Are Women's Studies Departments Dying?

Illustration for article titled Are Womens Studies Departments Dying?

After the current crop of seniors graduates this spring, women's studies will no longer exist as an autonomous field in Britain, says Angela McRobbie in today's Guardian. She thinks women's studies has disappeared for two main reasons: One, the mercenary job market, where a women's studies degree is not immediately applicable to a high paying job (though the same could be said of philosophy, comparative literature, or any other liberal arts degree). McRobbie's second reason is that women, in what she describes as a largely post-feminist England, "fear being seen as critical of men." Whether or not McRobbie's supposition about English women holds water, I wondered how American women's studies departments are faring these days. I called Barbara Howe, director of the women's studies department at West Virginia University and president of the National Women's Studies Association to find out.

"As far as I know," Professor Howe said in a phone interview, women's studies departments in the States "are not declining. The only one that I know of that's under some threat right now is at South Florida. There's been budget cuts and the dean wants to take away their autonomous status." Otherwise, Howe notes, the enrollment for her women's studies classes at WVU is strong, and they retain popularity because word of mouth is so potent. "What i see at West Virginia, is that people will get really excited about material and then they will recruit their friends. We can encourage them as teachers only so much," but it's the enthusiasm of the students that keeps 'em coming back.

She then told this anecdote about a student she had a few years ago. "She must have been 18 or 19 at the time. We were talking about Title IX in class, and this student asked 'Why hasn't anyone told me about this before?' She was furious that no one had told her about Title IX. But Title IX was her birthright, and she had been reaping the benefits of it without knowing its name. It's our obligation as women's studies scholars to point out the benefits, but also to point out that they need to protect them."

Advertisement

[Image via George Mason University Women's Studies Department.]

Postfeminist Passions [Guardian] Help Save The USF Women's Studies Department [Feminists To The Rescue]

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

stoprobbers
stoprobbers

It's funny, sometimes I think I hate women, but I think I just hate Women's Studies.

I wrote my undergraduate thesis about the Beatles, so I actually read a lot of feminist writers who, during the Women's Movement in the 70s, wrote about the Beatles as being a catalyst for a sense of unity among young women that had been missing before that time. Now, my thesis veered off to explain how the Beatles were a catalyst for a sense of unity among all young people at that time — something that had also been previously missing in American society — but because the Beatles were such a female-centric sensation, I think the closest I ever came to being a classical feminist was in those 228 pages.

Two weeks after it was done, turned in, and given highest honors (woohoo! 1 1/2 years of work paid off!!!), I was talking with another girl at my school, a WS major. She inquired as to my thesis and I started to explain. But when I started talking about the girls, she cut me off angrily and told me that my thesis was demeaning to women because it didn't recognize the inherently harmful nature of cannonizing these four young men, instead of creating our own female icons to look up to and therefore to weaken the historical patriarchy in the US.

I came about THISCLOSE to straight-up slapping her in her face. It was the most rude, insulting and close-minded reaction to my work I have ever — to this day — encountered. I've gotten plenty of "Really?!"s when I said I wrote on the Beatles [and, to be honest, I spent most of my time researching, writing, and wondering when they were gonna tell me to get serious already], and a lot of "Woah, awesome!"s, but only this ONE negative.

THAT is why I hate Women's Studies. So, study on you WS majors! And try not to insult other peoples' academic endeavors. Especially ones that sucked up a year and a half of their lives.