Planning to Get Rich Off Those Beanie Babies? So Sad, Too Bad

Illustration for article titled Planning to Get Rich Off Those Beanie Babies? So Sad, Too Bad

Bad, sad news: You're never gonna get rich off your heavily curated Beanie Baby collection.


Right out of high school, I worked at a children's toy store for a couple months. It was at the height of the Beanie Baby craze, and my old high school drama teacher — who, btw, was the most terrifying and amazing woman on Earth (to me) (at the time) (think, IRL Ursula the Sea Witch) found out I was working at around BB's (industry term) and would harass me to put them on super secret hold for her. It was totally against the rules, but I did it anyway. What can I say? This is the same woman who told me I needed to dye my naturally red hair black to play an aristocrat in my high school's production of Evita, and I did that shit, too.

I estimated that this woman put at least $500 into her BB collection in the short time I worked at the store, but she was sure she'd make every penny back and then some$$$. Looking at this breakdown of how well the Beanie Babies aged, I'm gonna guess that never happened. Ah, the sweet/disgusting excess of the late 90s.


[Buzzfeed, Pitch]

Share This Story

Get our newsletter


I'll admit it, I was a beanie baby freak - I still have them all, and the bigger ones, the Buddies (yes, I have those too, and the mini McDonald ones). I don't know what I am going to do with them, but I never collected them to make money, I just liked them and I still do. I'm gonna come out and admit there's stuffed animals in my bed right now... and I'm 29