Is plastic surgery un-feminist? Is not getting plastic surgery a feminist act?
I don't want anything done to myself now, and don't think I'd mind a few wrinkles in the future, but if, in my 70's, I wanted some work done & had the money to do it, I would.
It isn't what you do. It's why you do it. And the reasons why anyone does anything are a personal thing. Brigitte Bardot not having plastic surgery does not make her a feminist, and Sophia Loren having plastic surgery does not mean she is not.
This is an interesting article. I like Bardot for her bluntness, even if I rarely agree with anything she says. Her heart is in the right place when it comes to animal rights, yet her political incorrectness makes her difficult to embrace as a mainstream icon.
However, she is only saying what many people quietly think about Islam. It's sad, it's racist, it's depressing... it's also a problem that affects all of us on a daily basis, and many of us are too "polite" to point out. If her comments can inspire conversation on issues people don't want to talk about, then power to her.
@roxythekiller: However, she is only saying what many people quietly think about Islam.
That point could be made about what people are saying about Jews, Blacks, Hispanics, and Gays. I'd like to think the overwhelming majority of society are not a morass of hateful fucks, though.
@roxythekiller: Like I said, there will always be apologists for racists, but Ms. Bardot's comments are a wee bit more than merely 'politically incorrect'. And just because there are people who share her abhorrent views is no reason to give her a pass.
i guess the only type of female empowerment that is really worth celebration is the sexual kind.
im really glad we threw off centuries of oppression and submission so that we could have the freedom to give men boners! or better yet, so we could have to freedom to allow men to control our images so that they could give themselves boners.
now if only feminist historians would stop focusing on those ugly old bitches like margaret sanger and focus on women like brigitte who REALLY worked for the cause. the gaurdian really knows where its at.
I have no problem with people being praised for their bodies as long as other people are being praised for their minds. So I have no problem with the piece on Bardot, I just wish it was balanced with more awesome doctors, scientists, authors etc. we should know about.
As for just taking what you want from an person, just taking an image? Just look at Che Guevara. Most of America has no idea who he was or what he did, but they have his image on posters and t-shirts all over the place.
Humans are visual. We largely don't care what people we don't know are like, we just like to look at them. When it comes to people we do know, we don't care what they look like and do care about their personality.
Sorry, I rambled.
Also, the muslim thing in France and England IS a problem. Not that Muslims have immigated; that's their right if they do so legally; but that there has been poor integration into culture and society on one side and fear and racism on the other. Neither side is covering themselves in glory, and I'd love to see something worked out. I love immigration, but if it's too much too soon it can cause social problems.
@Agumen: i think the issue here is not that she was hot and everyone wanted a piece, but that she is being lauded as a feminist icon without ever having really done anything....too feministy.
@Agumen: There is explicit, open and notorious racism, lack of opportunity, and isolation of immigrants in Europe in a way that very, very, very few Americans will ever understand. Bardot fueled it with her hateful speech. I don't give the fuck she looked like but I do think the fact that she would just be another racist, anti-immigrant French woman but for her looks speaks volumes as to why the world is an insanely fucked up place. This isn't about Bardot. It's about us.
@KATE!: Because we equate "beauty" with merit. The pretty princess or angel. The ugly witch or monster. And I'm not going to touch what sort of cultural and racial prejudices going into categorizing these two extremes.
She would be irrelevant but for what one might call her "beauty." That is what is fucked up.
@Agumen: I see this shirt around everywhere in Israel--it's a t-shirt of Che Guevara's face, and underneath it it says "who IS that?". Favorite shirt ever.
@HereComesMyBaby: the true irony of both the original shirt and this clever new counter-counter-cultural meta-response is that che spent his entire life fighting this sort of cultural and capital imperialism and now his image has become nothing more than a bourgeois consumer commodity.
its kind of funny (in that sad kind of way) how it worked out: capitalism stole the iconography of one of the left's most mythic figures and subverted it to that point that it is so completely devoid of context that he's a running cultural joke. i have a real soft spot in my heart of that mythic che of the left, but i wouldn't go near that guerrillero heroico imagery on pain of death.
@Trulymadlyme: Here here. I stupidly spend far too much time worrying about living up to a visual ideal instead of looking at those with moral ideals and wondering if I live up to those - and she aint got the kind I like by the sounds of it, anyway. Funny though, when you get people who are quite sound on that front, like Chris Martin or, female-wise, Angelina (despite what gets written about more - ie Brad and the kids), they get labelled a do-gooder..
@Vivien Smith-Smythe-Smith: Hmm, I don't actually know. I think it's an independent little shirt place that makes them. You should just make your own unless you want one in Hebrew. Hah.
@KATE!: Well that's a depressing way of looking at it.
I personally don't mind the appropriation of historical figures for laughs if the laughs are intelligent/interesting/self-aware. But I also don't buy funny shirts/shirts with "messages." I only make my own.
@HereComesMyBaby: i actually really like when historical or political figures are used in popular culture but, as you said, only if they are intelligent/interesting/etc. because it can keep them relevent and in the current discourse. but sadly none of those words can be applied to the che shirts that you can buy at hot topic.
@HereComesMyBaby: But I love Hebrew! Mad keen! (and my best ever che-find was a lanyard emblazoned with his face, from some random dimestore a couple of years back.)
Very well said. It drives me nuts when women (cough, Jessica Simpson, cough, Paris Hiton, cough) talk about what an inspiration Bardot is for them, but have no idea who she is outside of her sex kitten persona.
@Highsmith: Last night I was bored, so I picked a movie from On Demand, "Viva Maria" starring Brigitte Bardot and Jeanne Moreau(sp?). It was HORRIBLE, and Bardot was absolute crap. Gloriously beautiful and charismatic, but a laughably bad actor. I only made it through about 30 minutes before I turned it off. One of the worst movies I have ever seen and that is not an exageration. It is, however, the only movie I have seen her act in. So you have one person here who might agree with you. If that movie is a true example of her acting skills, she was indeed untalented.
@Highsmith: It is the only reason to say something so spectacularly nasty about someone you don't know at all. So you disagree with her. Get over yourself.
@aureliajones: Really? You think if someone thinks another woman to be untalented & not particularly bright, then it would have to be because of "jealousy"? Jealousy of what? I don't get your reasoning? I do think Bardot was a pretty awful actress & the statements I've read of her over the years have made me convinced she's not very intelligent. I'm not holding being a fabricated sex symbol against her but neither am I impressed. Ok, I'll grant you that: her pouting & posing was impressive. Happy?
@Highsmith: So angry! You wouldn't know how bright she is. We get dozen word sound bites from her. If she were not so beautiful, she would not be deemed a "bimbo". Such vitriol stems from your utter annoyance with her popularity. And yes, I'm happy enough not to bash a woman I don't know, especially using such a misogynistic term as "bimbo". You give her that she's pretty but dumb, which is a common way to cut down conventionally pretty women. Good job!
You shush. My mam's still got her vintage Barbies and they are AWESOME. You just know they were so cold-hearted and would smoke cigs in those holder things and wear opera gloves and straight up cut bitches. The one in particular has the best hairstyle evar. It's like a perfect chignon. And she also has that permanent sidelong glance and her eyes are sultry as all get out. The modern Barbies have nothing on Vintage Barb. Believe it.
Am I the only one who had Francie? Barbie's boobs scared the shit out of me, and Francie was more modestly built. Of course, it was the 70's and I was obsessed with tanning so they were all Malibu Barbies.
I even had the Ken with real hair - his stick-on mustaches kept showing up in very strange places on Francie, which enraged Barbie enormously.
"The book says that young Ken "grew up embarrassed and humiliated by having an anatomically incorrect boy doll named after him . . . [with] no hint of genitalia."
Surely he would have been more embarrassed if the doll had plastic molded genitalia?
For Christmas, my niece got gymnast barbies that you attach to a bar and they do flips. I played with it for 2 hours on Christmas. My niece couldn't stop giggling because they put the doll in a sparkly outfit with like a g-string underneath.
I was a strange child. My doctor Barbie performed weird experiments on all the others. One of her more memorable experiments happened on the newest Barbies to join the ranks. One was not willing to cooperate with the doctor so she wound up in the freezer,then took a ride through the dishwasher.
The other one was set on fire, but I blame the boys in the neighborhood for that.
09/23/09
09/23/09
09/23/09
09/23/09
I don't want anything done to myself now, and don't think I'd mind a few wrinkles in the future, but if, in my 70's, I wanted some work done & had the money to do it, I would.
It isn't what you do. It's why you do it. And the reasons why anyone does anything are a personal thing. Brigitte Bardot not having plastic surgery does not make her a feminist, and Sophia Loren having plastic surgery does not mean she is not.
09/23/09
However, she is only saying what many people quietly think about Islam. It's sad, it's racist, it's depressing... it's also a problem that affects all of us on a daily basis, and many of us are too "polite" to point out. If her comments can inspire conversation on issues people don't want to talk about, then power to her.
09/23/09
That point could be made about what people are saying about Jews, Blacks, Hispanics, and Gays. I'd like to think the overwhelming majority of society are not a morass of hateful fucks, though.
09/23/09
09/22/09
09/22/09
09/22/09
im really glad we threw off centuries of oppression and submission so that we could have the freedom to give men boners! or better yet, so we could have to freedom to allow men to control our images so that they could give themselves boners.
now if only feminist historians would stop focusing on those ugly old bitches like margaret sanger and focus on women like brigitte who REALLY worked for the cause. the gaurdian really knows where its at.
09/22/09
As for just taking what you want from an person, just taking an image? Just look at Che Guevara. Most of America has no idea who he was or what he did, but they have his image on posters and t-shirts all over the place.
Humans are visual. We largely don't care what people we don't know are like, we just like to look at them. When it comes to people we do know, we don't care what they look like and do care about their personality.
Sorry, I rambled.
Also, the muslim thing in France and England IS a problem. Not that Muslims have immigated; that's their right if they do so legally; but that there has been poor integration into culture and society on one side and fear and racism on the other. Neither side is covering themselves in glory, and I'd love to see something worked out. I love immigration, but if it's too much too soon it can cause social problems.
09/22/09
09/22/09
09/22/09
She would be irrelevant but for what one might call her "beauty." That is what is fucked up.
09/23/09
09/23/09
09/23/09
its kind of funny (in that sad kind of way) how it worked out: capitalism stole the iconography of one of the left's most mythic figures and subverted it to that point that it is so completely devoid of context that he's a running cultural joke. i have a real soft spot in my heart of that mythic che of the left, but i wouldn't go near that guerrillero heroico imagery on pain of death.
09/23/09
09/23/09
09/23/09
I personally don't mind the appropriation of historical figures for laughs if the laughs are intelligent/interesting/self-aware. But I also don't buy funny shirts/shirts with "messages." I only make my own.
09/23/09
09/24/09
09/22/09
09/22/09
09/22/09
09/22/09
09/22/09
09/23/09
09/23/09
09/23/09
01/08/09
01/08/09
I even had the Ken with real hair - his stick-on mustaches kept showing up in very strange places on Francie, which enraged Barbie enormously.
01/08/09
Surely he would have been more embarrassed if the doll had plastic molded genitalia?
01/08/09
01/08/09
Also I punked out all my Barbies at one time, ripping their clothes and giving them mohawks. My parents applauded me for my creativity....
01/09/09
01/08/09
The other one was set on fire, but I blame the boys in the neighborhood for that.
I never received Barbies as presents after that.