my kid to be studying her school books, not how to give the best hand job on the block.
I do not suggest that the 14yo was disrespecting her parents or herself -- although that may have been the case; I argue that children need to be taught to respect themselves and (for boys in particular) to respect others, as well. Just because a 14yo, as mesmerelda puts it, "feels in love and/or confident enough" to have sex does not mean that she is putting herself in a smart or safe situation. Consider a boy who isn't satisfied with oral sex and coerces, not necessarily physically, the child to go even further, or to not use any protection. These are adult situations because of the serious consequences that can result from personal decisions. Children are not especially equiped to deal them. Not to mention the statistical likely that some of these girls would become pregnant, and be unable to pursue their education past the legally mandated age.
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
I do think it's an inappropriate and an unnecessary activity for a 14yo though. Again, otherwise I'd have to believe that you're suggesting it's okay for a 10yo or younger to be having oral sex.
What? So anyone who says that some 14-year-olds might be mature enough to engage in some sexual activities is automatically saying that 10-year-olds should be having oral sex? I don't follow this logic and I'm not sure I want to.
10/08/09
I would hope the same as you say. I just don't think it should start so soon. I appreciate that kids mature at different rates; but you were mature for what? For pregnancy? For rape? For VD? These issues are hard enough for an adult to deal with, that's why we protect our children from them.
10/08/09
Listen, I'm not saying that a girl or boy who has oral sex or plain old sex at 14yo should be ashamed of theirself, or that they are bad children. I'm also not saying that their parents would be bad parents, either.
I'm 27; I don't have kids. Maybe, like theonlybirdleftintheaviary, it is partly the uncomfortable idea of my child engaging in sexual activity, but it also has to do with the way I was raised. I became sexually active at 16 with my girlfriend. We were in love, and as committed as high school sweethearts could have been. I was an extremely mature boy. But I also know now, as an adult, that I was in no way ready to deal with the responsibility of fatherhood and other realities at that age. I know that girls have the added, and constant, pressure of date rape. I have several ladyfriends who've went through such an awful experience because they perhaps thought they were mature girls at 14. My girlfriend at 16, herself, went through it at 14. I'd not want my future daughter to go through the same hardship, even if they're stronger women for it now.
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/09/09
It's not surprising to me that the thought of your children having sex is icky, but to avoid dealing with it and talking to them about good choices and outcomes until way after they may be having sex does them a disservice and doesn't protect them at all. I was told where babies came from as soon as I asked (at age 4) via the fabulous picture book, and given a copy of Our Bodies Ourselves at age 12. I knew my parents had sex and enjoyed it, I was taught it was something fun/awesome/special you did with someone you loved. The religion I was raised in is pretty sex-positive and fairly liberal, which certainly helped.
And I think as a result of all that I was able to make good choices, and explore sexuality at a level I was comfortable with. My best friend's father died of AIDS before I ever had sex, so that really sold me on the necessity of condom usage. I didn't lose my virginity till I was almost 17, long after most of my friends, and it was a sweet clumsy experience with someone I really cared about. But I was certainly exploring other options long before then.
Educating me about sex (even when it made them feel uncomfortable) helped me avoid many of the pitfalls and pressures my female friends experienced..those friends who were told "don't have sex it's evil before marriage and that's all you need to know". It also has a lot to do with why I've never had a pregnancy scare or gnarly STDs. My dad certainly felt uncomfortable at the thought of me having sex, when my senior year boyfriend came to visit from boarding school for a week, my dad asked me not to have sex in the house because the thought of it freaked him out. And because he was so honest and upfront about his feelings, I didn't.
tl;dr summary : a 10 year old is not a 14 year old, pretending your children will never have oral sex/p-v sex puts them at much greater risk.
10/08/09
Are these girls getting head too? I hope so!!
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
I think the important thing is to make sure teens are armed with all of the information and are getting checked out by a physician on a regular basis and understand the responsibilities involved with a sexual relationship, rather than just hearing that it's bad and Dr. Phil says no!
10/08/09
early ages when they should be building themselves up and gaining an education, learning to be strong, growing persons ,not consumers via sex pathways.
10/08/09
And why is developing and educating yourself exclusive to having sexual relationships? I had boyfriends in high school and college. I also graduated with honors and obtained a bachelor's degree in a field that interested me. It's not an either or. Get over yourself.
10/08/09
Some of these 'teens' you all keep mentioning were only 10 or 11.
10/08/09
Shows of this ilk love taking one or two extreme examples (which probably had a variety of factors leading into them, such as childhood abuse) and extrapolating them into "The kids these days!"
10/08/09
10/08/09
Looking back I feel sorry for those boys. It was probably the toothiest head ever. Hah!
10/08/09
And this educator they featured really needs to pull her head out of her ass. Teens are bursting with hormones and bad judgment, and have been since we developed oppose-able thumbs, and yet these examples surprise you?
Tomorrow on Dr. Phil:
Aging: People Die From It
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09
10/08/09