New York City Will Encourage Moms to Breastfeed by Locking Up All the Formula

Illustration for article titled New York City Will Encourage Moms to Breastfeed by Locking Up All the Formula

Breastfeeding, according to all the trendiest news stories, is the best thing ever — it turns your baby into a super genius with a brain the size of a mutated cantaloupe and all but ensures that child's eventual acceptance into an elite university, either Oxford or the Sorbonne, but maybe Harvard as a back-up. There are drawbacks, of course, but there are drawbacks to eating too much ice cream and nobody's solution to brain freeze is, "Stop all intake of ice cream." The point is, if you're a truly dedicated mother, you'll breastfeed, and if you refuse, the city of New York under Caius Brutus Bloomberg will make it unreasonably difficult for you to procure formula.


Starting September 3, reports the Post with nary a tinge of salaciousness, New York will implement "the most restrictive pro-milk program in the nation." As part of the city Health Department's voluntary Latch On NYC Initiative (which, I think we can agree, is a terrible name), New York's 40 hospitals will give up "swag bags" featuring formula logos (which include branded mugs and bottles), as well as document a medical reason for every bottle of formula that a newborn receives.

Back in April, the consumer advocacy group Public Citizen wagged its finger at hospitals for being complicit in unethical marketing of the formula products, and so called for healthcare facilities to "immediately discontinue the distribution of commercial infant formula manufacturer discharge bags." Though New York's latest move to restrict the wanton distribution of formula grab-bags to labor-weary mothers has been applauded by breastfeeding advocates, formula-feeding moms are rightly pissed that they're getting a heavy-handed lecture on how best to fill their infant's squishy little body with nutrients.

"If they put pressure on me, I would get annoyed," said Lynn Sidnam, a Staten Island mother of two formula-fed girls. "It's for me to choose." Latch On won't deny women formula if they request it, but mothers who do ask for formula will be, according to Allison Walsh of the Bethel Medical Center, educated. Lisa Paladino from Staten Island University Hospital took the restrictions on formula one step further, explaining,

The key to getting more moms to breast-feed is making the formula less accessible. This way, the RN has to sign out the formula like any other medication. The nurse's aide can't just go grab another bottle.


Latch On NYC is extremely susceptible to criticism as a restriction on personal freedom, but the idea that formula makers aren't also exerting a similar (if subtler) kind of pressure on new mothers to use formula is naive. Still, nobody likes a lecture and being told that there's only one correct way to care for her newborn is probably the easiest way to anger a mom. "They make formula for a reason," says Roxanne Schmidt, "and the FDA makes sure it's safe." Putting that kind of trust in the FDA might be little too precarious a leap of faith for some people, but Schmidt does have a point — suddenly restricting a mother's choices is the most patronizing way to effect change there is. Besides, it's self-defeating — think of all the times someone reminded you to recycle or quit smoking or not huff so much glue, and then ask yourself if that person's nagging made you really want to change your behavior or, instead, exacerbated it, just to make them understand how paltry few fucks you gave about their attempt to regulate your behavior.

Mayor Bloomberg pushing NYC hospitals to hide baby formula so more new moms will breast-feed [NY Post]


Image via Rafal Olechowski/Shutterstock.



Why is this article written by someone who neither lactates or gave birth? It's a proven fact that hospital marketing of formula hurts a woman's chance of success at breastfeeding. It's not a "choice" to formula feed if it's an uneducated one. Good for NYC.

Birth should come with a lactation consultant appt, and a free coupon for a 1 on 1 session after you leave the hospital, complete with follow up calls. It was very hard for me to breastfeed, and I am very happy we worked through it.

Until hospitals support breastfeeding and educating patients on the real costs, benefits, risks, etc. moms are NOT getting a choice, they are being led on to thinking formula is "easier" or better. Don't get me started on GMO's and rGBH in formula, because it makes my heart sink.

Putting "Faith in the FDA" is something only an idiot who knows nothing about the organization would do. Did you all know who is the Obama appointed "Food Safety Czar" at the FDA? Michael Taylor from Monsanto, the largest company who makes genetically altered food, multiple pesticides/herbicides, which they claim are all safe. To put this in perspective, Monsanto also made Agent Orange, and let everyone know how safe that was too. I encourage everyone to look into this, and do some research before you just "trust" govt organizations who are literally run by lobbyists and/or now, like the FDA, the company that needs the most regulation and scrutiny from the FDA is literally RUNNING it from the inside.

Look it up.