Notre Dame Trustee Pushed Out Over Pro-Choice Donations

Illustration for article titled Notre Dame Trustee Pushed Out Over Pro-Choice Donations

Roxanne Martino is a 1977 Notre Dame graduate who went on to become the president and CEO of a Chicago firm that manages $8 billion in money from hedge funds. Two months ago, she was appointed to Notre Dame's board of trustees, but now she's resigned amid scandalous accusations. Her crime? Donating to a charity that supports pro-choice female candidates, and another that helps women and girls.


The Chicago Tribune reports that Martino has resigned following an expose last month by the Cardinal Newman Society, which monitors whether or not Catholic colleges and universities are upholding the faith. A post on the Society's blog reported Martino gave $16,150 to EMILY's List and between $3,000 and $6,000 to the "pro-abortion Chicago Foundation for Women."

School officials say Martino didn't know the organizations support abortion rights:

"On the basis of a recommendation from others, she made contributions to two organizations, and she regrets that she did not personally review their activities ... That she erred in not knowing completely about two of the many organizations to which she makes contributions does not in any way diminish the exemplary way in which she has lived her life and faith."


That's a harder to believe in the case of EMILY's List since, a quick Google search brings up the phrase, "EMILY's List is a national organization dedicated to electing pro-choice Democratic women to office." However, the Chicago Foundation for Women doesn't define itself by its love of dishing out abortions. The organization raises money to fund groups that support women and girls through programs that help women in poverty, and those suffering from domestic violence and lack of access to "health services and information." It doesn't exactly sound like the kind of thing Catholics should be rallying against, but the Cardinal Newman Society reports:

Chicago Foundation for Women made grants to the Chicago Abortion Fund, Planned Parenthood/Chicago Area, Planned Parenthood of Illinois, the ACLU Reproductive Rights Project, and Black Women for Reproductive Justice. The Foundation's website also notes that it supports the Illinois Campaign for Reproductive Health and Access, which seeks "to organize around the advancement of a broad pro-active, pro-choice agenda."

Martino responded in a statement issued by Notre Dame:

"I dearly love my alma mater and remain fully committed to all aspects of Catholic teaching and to the mission of Notre Dame," Martino said in a statement released by the university. I had looked forward to contributing in this new role, but the current controversy just doesn't allow me to be effective."


In all likelihood she had some idea that she was supporting pro-choice organizations, and like many people, still considers herself a Catholic even though she doesn't agree with every last one of the church's policies. Jon O'Brien, president of Catholics for Choice, said this incident demonstrates, "the lunacy of the extreme uber-conservative Catholics who represent really a minority opinion with in the church."


Martino may not be able to serve the school she loves as a trustee, but at least she can take comfort in knowing that she's in good company. The Cardinal Newman Society has been looking at Notre Dame moreclosely since the school invited President Obama to give the 2009 commencement address and receive an honorary degree, igniting a huge controversy. Apparently having a sitting president speak at your university is reprehensible if you happen to officially disagree on a woman's right to choose.

Chicago Businesswoman Resigns From Notre Dame Board [Chicago Tribune]
About [Chicago Foundation For Women]


Earlier: The Shifting Identity Of American Catholics

Share This Story

Get our newsletter



From what I can tell, the Cardinal Newman Society is basically a fundie Catholic group looking to force policies on Catholic universities.

They put together a college guide and the only school I recognized straight away was Catholic University in DC. Missing from the list are Georgetown, Notre Dame, Holy Cross, Boston College, Fordham, Gonzaga, St. John's and all the Loyolas. Apparently those schools are too liberal for the fundie seal of approval.

Ava Marie University makes the list and it was founded 8 years ago by the guy who founded Dominos are a super religious option.

It is too bad Notre Dame felt the need to explain themselves to crazy fundies.