NY Times Readers Go 'Psycho' On September 'Vogue'

Illustration for article titled NY Times Readers Go Psycho On September Vogue

Today's Women's Wear Daily reports on NY Times fashion critic Cathy Horyn's blog review of the ninety pound September Vogue and, as usual in these sorts of cases, WWD intimates that the comments following Horyn's post were the best thing about it. (Unless, of course, sentences like "Carolyn Burke's article about the friendship between Jacques Henri Lartigue and Richard Avedon was a surprise" get your juices flowing.) Here's commenter "Autre" on Vogue editor Anna Wintour:

I'm watching 'Psycho' after this - Hitch had the right idea about mothers, and other stuffed birds, there. Ya know, in the end, she was just like a stuffed bird, but the voice was still there. Well, as always, we hear the voice, but we need to see the stuffed (=inanimate) bird behind it. It's the powerlessness of the omnipresent voice. Or the fat issue - a lot of straw in there.

There's more!

One word SAYS IT ALL....STAGNATION! Imagine that on the cover: instead of the name Vogue, you'd see Stagnation.


A little further down:

Indeed, it has stagnated, in the most subservient way..."an old bitch gone in the teeth." Miller is as interesting as rain on a Tuesday in London; a prosaic choice to be sure. But what would it take to wake this slumbering mama up? What should the point of view be?

Sing it, sister! And from "Nadine":

Vogue magazine truly embodies all that is wrong in our culture while actually distorting all that is good-sycophancy and rampant cronyism abound while real talent is all but ignored. Unfortunately reading pop culture periodicals is work related but it gets very depressing.


Hey Nadine, it's okay, the Universe is just absurd like that. Anyway, these are so good we think we're going to have to scan some pages from the magazine and use them as captions. Developing!

Open Season[WWD]
Related: Big Mama: The New Vogue [NYTimes]


Share This Story

Get our newsletter


Dear Jezebel,

Just so you know: I'm not doing this for the giggles (well, most of the time), and the 'mother in Psycho' reference is connected to Cathy's title "Big Mama". It was never ever meant to be Anna bashing. It's not how I do things, ever. MY only concern is their work. Even if some comments are funny and over-the-top (but so is Vogue), there was a lot of constructive critique, especially after a 'Vogue Intern' came to Vogue's defence under 'Michael Roberts'.

Anyway, I'm new to this site (and was anonimously informed of this particular entry via email... I wonder who the sender might be...) - will check it out. But keep up the dirty work, women. Someone has to do it.

Best of luck,


P.S.: Could you tell me what Maureen Dowd's problem is? I just bet she only wants a man who can sew on a button and knows where the towels are.