The ren faire circuit is VASTLY different from slutoween. The people who really get into it, who work on their costumes or pay people a LOT of money to do it for them, are historical recreationists. They can tell you the history of their costume for 400 years and the specific town the stylea nd pattern came from. they are not picking up Sexy Bar Maid in a plastic bag at Target on their way to the fair. turn you "I'm so opressed!" ray somewhere else.
Also, btw? The part about being larger breasted is true. The fashions of today do not make large breasted women look attracted, and subsequently, we don't fel attractive. We feel fat, ugly, old, matronly. A nice boustier that lifts your burden and cinches your waist, makes you look like a Caravaggio painting, can definitely make you feel like a real woman. #renfaire
I am not sure this is the experience of all Ren Faire participants. My grandma was the president of an encampment in California for more than 20 years, and I took part in quite a few of them as a teenager. Sure, some of the women used the faires as an excuse to let their boobs hang out, but just as many of them - myself included - used them as an opportunity to wield swords and paint ourselves blue like Picts and Celtic warrior goddesses.
And also, as I recall, the objectification went two ways, especially as lot of the men didn't bother to wear anything under their kilts and many of the women had no problem making sure the men were "historically correct," so to speak. #renfaire
Hah, that reminds me of when I went in 5th grade for school and I was sitting down eating with my dad and "the town drunk" came by singing "Thank heaven for little girls" and when he got to the "for little girls get bigger everyday" he made the hand motion of boobs over his chest. It was super creepy and highly inappropriate. And in front of my dad too! Ridiculous. I shoulda kicked that drunken bastard in the nuts. #renfaire
I think the Post's article does Ren Fests somewhat of a disservice.
One of my first "adult"-type memories was attending a Ren Fest with my mother and a friend; I believe I was about 13. My early teens were not kind to me and I was the most gangly, six-foot-tall, awkward and be-pimpled teen I knew.
A Ren Fest actor who was playing a visiting Spanish lord showered me with attention- he gave me a rose and told a large group of gathered Faire attendees that I was beautiful. It was the first time since puberty decided to shit all over me that someone of the opposite sex had told me I was attractive; his single comment gave me hope that my pubescent state would be a passing phase.
Thinking back on that experience, I'm sure that I could pick it apart and think how utterly creepy it was for some 40 year old dude in a frilly shirt and leather vest to be saying anything to a 13 year old that even bordered on innuendo. But in my mind, he did me a great kindness.
For all the bad that Ren Fests- the groping, the titties, the bawdy drinking- there is a good time to be had for those that enjoy it. I haven't been to many Ren Fests since, but I certainly look back on that experience fondly.
@murraymk: I ran into a couple of men like that at Ren faires when I was about 14 or 15. Sure, objectively it could have been seen as creepy, but at the time, it did amazing things for my self-esteem. Plus, the guys never tried to grope or anything - they were just flirtatious. It was actually really nice. #renfaire
I used to go to Ren. Faires, but I stopped after I realized how hostile they were to non-gender-conforming people. I did not care to be called "my lady" constantly, nor did I want to be led around like a show pony because I was biologically female. I got tired of being harassed every time I stepped into a shop to look at an interesting item.
I especially didn't appreciate 3 merchants cornering me until I acknowledged that I was female. That wasn't too much fun.
I felt like people were constantly up in my face about how I was presenting (I wasn't wearing a costume, mostly because I wanted to look as "normal" as possible and have people assume I wasn't part of the event, therefore assume I wouldn't be in on the jokes), asking me questions about what kind of person I was and why didn't I want some random asshole kissing my hand? Boundaries were absolutely not respected in the three years I went. I don't think I'd ever really want to go again, despite how much fun other people have. They don't like people who don't look the right way is my experience. Others may differ, though.
By the way, pickle guy, if you ever read this, you are the highlight of the faire, because you are always friendly and give me giant pickles for one dollar. Also, you have never made me feel bad about how I look, and just let me get a pickle in peace. You are my favorite. #renfaire
@BytheSea: I am not sure as to whether or not I will transition, or how exactly I feel about my gender. It's a fairly complex thing to parse out, so I guess for ease of explanation, ftm is closest, but it implies a lot more than what's actually happening. #renfaire
@BytheSea: As of now, I'm at a standstill. I can either stay as I am, or I can transition. I have decided, mostly for safety reasons, not to. I fear violence that I see visited upon people like myself. But I am afraid of what will happen to me if I don't do something about this - a friend of mine just killed herself last week, her journals citing that it was too painful to live with. It's an ongoing thing; therapy is too expensive. I'd like to have more friends, but it seems that the people I run into are not... forgiving of my somewhat unusual appearance, so I've had a hard time making friends at university. At my old university, I made friends very easily - I was outgoing and sociable, but after moving here, you might as well have popped that like a balloon. Once I graduate, I hope that I can move somewhere a little less conservative and I hope that works out. #renfaire
@boxspelunker: I know what you mean, I'm not in a good town to be gay, either.
Not every transman transitions medically. the procedures are stupidly ineffective and it's a lot of hassle for little reward. I know more transmen than transwomen who were satisfied with their biologically female bodies. Is there a GLISBA or gay-straight alliance at your school? you need something.
If you want to take this offlist, I'm ofnone2150 on AIM or nardo218 on yahoo.
Also, what about the connection between men who want to return to (even for just a weekend) a time period in which women were chattel and the likelihood that said men will harass a nearby "wench"? #renfaire
In a recent issue of my university's employee newsletter, a coworker was profiled and shared her love of Ren Faires, and her penchant for dressing up as a pirate wench with a pet Griffon on her off time. More power to her, but to me it seemed a little bit like informing all your colleagues that you're a dominatrix-- not something you just generally share in the employee newsletter. #renfaire
@funnyface: By the way, there's a well-established connection between serious Renfaire geeks, BDSM, and Trekkies, so maybe not so far off the mark. Watch out if she ever shows up for Casual Friday with Spock ears. #renfaire
You know...serious cleavage like you'll see on most "wenches" isn't accurate. You wore a corset/bodice for support, but you also wore several other layers of clothing, including a shift/chemise underneath (which should be long-sleeved and worn on your damn shoulders!) and a partlet, which was basically a bit of fabric (I've seen triangular and square, and while I understand that square is more period, I can't for the life of me make it work) tucked in to the bodice to shield the girls from the sun and prying eyes. The "enormous cleavage" silhouette is much more Victorian than it is Renaissance; the proper silhouette is much closer to a cone, with a flat front rather than the hourglass shape that many people think of when they think of corsets.
Besides which, boning isn't accurate to most characters. Obviously some characters--kissing wenches, courtesans, and other women of ill repute spring to mind--may require cleavage, depending on the actor's vision for that character, and noble ladies would have boned corsets (also: a busk, which is basically a flat piece of wood or something that goes in the front of your bodice) to maintain the desired shape, but peasant ladies were working ladies; they couldn't afford boning and they sure as hell couldn't work in it.
I've been a performer for six years, since I was 19. Before that, I was a regular patron with my family from the time I was 8. My experience with the ren faire is that it's fundamentally no different than going to a football game. The costumes are different, but it's more or less the same concept: bunch of people getting together to be silly. There will always be the drunk assholes who don't have any concept of personal space. I've felt safe and unsafe in both places, but honestly, I feel safer at a ren faire. Is that because I'm used to the environment? Perhaps. But it's also less constrained; while a sporting event has assigned seating, at a ren fest I can pretty much go wherever I want. Plus, I'm more likely to be armed.
I have definitely met my share of assholes through faire, but I've also made some of the best, non-asshole friends I've ever had. I also met mr. biscuit there. :D It takes all kinds, basically. In my experience, the amazing, talented, funny, friendly people (typically performers, but some patrons as well) you'll find outweigh the lecherous asshats. They may not always outnumber them, but I do feel they do outweigh them. And obviously all this varies wildly from day to day, as well as from faire to faire. We're not talking about some monolithic entity called The Renaissance Faire (TM); each festival (or at the most two or three) is individually owned and managed, with its own specific goals, talent pool, and clientele. About the only thing they share is the aspect of outdoor, live, interactive performance, which is not, by its nature, going to be anything near safe space.
On a more personal note: as an actor, I love the renaissance festival with all the love in my jaded little heart. It's such a pure state of performance; for 7-8 hours a day I'm not just pretending to be someone else, I am someone else. I get to decide pretty much everything about that character: costume, mannerisms, family history, personality, you name it. Plus, I get paid to play with people. I don't think I'll ever go back to "legit" theatre. #renfaire
I've attended a few Ren Faires in California's Marin County where hippies and Deadheads started it all, and it was presented as a "pleasure faire" where historical accuracy was sacrified for the love of partying, New Age book hawking, boozing, pot smoking, Monty Python Holy Grail worshipping, and melodramatic acting (the traditional knight joust became a WWF match). Quite a women loved the wench schtick where they stuck roses and even grapes between their breasts, and smiled whenever people whistled at them. The only sight that discomforted me was when peasants literally planted their faces in the dirt to grovel at the feet of smug princesses. #renfaire
As a Wench, yes, a card-carrying member of the International Wenches Guild, I have to say that neither this article, nor the Washington Post article referenced provide much of a truly multi-sided, complete view of Faire, or Wenches.
I've been going to faire at least once a year for almost 10 years. In the early years, I went in my 'mundanes', then graduated to clumsy attempts to use street clothes to resemble periodish costuming. This Spring I completed my fourth season as a passholder, and my third as a playtron. I don't dress up for attention or anything else. I dress up because I like being part of the magic that is found in the village, whether it is my home village, or one of several that I visit on a regular basis. That being said, wench, and Wench are not necessarily interchangable terms. You never know when the woman with whom you are speaking may be a member of the guild. At my home faire, guild members include cast members in royal, court, and merchant classes, as well as tavern wenches, bellydancers, gypsies, and much more.
At the faires I frequent, guild members are relatively closely knit groups who, while we may not always agree with each other, or even particularly want to spend a lot of time together, we know that we have a support system and that we can count on others as necessary, should we get inappropriate attention or have other issues that warrant attention.
Rennies are MUCH more than hedonistic, shallow, slutty, attention-seeking geeks. Wenches are much more than "fat girls" in bodices with uber-cleavage. Doctors, nurses, computer-savvy folks, teachers, lawyers, students, law enforcement personnel, business owners, musicians, artists, secretaries, construction workers, military personnel, electricians, children, adults, state & municipal employees are all among the people you might encounter at faire, in a period persona, or not.
My faire outfit is pretty modest; just a pretty chemise and a green ladies' surcoat, but I have to admit that I enjoy going and seeing all the costumes in all their glory - I don't mind the fantasy aspect because the faire is all about fantasy.
Insofar as the ladies (and I'd throw in the men here, too) being larger than the average population - I call bullshit. I think larger people are just more visible because faire culture doesn't encourage people who aren't a size 4 to be invisible. I seriously cannot criticize an environment where people of ALL sizes are straight up accepted. #renfaire
I deeply offended ren faire regulars a few years ago by going as a Plague victim - complete with wheelbarrow in which to be pushed around by my cousin, a very embarassed and earnest ren-fan. My ankle was sprained, so I thought that I was to be congratulated on my inventive and non-ambultaory costume. Not so, apparently.
I guess the take-home lesson here is "More boob! Less bubo." #renfaire
I adore the Texas Ren Fest, but I don't think I'd ever dress as a "wench." To me, it's all about fantasy, and there is no fantasy in having a bunch of dirty old men ogle at my ta-tas. I can experience that by wearing a low-cut blouse and walking around my neighborhood. I don't like to be seen as sexy, and I sure as hell don't like to be objectified, which is something that happens a lot(in jest or not) at Ren Faires.
I prefer to go as some type of noblewoman or fantasy creature, because it allows me to be something that I can't be anywhere else. This year I happen to be going as an elf noble, and the only thing I want anyone to stare at is my gorgeous gown. #renfaire
@theizz: Here's what frustrating to me about the Ren fest.... the workers take their job too seriously, and its encouraged. As in, I was walking around with regular clothes on, with my boyfriend at the time, and a worker, pretty much a male wench, gets in my face and harasses me trying to give me a kiss.
I would like to say this has only happened the once, but its happened numerous times. I have no wish for some stranger to get all up in my personal bubble. Its disgusting.
And that's not even going into the female wenches and how they act towards the men... creeps my husband out... which I can understand b/c its just as disgusting as when the men do it. #renfaire
@theizz: The Washington Post wrote the expose, not Jezebel. And I see no criticism whatsoever of Ren Faires in this post. Just some insight into the pluses and minuses of being able to participate in a fantasy, and the varying experiences (some good, some not so good) of those who have participated in the Faires. #renfaire
@formergr: Perhaps I should be directing my comments more at The Washington Post. And I do acknowledge that the perspective of women who find Ren fair fun and empowering is represented. Still, Jezebel has reposted the story and seems to conditionally support it. #renfaire
@Kat@Work: This is part of my point. This behavior by the employees is exactly what Ren fair advertises. The employees are performers and professionals. It is an act. No one is in danger any more than members of the audience who are pulled onstage as part of Blue Man Group and end up covered in paint. If you don't want to get paint on you, don't go to Blue Man Group. If you don't want to listen to the dirty jokes, see pushed up boobs, or be flirted with, don't go to Ren Fair. #renfaire
@theizz: I would think sexual harassment might fall outside of the "well, you know what you're getting into" thing. A few dirty jokes, all right. Flirting, fine. Trying to force someone into kissing you in "fun"? Sounds kinda terrifying to me. I realize I have huuuuge boundary issues, but that is the kind of advertising that would make me avoid these events - despite me being very interested in attending. I should not have to expect to be physically harassed for going to an event. #renfaire
10/27/09
The ren faire circuit is VASTLY different from slutoween. The people who really get into it, who work on their costumes or pay people a LOT of money to do it for them, are historical recreationists. They can tell you the history of their costume for 400 years and the specific town the stylea nd pattern came from. they are not picking up Sexy Bar Maid in a plastic bag at Target on their way to the fair. turn you "I'm so opressed!" ray somewhere else.
Also, btw? The part about being larger breasted is true. The fashions of today do not make large breasted women look attracted, and subsequently, we don't fel attractive. We feel fat, ugly, old, matronly. A nice boustier that lifts your burden and cinches your waist, makes you look like a Caravaggio painting, can definitely make you feel like a real woman. #renfaire
10/26/09
And also, as I recall, the objectification went two ways, especially as lot of the men didn't bother to wear anything under their kilts and many of the women had no problem making sure the men were "historically correct," so to speak. #renfaire
10/26/09
10/26/09
One of my first "adult"-type memories was attending a Ren Fest with my mother and a friend; I believe I was about 13. My early teens were not kind to me and I was the most gangly, six-foot-tall, awkward and be-pimpled teen I knew.
A Ren Fest actor who was playing a visiting Spanish lord showered me with attention- he gave me a rose and told a large group of gathered Faire attendees that I was beautiful. It was the first time since puberty decided to shit all over me that someone of the opposite sex had told me I was attractive; his single comment gave me hope that my pubescent state would be a passing phase.
Thinking back on that experience, I'm sure that I could pick it apart and think how utterly creepy it was for some 40 year old dude in a frilly shirt and leather vest to be saying anything to a 13 year old that even bordered on innuendo. But in my mind, he did me a great kindness.
For all the bad that Ren Fests- the groping, the titties, the bawdy drinking- there is a good time to be had for those that enjoy it. I haven't been to many Ren Fests since, but I certainly look back on that experience fondly.
10/26/09
10/26/09
I especially didn't appreciate 3 merchants cornering me until I acknowledged that I was female. That wasn't too much fun.
I felt like people were constantly up in my face about how I was presenting (I wasn't wearing a costume, mostly because I wanted to look as "normal" as possible and have people assume I wasn't part of the event, therefore assume I wouldn't be in on the jokes), asking me questions about what kind of person I was and why didn't I want some random asshole kissing my hand? Boundaries were absolutely not respected in the three years I went. I don't think I'd ever really want to go again, despite how much fun other people have. They don't like people who don't look the right way is my experience. Others may differ, though.
By the way, pickle guy, if you ever read this, you are the highlight of the faire, because you are always friendly and give me giant pickles for one dollar. Also, you have never made me feel bad about how I look, and just let me get a pickle in peace. You are my favorite. #renfaire
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
#renfaire
10/27/09
10/27/09
do you have resources? A good therapist, books, money, friends?
#renfaire
10/27/09
10/27/09
Not every transman transitions medically. the procedures are stupidly ineffective and it's a lot of hassle for little reward. I know more transmen than transwomen who were satisfied with their biologically female bodies. Is there a GLISBA or gay-straight alliance at your school? you need something.
If you want to take this offlist, I'm ofnone2150 on AIM or nardo218 on yahoo.
#renfaire
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
Besides which, boning isn't accurate to most characters. Obviously some characters--kissing wenches, courtesans, and other women of ill repute spring to mind--may require cleavage, depending on the actor's vision for that character, and noble ladies would have boned corsets (also: a busk, which is basically a flat piece of wood or something that goes in the front of your bodice) to maintain the desired shape, but peasant ladies were working ladies; they couldn't afford boning and they sure as hell couldn't work in it.
I've been a performer for six years, since I was 19. Before that, I was a regular patron with my family from the time I was 8. My experience with the ren faire is that it's fundamentally no different than going to a football game. The costumes are different, but it's more or less the same concept: bunch of people getting together to be silly. There will always be the drunk assholes who don't have any concept of personal space. I've felt safe and unsafe in both places, but honestly, I feel safer at a ren faire. Is that because I'm used to the environment? Perhaps. But it's also less constrained; while a sporting event has assigned seating, at a ren fest I can pretty much go wherever I want. Plus, I'm more likely to be armed.
I have definitely met my share of assholes through faire, but I've also made some of the best, non-asshole friends I've ever had. I also met mr. biscuit there. :D It takes all kinds, basically. In my experience, the amazing, talented, funny, friendly people (typically performers, but some patrons as well) you'll find outweigh the lecherous asshats. They may not always outnumber them, but I do feel they do outweigh them. And obviously all this varies wildly from day to day, as well as from faire to faire. We're not talking about some monolithic entity called The Renaissance Faire (TM); each festival (or at the most two or three) is individually owned and managed, with its own specific goals, talent pool, and clientele. About the only thing they share is the aspect of outdoor, live, interactive performance, which is not, by its nature, going to be anything near safe space.
On a more personal note: as an actor, I love the renaissance festival with all the love in my jaded little heart. It's such a pure state of performance; for 7-8 hours a day I'm not just pretending to be someone else, I am someone else. I get to decide pretty much everything about that character: costume, mannerisms, family history, personality, you name it. Plus, I get paid to play with people. I don't think I'll ever go back to "legit" theatre. #renfaire
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
I've been going to faire at least once a year for almost 10 years. In the early years, I went in my 'mundanes', then graduated to clumsy attempts to use street clothes to resemble periodish costuming. This Spring I completed my fourth season as a passholder, and my third as a playtron. I don't dress up for attention or anything else. I dress up because I like being part of the magic that is found in the village, whether it is my home village, or one of several that I visit on a regular basis. That being said, wench, and Wench are not necessarily interchangable terms. You never know when the woman with whom you are speaking may be a member of the guild. At my home faire, guild members include cast members in royal, court, and merchant classes, as well as tavern wenches, bellydancers, gypsies, and much more.
At the faires I frequent, guild members are relatively closely knit groups who, while we may not always agree with each other, or even particularly want to spend a lot of time together, we know that we have a support system and that we can count on others as necessary, should we get inappropriate attention or have other issues that warrant attention.
Rennies are MUCH more than hedonistic, shallow, slutty, attention-seeking geeks. Wenches are much more than "fat girls" in bodices with uber-cleavage. Doctors, nurses, computer-savvy folks, teachers, lawyers, students, law enforcement personnel, business owners, musicians, artists, secretaries, construction workers, military personnel, electricians, children, adults, state & municipal employees are all among the people you might encounter at faire, in a period persona, or not.
10/26/09
10/26/09
Insofar as the ladies (and I'd throw in the men here, too) being larger than the average population - I call bullshit. I think larger people are just more visible because faire culture doesn't encourage people who aren't a size 4 to be invisible. I seriously cannot criticize an environment where people of ALL sizes are straight up accepted. #renfaire
10/26/09
I guess the take-home lesson here is "More boob! Less bubo." #renfaire
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
I prefer to go as some type of noblewoman or fantasy creature, because it allows me to be something that I can't be anywhere else. This year I happen to be going as an elf noble, and the only thing I want anyone to stare at is my gorgeous gown. #renfaire
10/26/09
10/26/09
I would like to say this has only happened the once, but its happened numerous times. I have no wish for some stranger to get all up in my personal bubble. Its disgusting.
And that's not even going into the female wenches and how they act towards the men... creeps my husband out... which I can understand b/c its just as disgusting as when the men do it. #renfaire
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/27/09