Robin McKinley's reimaginings ftw. Everything else pales for me. She also writes original fairy tales, usually as novella-length pieces; they can be found in "A Knot in the Grain and other stories" and "The Door in the Hedge" books. #fairytales
I have a paperback collection of short stories that are all classic fairy tales told with a strange twist or from an alternate point of view. I forget the name of it, but I love every single story.
Little Red Riding Hood lives in a futuristic wasteland ruled by man-eating clams, Snow White's witch works at an abattoir until she becomes obsessed with beauty pageants...you get the idea.
My favorite though? Cinderella, told from the point of view of Prince Charming, who has a foot fetish and a crush on his (male) tutor. #fairytales
I'd put a word in for Marina Warner's From the Beast to the Blonde, too. Also, Maria Tatar has a book just focused on Bluebeard that I love. Oh, and the Terri Windling fairy tale series--I don't know if there are any still in development, but those are some AMAZING books. There are some great stories and essays in the collection The Armless Maiden, too. #fairytales
Hey Anna, I used to LOVE Andrew Lang's fairy books (i had the Red One). The story that most jumps out at me (the title of which escapes me) is the one about the princess who is kept in a tower and not allowed to see any men, until she catches sight of an envoy/diplomat guy through a hole in the tower and becomes infatuated with him. She runs away with him to an island with no food or water, and when she finds food/water she gives it to him, and he eats it all without offering any to her, and basically is a total jerk. So she realizes he is a jerk, and ends up marrying the prince instead.
I wish I could remember the title. Darn! #fairytales
I have always been an enormous fanatic of fairy tales and mythology and most of what I write in my career use these stories for a base.
Do yourself a favor and check out Monty Python's Terry Jones and his fairy tale books. I was given this book on my 8th birthday and have loved its wit and wisdom ever since. And ATTENTION TEAM CAKE! There is a story about a cake horse that comes alive! Mmmm Mr. Edible.
My sister and I loved the Faerie Tale Theatre stories growing up. Except, the witch in "Hansel and Gretel" scared me like nothing else ever has. My sister used to have to physically restrain me in order to get me through the whole story. She found it on VHS a few years ago and gave it to me, and I still have a hard time getting through it. She is the scariest witch ever. #fairytales
@SisterSasquatch: Ha, as another older sister I must side with your big sis on the forced viewing issue. I don't recall ever tying my brother to a chair so we could watch the end of something, but I wish I had. I've never seen ET fly away on his bicycle because of my brother. #fairytales
I'd just like to say, it's very nice to read an article about fairy tales that doesn't sensationalise the issue. So much discussion of this topic is unnecessarily hysterical -- rather like the people who want to ban kids from wearing scary Halloween costumes.
As a kid I was allowed/encouraged to read the darker versions of fairy tales for myself, and even though I was and am pretty squeamish when it comes to realistic horror, I was never traumatised by a fairy tale. #fairytales
I loved Shelley Duvall's Faerie Tale Theatre as a kid- I remember seeing the Rumpelstiltskin one many, many times. I watched a couple episodes recently on Netflix. I've never realized how weird they were, and how many incredibly famous people guest starred to play even the smallest part. #fairytales
@NellMood: These were awesome. My favorite was Hansel and Gretel, starring Ricky Schroeder as Hansel and Joan Collins as the evil stepmother. My younger sister was so terrified of this one that I once tied her to a chair with a jump rope to keep her in the room.
I was a fan of Rapunzel in this series too. #fairytales
@NellMood: I have been trying to find these on DVD for ages! As kids, we had the vhs of all of them, I have no idea what happened... they were so freaking fantastic! #fairytales
@NellMood: I loved the series--it was my absolutely favorite thing to get when I was sick. I've watched a few as an adult, and it's amazing to see the cameos and the inside jokes! (One of my best friends from college and I took a class about fairy tales and watched the Faerie Tale Theater Beauty and the Beast (with Susan Sarandon and Klaus Kinski!) right after seeing the Jean Cocteau film, and there are some straight up references there. #fairytales
@alula: Oh, interesting! I don't remember Beauty and the Beast at all- I'll have to watch that one again! I watched the Nightingale episode this summer and the cameos were incredible- Mick Jagger, Anjelica Huston, Barbara Hershey- every other person was someone amazing. #fairytales
Anna, are you sure about the demon radish? Cuz I remember the FTT Rapunzel (Jeff Bridges was the Prince and I remember blood coming out of his eyes after he fell from the tower into the brier bush) and I don't remember any screaming radishes... #fairytales
@NellMood: HAHA- I seriously did not remember that at all so I don't know if it scared me when I was little but it just made me bust out laughing now! #fairytales
@librariesare4lovers: Maybe you repressed the terrible, terrible memory. I just watched the clip where the Jeff Bridges falls and I have to say, I forgot how creepy that was. What a bizarre/fabulous show.
@Uncommon Whore: Nope, it's real, but I still consider myself awesome. You can find it in the Oxford Book of Modern Fairy Tales. It is by Jeanne Carter. #fairytales
I'm partial to Vladimir Propp's analysis of Russian Folk Tales: [en.wikipedia.org]
It's interesting how all the best stories - films, books, TV series - pretty much conform to the same narrative elements and structure as folk tales, and that this is universal. It's been hard-wired into us since humans first started communicating.
My favorite modern take on them is Angela Carter's The Bloody Chamber - feminist, erotic and dark.
NB. The Folio Society is currently publishing beautiful new editions of Andrew Lang's famous Victorian rainbow fairy books: [www.foliosociety.com]
@Diziet_Sma: While I dig Propp, I haven't tested ye olde structuralismo against Oscar Wilde's fairy tales. Have you ever encountered them? While I think they conform somewhat, there's no discernible moral. At all. #fairytales
@Confabulatia: Well, Propp was a formalist, rather than a structuralist. I'm not familiar enough with Wilde's stories to answer your question, although the two I remember - The Happy Prince and The Selfish Giant - are extremely moral, aren't they? About giving up wealth (precious jewels) to help others, caring and sharing etc? #fairytales
@Diziet_Sma: I have Burning Your Boats, which is all of her short stories (inlcuding The Bloody Chamber), and I basically recommend it to everyone I know every time I see them. God, Angela Carter is awesome. #fairytales
Browsing books online today I came across an old favorite fairy tale that I haven't read in ages: East of the Sun and West of the Moon. I wish I could remember the whole story better, but it seemed pretty kickass to me as a little girl that the heroine was the one going off to rescue the prince.
Also, the illustrations were beautiful.
Of course now I find out that some of the interpretations include this: "The transformation of the man into a beast has often been interpreted to signify a young woman's revulsion from sexual activity." So um, yeah.
@Ms.Moneypenny: Oh, I loved that one! I remember that my dad bought that one for me. I don't really remember how it went either, but the name is so magical. #fairytales
@sallysparrow: I've been looking at used copies online all day. I can't believe how much they're going for. I loved Mercer Mayer's illustrations. #fairytales
@Ms.Moneypenny: so pricey! I'll have to see if I can dig up my old copy from my parents. The dust jacket is long gone though. I especially remember the illustration of the salamander in the fire pit, he had such a sweet face. #fairytales
I hate my reaction to hearing about arty movies that contain very shocking, violent scenes, because it really makes me want to watch them, and yet because I have the constitution of a bowl of cherry Jell-O, I know I never will. This list so far includes Irreversible, In the Realm of the Senses, Salo and a few others I'm not recalling because it's early. I'd really like to be able to make up my own mind about these things, but I know I can't deal with some of the scenes I've heard about in movies like this. #antichrist
@whynotshesaid: For what it's worth, I think you could handle "In the Realm of the Senses," with little trouble. It's not that disturbing - just emotionally intense. And, if I recall correctly, there's only one scene with the potential to really disturb, and what's happened is not shown but merley alluded to. It's been years since I've seen it, though. #antichrist
OK, I'm probably never going to watch this movie because I don't have the nerves to watch movies with this amount of graphic mutilation.
That being said, I did read a synopsis. And from that, I can conclude that either the synopsis did not do the film justice, or that it's the kind of film I wouldn't be able to appreciate even if I did manage to watch it.
I guess there is a vaguely supernatural element present, but the wife's motivations sound dodgy. One minute she's a grieving mother, then she suddenly decides to start maiming the nearest man because of some things she was reading on gynocide? Except then she stops, and helps him. Then she's crazy again and mutilates herself. Then later she attacks the husband again, then he kills her.
I recognize that I'm summarizing the events of like 90 minutes into a single paragraph, but the characters sound insane and unbelievable. Obviously I haven't seen the film, and apparently the acting is top notch, but the underlying script seems so incoherent that even with great acting, I can't imagine watching the movie and thinking anything other than "What the fuck, this is insane and random."
Or am I looking at this all wrong, and it's supposed to be the sort of very artistic film where the specifics about the plot and character are almost meaningless, and all that matters is the emotional impression you get from scene to scene?
I suppose that's it, but it still sounds lame. The nonviolent scenes don't sound amazing either. They go to a forest named Eden (Biblical allegory or something, get it?). The husband sees a deer with a stillborn young (symbolism or something, get it?).
I'm not trying to dismiss the movie out of hand having never seen it, I just want to know if someone can confirm my idea of what it must be like. Specifically, it sounds like one of those movies where 99% of its value comes from how well the scenes are shot and how solid the acting is, because on paper, as a story, it sounds utterly retarded. #antichrist
@nworobes: This film works very well as a fable. Von Trier is pretty much a fabulist--if you look at this body of work, it's plenty obvious he's not a realist.
Revisit the definition of "fable" and then you'll see how the elements you quibble about make perfect sense in a fable context.
But I'm not sure why you'd do that, since you don't want to see the movie anyway. #antichrist
@snugbug: Thanks, that helps somewhat. I do want to stress that my previous post wasn't trying to outright say the movie was terrible, but I was definitely failing to understand in what framework the events of the movie fit into, because at face value they seem rather incoherent.
Thinking of it as a fable does help, so thanks for pointing that out. #antichrist
@nworobes: You can certainly think of it as a fable - there are fabulous aspects to it (talking animals, the end scene) - but I don't see the problem with viewing the narrative 'straight', so to speak. Here's my take, for what it's worth:
****SPOILER ALERT*****
In the opening scenes, Gainsbourg and Dafoe are fucking passionately, while their toddler, aged about 2, wakes up and toddles over to an open window, falling 5 floors to his death. They are stricken with grief, naturally. Being a logical, scientific man, he recovers and wants to move forward with life; but she cannot, spending weeks in hospital. She cannot get over her guilt, about sex, about his death, about herself as a failed mother, etc. He is a psychiatrist, and is convinced that he can help her recover. He persuades her to leave hospital and starts psychoanalyzing her, which she resists. He wants to find her deepest fear, and she says 'the woods', meaning their cabin which is in a wood. He takes her there and continues to force her analysis, eventually driving her nutso. Obviously there are many more aspects of the film, but that, in effect, is the plot.
In my opinion, this is actually damning of MEN, and their inability to listen or give credence to the female perspective, and their arrogant belief that they are always right and always have a solution for everything. In fact, I've yet to hear a detailed analysis of exactly WHAT about THIS film IS so misogynist, living as we do in this ocean of misogyny that we call mainstream culture. Can anybody help? #antichrist
@Diziet_Sma: Unfortunately I can't help as I haven't seen the movie, but I too wonder what is so misogynist about this movie. This post talks about it being so, but never really explains why. #antichrist
@Kakapo: Okay... but it also mentions misogyny specifically, as does a previous post on this film. That's what I'm asking about, not misanthropy. #antichrist
@Diziet_Sma: I haven't seen the movie, either, but I have seen a few of his other films that have also been labelled misogynist. I didn't agree with it then, and I have a feeling I wouldn't here, because, for one reason (as one reviewer put it): look at the male characters in his movies.
Where I'm from, media tends to have a very moralistic view on drugs. Any movie, in which drugs play any sort of part, is thus labelled 'drug-romanticising', without any concern as to how they're portrayed, or that the movie might actually portray a real problem, that won't just go away if you ignore it. Routinely calling von Trier's movies misogynist just because they deal with women in terrible situations seems like an example of the same type of thinking.
-- Having said that, I am sure there could be very good arguments for why this movie is mysogynist... #antichrist
10/31/09
10/30/09
Little Red Riding Hood lives in a futuristic wasteland ruled by man-eating clams, Snow White's witch works at an abattoir until she becomes obsessed with beauty pageants...you get the idea.
My favorite though? Cinderella, told from the point of view of Prince Charming, who has a foot fetish and a crush on his (male) tutor. #fairytales
10/30/09
10/31/09
10/30/09
I wish I could remember the title. Darn! #fairytales
10/30/09
I have always been an enormous fanatic of fairy tales and mythology and most of what I write in my career use these stories for a base.
Do yourself a favor and check out Monty Python's Terry Jones and his fairy tale books. I was given this book on my 8th birthday and have loved its wit and wisdom ever since. And ATTENTION TEAM CAKE! There is a story about a cake horse that comes alive! Mmmm Mr. Edible.
[www.amazon.com] #fairytales
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
As a kid I was allowed/encouraged to read the darker versions of fairy tales for myself, and even though I was and am pretty squeamish when it comes to realistic horror, I was never traumatised by a fairy tale. #fairytales
10/30/09
10/30/09
I was a fan of Rapunzel in this series too. #fairytales
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
@TiniDarling: That sounds like a pretty bad combination! #fairytales
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
@Uncommon Whore: Nope, it's real, but I still consider myself awesome. You can find it in the Oxford Book of Modern Fairy Tales. It is by Jeanne Carter. #fairytales
10/30/09
It's interesting how all the best stories - films, books, TV series - pretty much conform to the same narrative elements and structure as folk tales, and that this is universal. It's been hard-wired into us since humans first started communicating.
My favorite modern take on them is Angela Carter's The Bloody Chamber - feminist, erotic and dark.
NB. The Folio Society is currently publishing beautiful new editions of Andrew Lang's famous Victorian rainbow fairy books: [www.foliosociety.com]
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
Also, the illustrations were beautiful.
Of course now I find out that some of the interpretations include this: "The transformation of the man into a beast has often been interpreted to signify a young woman's revulsion from sexual activity." So um, yeah.
10/30/09
10/30/09
@Ms.Moneypenny: This is the version I had which is, I guess, a variation on the Norwegian(?) fairy tale. #fairytales
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
10/30/09
Perv. #fairytales
10/27/09
10/28/09
10/27/09
That being said, I did read a synopsis. And from that, I can conclude that either the synopsis did not do the film justice, or that it's the kind of film I wouldn't be able to appreciate even if I did manage to watch it.
I guess there is a vaguely supernatural element present, but the wife's motivations sound dodgy. One minute she's a grieving mother, then she suddenly decides to start maiming the nearest man because of some things she was reading on gynocide? Except then she stops, and helps him. Then she's crazy again and mutilates herself. Then later she attacks the husband again, then he kills her.
I recognize that I'm summarizing the events of like 90 minutes into a single paragraph, but the characters sound insane and unbelievable. Obviously I haven't seen the film, and apparently the acting is top notch, but the underlying script seems so incoherent that even with great acting, I can't imagine watching the movie and thinking anything other than "What the fuck, this is insane and random."
Or am I looking at this all wrong, and it's supposed to be the sort of very artistic film where the specifics about the plot and character are almost meaningless, and all that matters is the emotional impression you get from scene to scene?
I suppose that's it, but it still sounds lame. The nonviolent scenes don't sound amazing either. They go to a forest named Eden (Biblical allegory or something, get it?). The husband sees a deer with a stillborn young (symbolism or something, get it?).
I'm not trying to dismiss the movie out of hand having never seen it, I just want to know if someone can confirm my idea of what it must be like. Specifically, it sounds like one of those movies where 99% of its value comes from how well the scenes are shot and how solid the acting is, because on paper, as a story, it sounds utterly retarded. #antichrist
10/27/09
Revisit the definition of "fable" and then you'll see how the elements you quibble about make perfect sense in a fable context.
But I'm not sure why you'd do that, since you don't want to see the movie anyway. #antichrist
10/27/09
Thinking of it as a fable does help, so thanks for pointing that out. #antichrist
10/27/09
****SPOILER ALERT*****
In the opening scenes, Gainsbourg and Dafoe are fucking passionately, while their toddler, aged about 2, wakes up and toddles over to an open window, falling 5 floors to his death. They are stricken with grief, naturally. Being a logical, scientific man, he recovers and wants to move forward with life; but she cannot, spending weeks in hospital. She cannot get over her guilt, about sex, about his death, about herself as a failed mother, etc. He is a psychiatrist, and is convinced that he can help her recover. He persuades her to leave hospital and starts psychoanalyzing her, which she resists. He wants to find her deepest fear, and she says 'the woods', meaning their cabin which is in a wood. He takes her there and continues to force her analysis, eventually driving her nutso. Obviously there are many more aspects of the film, but that, in effect, is the plot.
In my opinion, this is actually damning of MEN, and their inability to listen or give credence to the female perspective, and their arrogant belief that they are always right and always have a solution for everything. In fact, I've yet to hear a detailed analysis of exactly WHAT about THIS film IS so misogynist, living as we do in this ocean of misogyny that we call mainstream culture. Can anybody help? #antichrist
10/27/09
10/28/09
10/28/09
10/28/09
Where I'm from, media tends to have a very moralistic view on drugs. Any movie, in which drugs play any sort of part, is thus labelled 'drug-romanticising', without any concern as to how they're portrayed, or that the movie might actually portray a real problem, that won't just go away if you ignore it. Routinely calling von Trier's movies misogynist just because they deal with women in terrible situations seems like an example of the same type of thinking.
-- Having said that, I am sure there could be very good arguments for why this movie is mysogynist... #antichrist