Watch Olivia Wilde and Billy Eichner Play 'John Mayer or Pepé Le Pew?'

Olivia Wilde recently stopped by Billy on the Street to play “John Mayer or Pepé Le Pew,” an exciting new game in which contestants are read a set of overwrought quotes and have to guess who, between an aggressively amorous stink mammal (John Mayer) and a cartoon skunk, said what.

(Sorrrrrrrry for being so harsh, John. I’m sure you smell okay.)

Wilde didn’t fare so well in the game, but she did a great job winning over our hearts. For her charm, she was rewarded with a reunion of fake Danity Kane and forgiveness for the whole Alex/Bait Shop storyline during season 2 of The O.C.