the breakfast club

posts about #thebreakfastclub more →
Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
5 Movies John Hughes Will Be Remembered For
The Ups And Downs Of Having A John Hughes Boyfriend
"That Girl Was, Is, And Will Always Be Nada"

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

geckogirl
08/09/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
Quote: "admits she won't acknowledge the rest of the Breakfast Club once school resumes" of Claire from the Breakfast Club.
Wait, she is LOSING points for that? I always thought she GAINED them for being the only honest one there. Everyone sort of mumbles "yeah, sure, we'll still talk" but every single one of them knows that it's not true. Well, Claire says it. They're not being honest with themselves and she's the only one who is.
Just my two cents.
Reply

Cunning_Linguist promoted this comment geckogirl was starred geckogirl was unstarred

Callinectes
08/08/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
I was almost hyperventilating by the time I got to the end b/c I thought you were going to leave out Watts. I should have had more faith in you.
Reply

mbot says Spock yeah! promoted this comment Callinectes was starred Callinectes was unstarred

voteforme
08/08/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
With the exception of Ferris Bueller, I've always felt that Hughes' films are incredibly poorly written, in no small part because he never figured out how to craft a worthwhile female character.
Reply

Cunning_Linguist promoted this comment voteforme was starred voteforme was unstarred

BubbaYaga
08/08/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
you know, i was one of those girls that the other high school girls always wanted to "make over". i blame movies like the breakfast club and many more after that; clueless etc were more my generation. movies like this create unrealistic expectations both for the maker over and the makee. it didn't change a damn thing. except giving me a chance to smoke pot with the girl who gave me a horrible jennifer anniston haircut. no boys did a double take when i walked into school the next day. i still didn't know how to talk to the other kids and spent PE class hiding in the art room. i'm not exactly complaining, i just have a lot of mistrust for that makeover concept. i cut my own hair and learned to make friends when i got to college.
Reply

maude_flanders promoted this comment BubbaYaga was starred BubbaYaga was unstarred

ShreelaBabas
08/08/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
"You look good wearing my future." Watts was the only girl in a John Hughes movie who loved a guy for all the right reasons. Claire wanted to rebel so she went with Bender. Samantha was in love with the idea of someone - not the real person. Same thing with Andie. Only Watts fell in love with the real person, the whole package. Ok, so she is a bit of martyr, but when she teaches him how to kiss and he grabs her ass, you kinda want to melt...
Reply

Cunning_Linguist promoted this comment ShreelaBabas was starred ShreelaBabas was unstarred

AllieCaulfield
08/08/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
Anyone else marvel at the fact that Mary Stuart Masterson didn't become a big time film star? At Close Range, Fried Green Tomatoes...Masterson was amazing on screen.
Reply

mbot says Spock yeah! promoted this comment AllieCaulfield was starred AllieCaulfield was unstarred

Hooplehead
08/08/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
Sorry guys, but I think Jeannie Bueller was an archetypal "hysterical, annoying female" part. She's obsessed with Ferris getting away with more than she does and is extremely one-note until....she makes out with a hot guy at the police station, after which she regains a little sanity. I'd have graded her much lower.
Reply

Hooplehead was starred Hooplehead was unstarred

My_Latest_Incarnation
08/08/09

@Hooplehead: Her obsession with crushing Ferris under her heel never bothered me. It was her lack of success. As someone with siblings, I knew sisters were good at crushing irritating little brothers like bugs. What annoyed me was the parents/adults who always bought Ferris' line of crap and let him get away with shit. I hated guys like that in school.
Reply

Hooplehead promoted this comment

Hooplehead
08/09/09

@My_Latest_Incarnation: I'd say that depends on the family, entirely. Sisters can only be successful in crushing out entitlement where the parents back up their efforts. There are some families determined to turn little boys into spoiled little shitheads, regardless of how much the sisters complain about it.
Reply

Hooplehead was starred Hooplehead was unstarred

bluebears
08/08/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
I was a non-teen in the 80s but I remember loving these movies. However watching them as an adult is a bit of a let down. The characters are all so DRAMATIC which is of course typical teen behavior. He really did make the ultimate for teens/about teens movies. All this is to say, when I read this list I find myself unable to really identify with any of these characters.
Reply

Edited by bluebears at 08/08/09 3:49 PM bluebears was starred bluebears was unstarred

Lymed
08/08/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
Next can we grade couples? Although I guess it isn't fair if we end up comparing couples to Watts and Keith.
Reply

Edited by Lymed at 08/08/09 3:33 PM Lymed was starred Lymed was unstarred

MagentaCuppa
08/08/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
i love allison.. as for the makeover, yea it is kinda disheartening to see a girl who was cool before change.. but isn't it growing too??? new interests, new relationships change how you feel about yourself allow you to try to change yourself without being scared..

and i don't know since i was ten i have melted every time emilio estevez looks at her when she walks into the room...
Reply

Hooplehead promoted this comment MagentaCuppa was starred MagentaCuppa was unstarred

Hooplehead
08/08/09

@MagentaCuppa: I always thought that the makeup was kind of like armor for her-like the black and the weirdness and saying things for shock value. All meant to keep people away. I felt like her letting the makeup be taken off meant that she was turning a bit of a corner. And yes, the way he looked at her was adorable.
Reply

Hooplehead was starred Hooplehead was unstarred

CharlotteT
08/08/09

@Hooplehead: I agree with this. She seems to open up more when she gets the makeover, which is a little corny, but its not like she is suddenly "normal." She is just less closed off. Her hair is out of her face, her eyes are wide open. I have the feeling she allowed herself to be made over because she wanted to try something new, not because she wanted to win over a guy. She will probably experiment with her style over and over, like a lot of teenagers.
Reply

mbot says Spock yeah! promoted this comment CharlotteT was starred CharlotteT was unstarred

MissTicklebritches
08/08/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
I have to disagree with your analysis of both Amanda Jones and Watts.
I think Amanda grew a lot throughout the movie. She must be upgraded to at least B+ simply for her amazing double-slap of Blaine in the movie's party scene. She also gave back the earrings, if I remember correctly.
Watts gave me a stalkerish vibe. I found her chauffering them around on the date a bit scary. I kind of wondered if she'd have a creepy shrine to Keith if she didn't have her drums.
Of course, I'd have a creepy shrine to Keith, too. Eric Stoltz was incredibly hot!
Reply

MissTicklebritches was starred

Lymed
08/08/09

@MissTicklebritches: Take back those negative comments about Watts now! Nobody disses my girl crush!
Reply

Lymed was starred Lymed was unstarred

Hooplehead
08/08/09

@Lymed: Sorry, but I'm going to have to agree. I don't know about a shrine, but the chauffeuring scenes always creeped me out a bit.
Reply

Hooplehead was starred Hooplehead was unstarred

BlondeGoddess
08/08/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
I haven't read through all Hortense's labour of love yet because I got distracted by the visual of a wasted Charlie Sheene at the police department. He was so hawt way back then! Hawt I tell ya!
Reply

BlondeGoddess was starred BlondeGoddess was unstarred

Rooo sez BISH PLZ
08/08/09

@BlondeGoddess: *said in Jack Black/Todd Louiso voice hypnotized by Lisa Bonet even though she's covering a Peter Frampton song*
"Yeah..."
Reply

Rooo sez BISH PLZ was starred

ides
08/08/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
Ferris and Jeannie were twins, no? If she's the older sister still in high school when Ferris is a senior, she either stayed back a year or they're the same age. I vote for twins because there's no indication that she would be held back for any reason.
Yes, this has seriously been on my mind since the movie came out.
Reply

VirginiaDentata promoted this comment ides was starred ides was unstarred

VirginiaDentata
08/08/09

@ides: oh my god, you're right. you just BLEW MY MIND
Reply

VirginiaDentata was starred VirginiaDentata was unstarred

SanFranLefty
08/09/09

@ides: I thought she was the younger sister. Now I must watch the movie again.
Reply

SanFranLefty was starred SanFranLefty was unstarred

TheGuvnah
08/08/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
I've definitely never seen Some Kind of Wonderful. I wonder how it would hold up viewed for the first time by a 30 year old.
Reply

TheGuvnah was starred TheGuvnah was unstarred

LipstickLibrarian
08/08/09

@TheGuvnah: H gave away some major plot points, but I still recommend it.
Reply

LipstickLibrarian was starred

hortense
08/08/09

@LipstickLibrarian: I thought of that, but I have a hard time yelling "Spoiler Alert!" for a movie that's over 20 years old, you know?
Reply

hortense was starred hortense was unstarred

Rooo sez BISH PLZ
08/08/09

@TheGuvnah: Don't miss it. Somewhere in there you will likely see your high school self.
Reply

Rooo sez BISH PLZ was starred

TheGuvnah
08/08/09

@LipstickLibrarian: that's okay, I skimmed those sections anyway since I haven't seen the movie :)
Reply

TheGuvnah was starred TheGuvnah was unstarred

LipstickLibrarian
08/08/09

@hortense: Oh, I know.
I was just sayin' that she should watch it anyway.
Reply

LipstickLibrarian was starred

jasonelias
08/10/09

@TheGuvnah: I probably saw it first saw it 15 years ago when I was 25 or so. It's really 80s to be sure but there was an element of truth (painfully so) that makes it essential viewing. Especially if someone was a teenager during that time.
Reply

jasonelias was starred jasonelias was unstarred

maydaystudio
08/08/09

In reply to Who Was The Ideal John Hughes Heroine?
Perhaps we should grade on a curve?

It has been 20+ years, and I'm a bit jaded in the teen-queen department, but Watts, Andie, and Jeannie Bueller would kick the stretch pants off Hannah Montana any day.
Reply

Rooo sez BISH PLZ promoted this comment Edited by maydaystudio at 08/08/09 2:55 PM maydaystudio was starred maydaystudio was unstarred

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion