It never ceases to amaze me how much people gush over a man just doing the very basics of parenting. People support this notion that it's "cute" for a man to "babysit" his child. Unless full-on parenting is demanded we will never see a difference. #dads
@lovecake: I think the point is that nothing should be "demanded" of any man or woman by anyone. The problem lies in the fact that we, as a society, demand that women serve as the primary care-givers. The solution to the problem is certainly not to "demand" that men serve in that role, but to allow families to decide who does what without feeling pressured to conform to some arbitrary standard. #dads
@Vermontboy: No, society has ever right to demand parents take care of their children as much as is possible. What shouldn't be expected is parenting based on gender. #dads
@clevernamehere: Sure, but that's just an abstraction. Everyone (including me) will agree that society can expect you to take care of your kids, no two people, no matter how like-minded will ever agree on exactly what that means in practice. As a society we have established certain very basic standards that most people can abide by (don't hit your kids, educate them to some degree). What happens beyond that is open to interpretation.
The republican asshole who will probably be the next governor of Virginia, for example, thinks that working mothers take insufficient care of their children. Point being: while we all expect people to do what's right by their children, we will never all agree on what that is. So the reality of the situation is that, beyond the basics of protecting the health and well-being of our children, society has no right to demand anything about how they are raised. #dads
When my ex quits expecting a Nobel Prize in Parenting for putting a goddamned bandaid on our child, I'll be the first in line to help repaint pink walls. #dads
I am currently dating a man who is raising his two daughters by himself (their mother has profound issues she doesn't recognize or deal with) and his biggest frustration is that government agencies and educational institutions automatically assume that he couldn't be the more responsible parent, especially to two daughters. This ranges from schools that ask to speak to their mother, even when they have their father on the phone, to a child welfare agency that didn't even bother to contact him when his ex-wife went on a bender and left the kids at a motel by themselves, even though they asked for him and he was listed on the custody paperwork.
I honestly didn't believe him about how bad it was until the kids verified the whole story.
Apparently you lose either way. You can be an active, involved dad, but a)you'll have either other people make you feel enferior and not "masculine enough" and/or b) believe you're the best father ever even though you're just doing your job.
It doesn't help that many mothers feel like they need to be on the "mommy track," in order to properly raise their kids. Fathers can't be on a "daddy track," because someone has to feed/educate the children. #dads
@lilyHaze: It's not an issue of how people make you feel, it's true discrimination that can be downright scary. Twice now I've brought my oldest daughter in to the doctor and dentist for routine kid-accident stuff and been treated as a presumed abuser. Once I brought her in with a broken tooth from a face-first trip down the slide and my wife got a call (at work) to ensure that she "was aware of the injury." Another time we went to the urgent care clinic with a swollen wrist to get it x-rayed, and even though I explained how it happened (a trip on the stairs that happened, ironically enough, while my wife was home and I wasn't, but I took her to the doctor when the swelling hadn't gone down the next morning), they told me that I needed to get my wife on the phone to tell them how it happened or they would report it to DCF.
So it isn't just that the walls are pink, it's that when you act outside of your assigned gender role, as a male, you are presumed to be some sort of a criminal. #dads
@Vermontboy: Holy hell, that reminds me of a story about my dad. We had gone to Alaska to visit relatives. All of us are American citizens, and share the same last name. While we were visiting, the airlines went on strike, and we could only fly into Canada. We had to drive over the border.
The border patrol stopped us, and separated us into different rooms to ensure that my father wasn't kidnapping us (back into the country?). I don't remember any of it; I was too tired. Apparently, I shouted at one of them that he was my dad and all I wanted to do was go home, and that they were being stupid. Ah, 12-year-old rage sure is scary and not at all infurating, I'm sure.
@Vermontboy: while i can see how that sucks for you, I suggest you instead view these things as evidence that other people, too, are looking out for your child's best interests. I would commend a physician/etc who followed up a young child's injuries to make sure there wasn't abuse in the house. #dads
@TheGuvnah: I suppose I'm of two minds about it. Before I went back to school I worked as a very small cog in a huge (by VT standards) social services agency, and dealt with a lot of abused kids, abused spouses (men and women), and abused social services workers (seriously, you walk the hallways at the agency and every tenth person has a black eye or a bruise or a scratch on their face). So I understand the importance of being aware of the potential for abuse and the important role that doctors, teachers, etc. play as reporters.
On the other hand, that experience also taught me that in no way can one presume that physical/non-sexual child abuse happens mainly at the hands of men (unlike sexual abuse, which does seem to happen mostly, but not exclusively at the hands of men). In both of the situations I described, I was suspected because I was a male, bringing a child for medical care. The automatic presumption was that something must be wrong, because men don't take kids for medical care. In neither case did the doctor/dentist look for actual abuse, instead they were satisfied to just talk to my wife and hear the same story from her. #dads
What if Dad IS incompetent, does give advice or make demands that screw the kids up (instead of helping them , or attempting to), and IS wrong? Maybe because of some bullshit or something nasty he learned from his own upbringing?
And by the same token--what if that describes Mom? (It describes MY mom half the time, who rants, raves, threatens, makes a big deal of things my father doesn't, like whether or not my 21 year-old brother's friends could drink a few beers at our house, so long as they didn't get hammered. Never did.)
My parents have different parenting styles. To be fair, my father is more lenient when it comes to everything but school-related safe. None of us have dangerous friends or other dangerous habits, none of us are law-breaking tendencies. My mother makes unilateral decisions, and when my father questions them, she loses her shit. If one or both the parents don't know how to handle things, who gives a shit if they agree? That's the least of the family's problems.
Going back to the idea of at least ONE parent balancing understanding/authority with their kid--who will help the kids when the difference isn't simply one parent "micromanaging" a different-but-legitimate style, but micromanaging because one parent's way of doing things neglect the problem, worsen it, create conflict where there shouldn't be any, or effectively blow that kid off (i.e , when a kid has problems with bullies at school and brings it up to parents, the parent fails to sympathize and simply demands kids meet every challenge to fight that bully at school, shaming them if they seek adults out for help in the future or if they lose a fight?)
Different article, I guess.
Sometimes parental conflict (or even absence) isn't the only thing amiss here....
My Dad was a single father to five kids. He was completely awesome and did an absolutely fantastic job, but I really kind of hated the massive amount of praise he got. Not because he didn't completely and utterly deserve it, but because if he were a woman he wouldn't have been praised at all, more likely he would have been cast as a 'drain on society' and all those other 'single mother' cliches you hear. #dads
@aimeeg: I hear you on that. Growing up, my mom had primary custody of my sister and me, but my dad worked hard to remain a steady, significant part of our lives, even when he lived across the country (he would fly all day just to make sporting events, recitals, Halloween, parents' day at school, and once to back up my mom when we all had the flu). And yes, praise was heaped on him for his efforts. While I dearly love and appreciate my dad, I hate that my mom didn't get any accolades for single-handedly parenting two kids for more than a decade. #dads
@jigglyball: Yeah, absolutely. Also, the venom directed at my mum because she was the one who left. She wouldn't have been nearly so villified if she were a man. #dads
I guess I was lucky in that my dad was loving and involved in my life. He worked days so he could take care of me and my brother after school and my mom worked nights so she could see us off. He was the first person in my life that treated me like an adult and asked for my opinions and when he didn't agree with me he would have me explain why I felt the way I did and tell me why he felt the way he did. He died 5 years ago and I miss him every day. #dads
Sadly, this is a huge issue in my house right now. When the baby is fussy, or my husband is tired, I am the last line of defense. My husband is quick to say "well, you are so much better at calming him down"... really? You know why? Because I got a lot of practice.
The real issue is (IMHO) that my husband did not get nearly the same amount of bonding time that I did because he got 1 week of paternity leave - during which, we were still in the hospital. Then my husband was back at work while I spent long days with a newborn. Of course I figured a lot of stuff out the hard way but I can't naturally hand off that experience to my husband. And, at the end of the day, if I know that the baby is hungry because I recognize the cry, then I think that feeding the baby is a higher priority than letting my husband work it out on his own.
All this study does is reinforce that we need equity in the workplace (PARENTAL LEAVE!) before we can get much farther anywhere else. #dads
I'm really conscious of this crap because my wife is in med school, on rotations, making me the primary parent. Most days of the week, she's gone from before the kids wake up until after they got to bed. As such, I do all the cooking, all the cleaning, run all the trips to the dentist, doctor, preschool, daycare, swim lessons, etc... Nonetheless, absolutely everyone operates under the presumption that I must just be filling in for the day. I've stopped trying to correct the pediatrician when she asks me to "give instructions to the children's mother," the preschool when they have a sign up sheet for "classroom moms," the dentist who calls after I brought in my daughter with a chipped tooth (accident on the slide) to "check with her mother to make sure she was aware of the injury."
It's not just "pink walls and women's magazines," it's a systemic presumption that really sucks. I see it as an unavoidable pain in the ass, but its easy to see how fathers in a different situations, where it is not absolutely necessary for them to step into an intensive parenting role, would be turned off. #dads
These problems persist in all walks of life. Two summers ago, I was working a lot and my hubby went on all of the daycare field trips with my son. He was always the only father-- fêted for being there-- except when they went to the train museum. Luckily, he has no problem feeling less-than-masculine because he parents, but he certainly got weird reactions for being plugged in. The same is true at the doctor's office, on the playground... anytime he enters a mom-realm. Even at work (we work together) no one thinks anything of me leaving early to pick my son up, but they raise eyebrows and comment (often in praise, but still it reinforces the idea that it's somehow strange, special, whatever that he actually parents) when he does. #dads
My dad ties to be more of a friend than a parent which is somewhat effective, but there are times where there is trouble with discipline.
Even with that we (still) get in to all sorts of shenanigans together and its fun. #dads
I do believe that SOME women muscle their male partners out of childrearing a bit--I'm realizing, as I get older, that my mom definitely did that to my dad. But I don't think that's just the woman's fault, as you say--a large part of the problem is the concept of motherhood as the most primal, natural instinct a woman could, or SHOULD, have. I think that women who aren't the primary parent are made to feel like failures, like Unwomen, and a lot of people internalize that. Just look at politicians: it was objectionable to some that Palin was campaigning despite having young children, which would've been irrelevant for a man. Obama Homme spent so much time away from his family due to his jobs in politics, which would've been unthinkable for Obama Femme--she would've seemed cold and monstrous to most people for even being able to do it.
My mom's a hard-core feminist, a high-powered lawyer, the whole shebang, but she was raised by a suburban housewife. And while she has a low opinion of housewifery (overly so, I feel), I think she has such powerful memories of her mother that she identifies with that role. You read/hear sometimes about women who get anxious or hurt if their children look to Dad when they're sick or sad or whatever, which I think is natural given societal expectations. So we DEFINITELY need to give dads more credit--and we also need to value women as anything other than mothers. #dads
I'm not sure I buy the whole "he won't be a father because we aren't letting him". Like a pink waiting room is going to stop a man who wants to be a father to his child from doing so? No way. The absence of alot of fathers from their kids lives has probably more to do with their own immaturity and lack of a model parent in their own lives. And I've seen multiple cases of uncles stepping in to fill this role for their falling-down-on-the-job brothers. #dads
@sirsnarksalot: I totally agree and almost typed the same thing (like, the social worker comes to the door and asks to speak to your wife and you just let her without engaging? that is on you, sorry) until I realized that we as feminists sometimes point to really ineffable stuff like this, like "they only talk about sports at work so I can't join in" or whatever as subtle barriers to our success so I guess I felt like I should step back on that one. #dads
@sirsnarksalot: I think it can be both. I mean, yeah, if a man really wants to be involved, he will. But if he's been raised to believe that the woman knows best, and he's a bumbling idiot, he may feel apprehensive at taking charge. Especially if he's got that macho streak where he believes he can't make mistakes. A pink waiting room, an emphasis on the feminine, and cultural cues telling you that you are being strange or unnatural are powerful demotivators.
Of course, men should be involved in their kids' lives, pink waiting rooms or not, but it can be really tough to overcome societal conditioning. #dads
@boxspelunker: I think that's a really good point -- too often we attribute behavior either entirely to social conditioning or entirely to personal beliefs/decisions, but it's so rarely that cut-and-dry. Yes, a father who is aware of and really wants to overcome his social conditioning can do so, but there's a lot of stuff to get through before some fathers can get there. #dads
@sirsnarksalot: I agree that if they're really on board with parenting the pink waiting room shouldn't stop them, BUT: it's not just that it's "pink"... it's really systematic and over time it starts to feel like you're shut out. I speak from some experience - my dad was the stay-at-home parent (80's and 90's) and it is always questioned when I mention it. People from all walks of life think it's weird. If it were my mom who stayed home it wouldn't even register, but because it's my dad I always get "really??" and then feel compelled to explain.
If you're the Dad Who Shows Up, you can expect to be questioned at every turn. Maybe sometimes you're lauded, like at the train museum or whatever, but it's always. a. THING. that you're there. You'll never be part of these mom's clubs, nothing is marketed to you -- it's pretty much like being the kid who got picked on by the cool kids in middle school. I can see why some dads would get frustrated - I know mine did, and his response was to avoid engaging with the other moms.
SO, yes, of course a pink waiting room shouldn't be stopping anyone. But it's so much more than that, it's all the time, and it's exhausting. My dad did it, but someone more on the fence about the whole thing could easily just give up, feeling unwanted and shut out.
ETA -- Additionally, it's sometimes seemed like people think it's creepy for a man to be in charge of a kid (especially a little girl, such as myself). You get the stink eye going doing normal things with your kid if you're the dad, but never if you're the mom. It seems the people are conditioned to imagine men to be kidnappers and pedophiles, not caretakers.
@the grid girl: I totally hear you on that. i had a stay at home Dad for a few years when my Mom went back to work. It was like a social experiment, they totally flipped responsibilities including house work. It was always way cool to have my Dad show at things but I do think it was probably hard for him at times to be the only 'non mom' at stuff. And a good friend of mine has been really active in his niece's life because his brother is, to put it nicely, a loser. I love him for it. And he actually had a woman pull her car over and ask his niece in front of him if she "knew this man" and if she felt safe. Unreal.My hat is off to all the Dads who show up and report because I wouldn't be half the woman I am without my Dad. Its tough in some ways, but for too long we have been willing to give guys a pass because they couldn't be bothered. #dads
11/03/09
11/03/09
11/03/09
11/03/09
11/03/09
The republican asshole who will probably be the next governor of Virginia, for example, thinks that working mothers take insufficient care of their children. Point being: while we all expect people to do what's right by their children, we will never all agree on what that is. So the reality of the situation is that, beyond the basics of protecting the health and well-being of our children, society has no right to demand anything about how they are raised. #dads
11/03/09
11/03/09
11/03/09
I honestly didn't believe him about how bad it was until the kids verified the whole story.
11/03/09
It doesn't help that many mothers feel like they need to be on the "mommy track," in order to properly raise their kids. Fathers can't be on a "daddy track," because someone has to feed/educate the children. #dads
11/03/09
So it isn't just that the walls are pink, it's that when you act outside of your assigned gender role, as a male, you are presumed to be some sort of a criminal. #dads
11/03/09
The border patrol stopped us, and separated us into different rooms to ensure that my father wasn't kidnapping us (back into the country?). I don't remember any of it; I was too tired. Apparently, I shouted at one of them that he was my dad and all I wanted to do was go home, and that they were being stupid. Ah, 12-year-old rage sure is scary and not at all infurating, I'm sure.
It was disappointing, to say the least. #dads
11/03/09
11/03/09
On the other hand, that experience also taught me that in no way can one presume that physical/non-sexual child abuse happens mainly at the hands of men (unlike sexual abuse, which does seem to happen mostly, but not exclusively at the hands of men). In both of the situations I described, I was suspected because I was a male, bringing a child for medical care. The automatic presumption was that something must be wrong, because men don't take kids for medical care. In neither case did the doctor/dentist look for actual abuse, instead they were satisfied to just talk to my wife and hear the same story from her. #dads
11/03/09
And by the same token--what if that describes Mom? (It describes MY mom half the time, who rants, raves, threatens, makes a big deal of things my father doesn't, like whether or not my 21 year-old brother's friends could drink a few beers at our house, so long as they didn't get hammered. Never did.)
My parents have different parenting styles. To be fair, my father is more lenient when it comes to everything but school-related safe. None of us have dangerous friends or other dangerous habits, none of us are law-breaking tendencies. My mother makes unilateral decisions, and when my father questions them, she loses her shit. If one or both the parents don't know how to handle things, who gives a shit if they agree? That's the least of the family's problems.
Going back to the idea of at least ONE parent balancing understanding/authority with their kid--who will help the kids when the difference isn't simply one parent "micromanaging" a different-but-legitimate style, but micromanaging because one parent's way of doing things neglect the problem, worsen it, create conflict where there shouldn't be any, or effectively blow that kid off (i.e , when a kid has problems with bullies at school and brings it up to parents, the parent fails to sympathize and simply demands kids meet every challenge to fight that bully at school, shaming them if they seek adults out for help in the future or if they lose a fight?)
Different article, I guess.
Sometimes parental conflict (or even absence) isn't the only thing amiss here....
11/03/09
11/03/09
11/04/09
11/03/09
11/03/09
The real issue is (IMHO) that my husband did not get nearly the same amount of bonding time that I did because he got 1 week of paternity leave - during which, we were still in the hospital. Then my husband was back at work while I spent long days with a newborn. Of course I figured a lot of stuff out the hard way but I can't naturally hand off that experience to my husband. And, at the end of the day, if I know that the baby is hungry because I recognize the cry, then I think that feeding the baby is a higher priority than letting my husband work it out on his own.
All this study does is reinforce that we need equity in the workplace (PARENTAL LEAVE!) before we can get much farther anywhere else. #dads
11/03/09
11/03/09
It's not just "pink walls and women's magazines," it's a systemic presumption that really sucks. I see it as an unavoidable pain in the ass, but its easy to see how fathers in a different situations, where it is not absolutely necessary for them to step into an intensive parenting role, would be turned off. #dads
11/03/09
11/03/09
Even with that we (still) get in to all sorts of shenanigans together and its fun. #dads
11/03/09
My mom's a hard-core feminist, a high-powered lawyer, the whole shebang, but she was raised by a suburban housewife. And while she has a low opinion of housewifery (overly so, I feel), I think she has such powerful memories of her mother that she identifies with that role. You read/hear sometimes about women who get anxious or hurt if their children look to Dad when they're sick or sad or whatever, which I think is natural given societal expectations. So we DEFINITELY need to give dads more credit--and we also need to value women as anything other than mothers. #dads
11/03/09
11/03/09
11/03/09
Of course, men should be involved in their kids' lives, pink waiting rooms or not, but it can be really tough to overcome societal conditioning. #dads
11/03/09
11/03/09
11/03/09
If you're the Dad Who Shows Up, you can expect to be questioned at every turn. Maybe sometimes you're lauded, like at the train museum or whatever, but it's always. a. THING. that you're there. You'll never be part of these mom's clubs, nothing is marketed to you -- it's pretty much like being the kid who got picked on by the cool kids in middle school. I can see why some dads would get frustrated - I know mine did, and his response was to avoid engaging with the other moms.
SO, yes, of course a pink waiting room shouldn't be stopping anyone. But it's so much more than that, it's all the time, and it's exhausting. My dad did it, but someone more on the fence about the whole thing could easily just give up, feeling unwanted and shut out.
ETA -- Additionally, it's sometimes seemed like people think it's creepy for a man to be in charge of a kid (especially a little girl, such as myself). You get the stink eye going doing normal things with your kid if you're the dad, but never if you're the mom. It seems the people are conditioned to imagine men to be kidnappers and pedophiles, not caretakers.
11/04/09