Exes Sarah Silverman and Jimmy Kimmel reunited last night when Silverman was a guest on Jimmy Kimmel Live. Although she was there to promote her upcoming HBO special, Silverman used the opportunity to return some of Kimmel's things that she'd been hanging onto since they broke up in 2009.

By all accounts, the pair have an amicable relationship, but that didn't stop them from playing up the extreme awkwardness of the situation as Sarah returned his old toothbrush, jeans and a few other surprise items. It's always been fun to watch these two interact (it's while they were dating that we got "Fucking Matt Damon" and "Fucking Ben Affleck") — good to see that that remains the case even with all of those "Team Sarah" t-shirts out there.