Vote 2020 graphic
Everything you need to know about and expect during
the most important election of our lifetimes

Study: Feeling Bad Can Make You Smarter

Illustration for article titled Study: Feeling Bad Can Make You Smarter

In yet another blow to positive thinking supporters, scientists have found that a bad mood can improve people's memory and judgment, and make them less reliant on stereotypes.


According to Miral Fahmy of Reuters, researchers first put their subjects in sad or happy moods by having them watch movies or recall positive or negative memories. Then they conducted several different experiments. They found that people in bad moods were less likely to believe urban myths or rumors, and were also less likely to make decisions based on racial or religious prejudice. They were better at remembering events they'd seen, and better at persuasive writing. Study author Joseph Forgas wrote that a "mildly negative mood may actually promote a more concrete, accommodative and ultimately more successful communication style." He added, "positive mood is not universally desirable: people in negative mood are less prone to judgmental errors, are more resistant to eyewitness distortions and are better at producing high-quality, effective persuasive messages."


So despite the conventional wisdom that thinking positively will help us solve all of our problems, it seems that feeling sad can actually be productive — maybe there's a use for a bad mood after all. Negative feelings appeared to boost subjects' critical thinking skills, the kind of skills that come in handy when something bad happens to you. Being the victim of a crime would be a good example — if it puts you in a bad mood, you may actually remember the incident better, making it more likely that the police can catch the criminal. Perhaps bad moods, rather than being a relic of some less-evolved mental state, are actually adaptive, sharpening our cognitive faculties when we need them most. As Forgas says, "our research suggests that sadness ... promotes information processing strategies best suited to dealing with more demanding situations."

Of course, the research raises questions. Were the good or bad moods induced by scientists really similar to feelings subjects would experience on their own? And how bad does a bad mood have to be before it stops being a help and starts being a hindrance? Clinical depression might actually reduce cognitive ability, and it seems possible that a certain intensity or duration of negative feelings could impair judgment rather than boosting it. Still, it's intriguing and in a way reassuring to hear that our bad moods may be doing something for us — perhaps instead of fighting against them, we should learn to use them.

Thinking Negatively Can Boost Your Memory [Reuters]

Share This Story

Get our newsletter



I bet this is a really common personality trait for people who work in law enforcement.

I read Ehrenreich's book over the weekend, and thought it was genius. People who tend to conflate positivity with happiness or satisfaction, and "negativity" with depression or unhappiness or unproductiveness should really read it. It's a good deal more complex than that. And it seems quite obvious to me that positivity as we now understand it has the capacity to render people incapable of critical thought. It is, in practice and in theory, thought-terminating. Real growth and development comes out of dissatisfaction, with an ability to identify and solve problems, to think analytically. Until we understand how positivity is used to prevent us from upsetting the apple cart, so to speak, we're not going to be able to move forward. #emotions