Officials have been busy publicly disagreeing over just how serial killer-riddled Long Island is, but it seems any speculation may be premature. Several of the 10 victims recovered on South Shore beaches still haven't been identified, and now police are asking for the public's help. They've released a sketch of a… » 1/08/12 9:39pm 1/08/12 9:39pm

Authorities have confirmed that the remains found last week on Long Island's South Shore are those of 24-year-old New Jersey woman Shannan Gilbert. Though this is a major breakthrough in the case, officials are now openly clashing over what they believe happened to the 10 people whose bodies were found during the… » 12/19/11 10:10am 12/19/11 10:10am

Nineteen months after Shannan Gilbert disappeared, and exactly one year after the investigation into her case led to the discovery of the first of 10 bodies on Long Island, police say they've found her remains. This morning a body was located in a marsh near where Gilbert's belongings were found earlier this week, and… » 12/13/11 11:50pm 12/13/11 11:50pm

Earlier this week Long Island police were vague about what exactly they found during their continuing search of a marshy area near where Shannan Gilbert, a 24-year-old sex worker from New Jersey, was last spotted a year ago. Yesterday, detectives announced that they've recovered Gilbert's jeans, shoes, cell phone, and… » 12/08/11 11:45am 12/08/11 11:45am

Yesterday police found several items related to their investigation into the deaths of 10 people whose remains turned up on Long Island beaches. Previously, police said the murders were committed by multiple killers, but recently they announced they're now hunting for one serial killer. Police say they decided to… » 12/07/11 1:00pm 12/07/11 1:00pm

Today police said they've concluded that there aren't multiple serial killers roaming around Long Island. That seems like good news, but it actually means there's one prolific killer on the loose who's managed to evade police for more than a decade. » 12/01/11 12:17am 12/01/11 12:17am

In December, the bodies of four women were found near a stretch of highway on Long Island while police were looking for Shannan Gilbert, a missing New Jersey woman who worked as a prostitute. In the next few months, the remains of six more people turned up a few miles away. Yesterday police revealed that they still… » 9/21/11 10:15am 9/21/11 10:15am

Naturally, the New York Post has been a fount of ambigulously-sourced knowledge since the news broke that there are at least two active serial killers on Long Island. Previously, it was reported that the killers may be familiar with police techniques (or watch a lot of CSI), and now "sources familiar with the probe"… » 5/15/11 10:33pm 5/15/11 10:33pm

At a news conference today authorities identified another body found along Long Island's Ocean Parkway, and revealed that the 10 sets of human remains discovered since December were likely dumped by at least two killers, and probably more. » 5/09/11 11:38pm 5/09/11 11:38pm

In the past few months, investigators have found 10 bodies on the Long Island shore line and while at least four are believed to be the victims of one serial killer, the other six remains may not be connected to the case. » 4/14/11 12:39am 4/14/11 12:39am

On Monday, just hours after extending the search for a possible serial killer's victims from Suffolk to Nassau County, police found a skull and a bag that contained "upper and lower extremities." The remains were found two or three miles apart, and authorities haven't determined if they come from more than one person. » 4/12/11 12:19am 4/12/11 12:19am

The serial killer terrorizing Long Island has led to an unlikely support network. » 4/11/11 5:30pm 4/11/11 5:30pm

Tomorrow the search for more bodies tied to a possible serial killer on Long Island will move west, from Suffolk County to Nassau County. As the investigation continues, police say evidence suggests that the killer understands police techniques, and may even be a former officer. » 4/10/11 11:58pm 4/10/11 11:58pm

Today police found three more bodies in the dense brush of a Long Island beach, bringing the body count up to eight. The finding supports the suspicion that the murders are the work of a serial killer, and could make this the most prolific case in the New York area since Joel Rifkin was caught in 1993, according to… » 4/04/11 10:44pm 4/04/11 10:44pm