Time for bed, lovelies. I just wanted to share that I am about 4/5 done with my final paper, which is due in a week. It has been a long slog, so thanks for keeping me entertained enough to get through it all weekend!
Any Georgians out there? I'm not (Canadjun, eh!), but I have a new dude at my office who's from Atlanta. He invited a couple of us over for bevvies on Thursday, and due to a variety of circumstances (working, family obligations, me getting h1n1) no one went. And then I realized that not only was this shitty because he's the new guy at the office and no one went to his shindig, but he's the new guy at the office and no one went to his THANKSGIVING shindig (ours was so long ago, we all forgot).
Anyway, I want to do something for him that will remind him of home. Is there anything specific that people in Georgia do for Thanksgiving? Or just some Georgia tradition, or dish, or thing, or whatever I can do to make him feel welcome and less homesick and less convinced that Canadians are shitty? (Because we're not -- just a little flaky and daft sometimes!)
Anyway, thoughts are appreciated. Otherwise, he's getting the Canadian rhymeswithfeather Thanksgiving specialty -- me, a case of cheap beer, a joint, two forks and a pumpkin pie (with real whipped cream, natch).
@rhymeswithfeather: I'm not from Georgia, but everyone I've known from there has loved unsweetened cornbread. Totally different tasting than anything I ever had growing up.
@rhymeswithfeather: Well, I'm a Northeasterner, but I do know that they love the sweet tea down there in Georgia. And, if he's a drinking man (and if it's available up there), this sweet tea vodka is pretty amazing: [www.fireflyvodka.com]
@Tippi Hedren: As a Southerner (South Carolina, not Georgia, but close enough) I have to agree on the unsweetened cornbread. Sweet cornbread is nonsense.
@NellMood: @Tippi Hedren: What is this unsweetened cornbread of which you speak? I'ma have to find a recipe.
@All - Thanks so much! I love the random conjectures from a bunch of non-Georgians ;) Glad you're all as lost as me. Oh, and as for that 'sweet tea' nonsense, all iced tea is sweetened in the great white north, so maybe I'll just so some of that with straight up vodka. I dig, I dig! It will surely go nicely with pumpkin (or pecan!) pie.
@NellMood: More proof that my being born in the South was a mistake ... I love sweet cornbread. I didn't know it existed until I was 20 or so because my mom always made the "regular" kind. Ick. :)
@rhymeswithfeather: Sweet ice tea. Pecan pie. Biscuits. These are all typical Southern foods that most Southerners will appreciate. (Except me, because I'm weird. See above.) You should Google Paula Deen. She has a show on Food Network, and she's from Georgia. Her food looks amazing, and it might give you some ideas.
@dj_chick: Blasphemy! No, I'll admit that sweet cornbread isn't SO terrible, and sometimes can be great. I just don't think it counts as cornbread. Corncake maybe.
OMGGGGGGG I was in the car for sixteen hours today. I had a fantastic week and it was lovely seeing my family, but they are on the far side of a long, aggravating trip that involved being detoured around that stupid rockslide on I40 and then getting lost in stupid Cincinnati.
On the bright side, I got to drive through the 25E tunnel in the Cumberland Gap. It was AWESOME.
So after a fantastic 40 person Thanksgiving dinner at my aunt's house, my mother (who up until the past couple years did a smaller Thanksgiving every year) decided to continue her tradition of "Thanksgiving El Segundo" this evening.
This isn't eating leftovers: she makes a second Thanksgiving dinner for the immediate family, complete with two different kinds of pie. It. Was. Epic.
@Tippi Hedren: In cases like this, my mom's crazy works out beautifully for me. Between that and the chocolate chip pancake(s) she made me this morning (she thinks I'm too skinny... I'm not) I ate like the Queen of the Pigs today.
How soon after receiving a gift is it socially acceptable to regift it? My bf's parents gave us our Christmas gifts early b/c they won't see us for Christmas and his mother gave me the most horrible purse I have ever seen. She went crazy at her church's crafts fair and this thing is something Holly Hobbie would wear. I'm sure some 5-year-old girl would find it adorable but I am 40. I'd like to go ahead and give it to Goodwill so at least someone can get some good out of it.
@willwriteforfood: That sounds perfectly reasonable to me... though is this something you will have to wear when you see her? Is she the type to notice?
@willwriteforfood: Maybe wait until after the holidays to give it to Goodwill? I think it would be classy (though totally not necessary) if you used the purse just one time--the next time you see them. Although you might not want to encourage her!
@NellMood: @LaComtesse: @Tippi Hedren: You don't understand. This purse is handmade...in the shape of a baby's bottom. Seriously, it's made out of baby jeans, sewed up at the bottom, so it looks like a fat, round little baby butt with little ribbons and a cute little hanky sticking out of the back pocket. It is not something an adult wears.
Luckily, it may be next Thanksgiving before I see her. She won't ask me about it. But I take everyone's point and will wait a decorous amount of time.
@willwriteforfood: Oh god, that's AWFUL. Just hide it somewhere in a closet or drawer and get rid of it in a few months. Did she pick this out because she actually thought you'd like it, or is she punishing you?
@willwriteforfood: That's maybe the worst gift ever in the history of gifts. I agree with @NellMood, this could be punishment. My MIL has given me multiple copies of both the Bible and Mere Christianity. MILs love passive aggressive punishment. LOVE.
@Tippi Hedren: I usually go with something industrial/techno-y, which I'll guess is probably outside your musical interests. Combichrist, Anders Manga, Deathstars, Doctor Steel, remixed Mindless Self Indulgence, Hadouken!, Ministry, stuff like that. :)
@Tippi Hedren: God I LOVE Missy at the gym. I might also recommend Outkast, Janelle Monae, some Black Eyed Peas, Kylie Minogue, a little Britney, Madonna.... My list could go on forever.
@robyngraves: Ministry is an interesting choice, I might look into that. I know saying that I normally work out to Missy doesn't give much insight, but I like a HUGE spectrum of music.
@Tippi Hedren: Oooh, KMFDM is a must to add on to that if you're going to look into Ministry. Ohoh, or Lords of Acid.
I made the list because I was hoping you might be open to other types of music, but I'm more used to being wrong about that. I'm the same way though- I go from Lady GaGa to Nattefrost without a second thought.
@Tippi Hedren: On rotation for me right now is Kylie Minogue's Boombox, all the fast Lady Gagas, and for some reason, Gwen Stefani's Wind it Up. I have to get rid of that one, but it's perfect for the elliptical. Tip: Bob Dylan doesn't work.
@Tippi Hedren: I have Missy on high rotation, but I throw in a mixture of pop, electroclash, metal, and industrial. I like to run to Kylie, Orgy, Rob Zombie, and Ladytron. The Killers get on there, as does Chemical Brothers, Li'l Kim, Gwen Stefani.
I'm hoping to benefit from any resources you may all know of for help treating depression. For me it's been a lifelong struggle - my depression pervades memories from early childhood - and so I'm beginning to suspect that it is physical and not situational. I'm going through a very extreme low right now, which has lasted almost a year. This week I actually began feeling better, and so I want to address my problem while I'm clear-headed (before a trigger sends me back to a place where I cannot reach out for help). I'm asking here if anyone knows of a good resource to get help. I have attempted to talk to counselors before without success, but am willing to try again if I can find a way to afford it (I'm not in school, and don't know of any community services near me). I want to talk to a doctor, but I'm afraid to answer the questions because I don't want them to believe I'm at risk for self-harm. I don't have anyone in my life right now who I trust enough to reach out to. Where should I go to get help? How do you bring up the topic of depression with a doctor?
Any advice, personal experience, links, etc. would be much appreciated. I'm in the L.A./Orange County area if that helps.
curiousgeorgiana promoted this comment
Edited by Lizard in the Wires - synthesizer signals suspense! at 11/29/09 11:11 PM
Lizard in the Wires - synthesizer signals suspense! was starred
Lizard in the Wires - synthesizer signals suspense! was unstarred
@Habibiti: My advice is to do whatever you need to in order to get better. Don't worry about answering questions, etc.- just do it.
I pushed myself for a long time before my depression got bad enough to be hospitalized. Now with talk therapy and medication, I'm doing a lot better. The difference is night and day.
Also, remember that:
1) You might not connect with any given therapist. Don't give up on therapists altogether because of one bad one. I had an awful therapist in high school, but I have a great one now.
2) Medication is much better than it used to be. The one I'm on now basically just makes me feel more like myself, just without the crushing despair. I'm a little sleepier, but if it means the ability to feel joy, I'll take it.
3) You can do it! The biggest step is wanting to get better. Once you get over that hump, the rest is easy.
In terms of cost, one of my friends was doing a free clinic thing for a little while, but you get limited to a certain number of appointments, which isn't super helpful if you need more than that. Find out if your insurance covers this sort of thing, and if they have any recommended places.
@Habibiti: first action should be to actually go to the doctor and just tell them exactly what you've typed here.
most likely they will simply test you and make recommendations but you must understand that if you show any real indicators of self harm, it may behoove you for them to take you into custody. the latter rarely happens.
But this doesn't mean you should delay any treatment so I'm glad you are showing interest.
back to the doctor visit:
you need to find out whether there are any nutritional deficiencies. I've posted several times, here, that i became severely depressed and suicidal over the course of a year and it was found I had severe B12 and vitamin D deficiencies. Nutrition, excercise and sleep habits play a big part in a lot of depression cases.
if all is well on the health front then you may want to reach out to this organization for referrals.
I would also recommend, if you haven't already, telling at least one person close to you about your battle - it is important to have someone who knows your situation, especially when you seem to go in and out of more serious episodes.
@Habibiti: i would look to see if there are any colleges nearby that have training programs. i had much more success with people who were training to become therapists, than with anyone i was referred to through my private insurance.
specific to that area, i saw a couple people at hope international university. it was just counseling, no medication, but they matched me pretty well.
you're doing good by taking that first step. i would also look around to see if there is anyone that you can trust. i know it's hard if you don't have anyone, but you might be surprised by how willing to help people are.
i would bring it up in any way that is comfortable with you. i would also focus things in a positive way, like if you've found that you don't have the energy for things you used to enjoy, say that you want to be able to go out and live your life. you could also say that you're tired of feeling crappy.
i know it's hard, but if you are at risk for self harm, that's something that you're going to have to address. they probably won't immediately lock you up somewhere, but it is a very real part of the illness and should be included in your treatment plan.
best of luck, i'll be sending positive energy your way.
@Habibiti: First of all, I agree with a lot of the advice listed. Try to find someone in your life you can talk to, and then find a way to see a professional. The first step is realizing you need help, and you should be proud of yourself for that. I'm proud of you too!
I live in the LA area, but I have health insurance right now (I get the impression from your post that you don't). A quick search directed me to this site, which I remember seeing when I first moved to LA. I'm not sure that it's up-to-date, but this page has a whole list of free and low-cost mental health services in LA County: [www.ihatemylife.us] (And yes, I know it's called "ihatemylife" which sounds very negative. But it's actually a blog about someone who got out of homelessness.)
@spiraloflife: Thank you so much for the support. I can't tell you how much it means to hear this from someone else who's been there. I'm trying to be proactive during a time when I'm capable of thinking positively, because I know that when (and at this point it is "when" and not "if") I spiral back down, it will be worse than the last time, and I won't be able to ask for help. Thank you for the encouragement!
@Scout: Thank you for your advice about the doctor. Though I can honestly say that I have no plans for self-harm, I'm genuinely terrified that I will be taken into custody. This may be paranoia, but it's a huge block to me talking to my doctor. And I've been really careful lately about diet and exercise, trying to keep my system stable. I'm taking vitamins, St. John's Wort, not drinking any alcohol, etc. But I think I need a professional opinion about what's going on. I'm also trying to find someone to reach out to, but it's hard. I only have two people who are realistic options and neither have returned a phone call in several weeks (they live a long plane-ride away). I think my best plan is just to go to a doctor, and focus on myself without expecting other help. Thank you so much for taking the time to write - it's helped more than you know.
@elliotellsworth: Thank you so much for responding to me. I just left a message at Hope, and they will get back to me within 24 hours. I'm trying to find someone to reach out to, but I don't want to set myself up with unrealistic expectations - I know that this has been a trigger for me in the past (when I can't contact anyone the depression worsens), so I am focusing on just getting to a doctor. Your advice about phrasing things positively is of particular help - I will have that in my mind as I address my problem in the future. I am very afraid of being taken into custody, even though I can honestly say I have no plans for self-harm. I just don't know the protocol, and I don't know what the consequences of my words will be. It makes me hesitant.
Thank you again for answering. You've helped so much.
@girl.of.your.dreams: Thank you for responding so quickly. I will be calling some of those numbers tomorrow, and I am grateful for the link. My insurance is pretty limited, and I know that I can't afford to pay anything for health services (unless I want to give up food or gasoline) - that link looks like it will be very helpful. I am considering reaching out to someone, but I don't really have anybody. I think I just need to focus on my own abilities to find professional help, and not set up expectations for help from people in my life. That's been a trigger in the past, and though I don't want to isolate myself, I think that being alone to face the problem now is probably best. I can't tell you how much your response meant. Thank you again.
@Habibiti: You're very welcome. Good luck with those numbers - I hope they're helpful. And remember - you're not alone in this. I know being depressed can be isolating (I've struggled with depression and anxiety for a good chunk of my life), but there are people who care about you.
@girl.of.your.dreams: Thanks for posting that. I remember a commenter a while back talking about free/low cost treatment in LA. Myabe that was you? I so wanted to repost but I couldn't find it!
@Habibiti: I was worried to talk about things with my GP at first, but he knows I am not at risk and I've been seeing my him for ten years. He's always done what he can, meds, referrals and just honest talk right back at me. Below some commenters are talking about therapists in training. Is there a Wright Institute near you? My friends and ex's have have success with their low cost psychotherapy. Know that you are not alone, you are seeking treatment and good luck!
MS Word and MS Excel are the two most worthless pieces of crap in the world. Seriously, WTF, the 2003 and 2007 versions have major compatibility issues and I could also write a dissertation on the worthlessness of the equation editor.
And the only thing more annoying than MS Office is Open Office!
I want to spend the next several years of my life developing spreadsheet and word processing software that doesn't suck.
Edited by pantsless economist...access RESTORED at 11/29/09 11:03 PM
pantsless economist...access RESTORED was starred
pantsless economist...access RESTORED was unstarred
@pantsless economist...access RESTORED: Can I join your club? Can we get matching jackets? You do realize, though, that most people using Excel have no notion of how deep they could go?
@pantsless economist...access RESTORED: I hate MS Office with a passion, but at least it's portable-sort of. I've been using Open Office at home, and when I get to work to print out my papers, they've magically been transformed into an inscrutable wall of Webdings. That I then get to copy into Word and entirely reformat. HATE IT!
@laetitiae: Yeah LaTeX!! It does work on PCs. I unfortunately am a slave to Microsoft since I'm usually transferring school work between my home computer, school computer labs, and my work computer, where I don't have the priveleges to install anything. So Word it is.
@SomeAuthorGirl: Let's make jackets. I like that idea. Excel can do some awesome stuff, and it pisses me off way less than Word, but there are some things about it (like, it maxes out at 65,000 rows!--and I actually need more than that often) that really bug me.
@Hooplehead: Yup. I feel bad knocking Open Office, since I'm all for free software and exchange of information, but it has totally webdinged me as well. Which is why I sucked it up and paid for Office.
@pantsless economist...access RESTORED: The compatibility issues are the WORST! My (large, international) office upgraded by groups. Meaning, it was pretty much impossible to share documents with anyone else when it's 100% required for our work. Good luck with your development!
@pantsless economist...access RESTORED: I know, I recently got into an argument about this with my friend the Linux purist. I appreciate the open source folks and support them when I can. But I work full time and go to school, so the current state of affairs is completely untenable. At the end of the day, I don't have time to do 5 million workarounds so I can say I use freeware. I just want a product that works, the first time. On all computers, with all features, whatever. And OpenOffice is not that product.
I don't really have anything against them, but does anybody else get really annoyed by people who think that listening to Manheim Steamroller and Trans Siberian Orchestra Christmas music makes them "edgy"?
@whats_in_a_name: I have never met such people, and I think if I did, I would have trouble not cracking up. I mean, I like them, but I'm fully aware of how dorky that makes me.
@whats_in_a_name: I've never heard of that happening. Does they think it makes them edgy because of hipster irony, or because the music is genuinely edgy?
@Meglantine: I work at a Starbucks, and honestly? You should know you're a barista's favorite kind of customer. You sit quietly and don't harrass people; you don't have small children; you're harried enough that you make us and our caffeine feel needed, but you don't make outrageous demands or abuse us like people with too much spare time do. I'd rather have a thousand of you sitting in our cafe, unobtrusively studying, than the hundred or so rich old ladies in their SUVs with their obnoxious yappy dogs sitting at the drive thru window bitching about how many pumps of whatever stupid crap they want in their damn drink or whatever.
Sorry, I just got off a shift that was way longer than it should've been and also it's like 75 degrees out here why the hell are people drinking coffee and it's Sunday so we were sold out of EVERYTHING and... yeah, I'm a little grumpy. But great good luck with your exams! I'm sure you'll do wonderfully.
@Meglantine: I won't yell at you. You remain one of my favorite-named commenters. Plus I indirectly sympathize, since I am the indulgent older sister that feeds, encourages, and buys beer for a law student.
@girlscoutcookie is back from hiatus: Just so you know. . .I love my baristas. I stop at my Starbucks every morning and I really appreciate the kind folks who work there and are a ray of sunshine every weekday (and some weekends). Sorry you had some shitty customers!
@BadgerChaser: Oh, and we love our regulars! (Well, except for Really Creepy Old Guy). It's so fun to see them every day and the delighted expressions they give us when we make their drinks without having to ask their order and chat about their lives. The assholes are never the commuters. They're the random business travelers off the interstate or entitled bitches on their way to a manicure or crazy county people who don't know what a latte is. Or the people who get mad that we don't carry all the flavors of bottled Frappuccinos. (Seriously. There are nine gas stations within sight of our store that have them. !!!!)
I've only had office jobs before this one, and let me tell you it's taught me a LOT about our society. I feel like everyone should have a fast-food or retail job at some point in their lives just to learn about, like, common courtesy and the value of labor. And to tip more. Always tip, everybody!
@girlscoutcookie is back from hiatus: In all the countries I've ever been to, all across Europe, Africa and Asia, I've never come across one in my entire life!
@chinaplate: I'm in the American South, and most of the freestanding ones (i.e. not in Target, Barnes & Noble, or a mall of some kind) I've seen do. Man, I wish ours didn't, though! It is a HUGE pain in the ass to work. My favorite thing ever is when somebody calls in sick and we have to shut it down because we don't have enough labor to run it.
@girlscoutcookie is back from hiatus: I don't think I know of anything in the UK that's a drive-through except McDonalds. Wow, my mind is seriously blown and I wish we had them here, but I've done a lot of behind-a-counter jobs and I can imagine they're even shittier when you're not even really face to face with your customers...
@chinaplate: Ah, the UK-- that explains it. Americans hate having to get out of their giant cars for anything. There are even drive-thru liquor stores-- well, in Louisiana there are.
@Tippi Hedren: If you watch Glee, several of the actors Tweet (Chris Colfer, in particular, is great and updates frequently: he's @ChrisColfer) but also several of the characters have Twitter accounts, which can be hilarious. @S_SylvesterGLEE, @RachelBerryGLEE, and @QuinnFabrayGLEE (I think Kurt has one too). Also, @ActuallyNPH (Neil Patrick Harris) and @Broslife (Barney Stinson) are TOO hysterical if you're a HIMYM fan.
Oh, you were asking about people who exist outside of television? I will just sit quietly, then.
Guys, guys. My shit is being flipped, and it sucks.
I know it's all old news and business, but I was reading around on stuff about The Last Airbender movie, wondering if people had come to their senses and were like, "durr, maybe Jackson Rathbone isn't the best choice to play an Inuit kid..." but they haven't.
It makes me sad. Avatar: The Last Airbender is a great show. I really enjoyed it, and it's been ages since I actually watched a TV series in its entirety. I know, I know, it's a kid's show, it's just one show, whatever, but this is so common.
Did anyone see the Dragonball movie? I mean, they managed to find Asian people to play Bulma and Roshi, but apparently Goku was TOO MUCH. I mean, after all, he's an ALIEN, right? He could be anything! Therefore, he's white. Huh. Except his fucking name is Goku, referred to as "Son Goku" and is based off "Journey to the West" (I think). But LOLLITY LOL LOL, let's make him white! 'Cause that makes sense. A Chinese legend, a Japanese creator/writer/artist team, and a whitey mcwhiterson main dude.
ATLA is a really great TV show, with a fair amount of racial diversity. The majority of characters are East or Southeast Asian, but there are white people and First Nation people as well. The creators of the show don't support the film's casting and have distanced themselves from the project, repeating that they have nothing to do with it other than the original source material, which is owned by Nickelodeon, not them, if I remember correctly. It's so frustrating. This was a chance to show that race really didn't matter - Aang can save the world if he's Tibetan. Katara and Sokka are just as relevant to kids if they're Inuit. Toph is still a delightful jerk even if she's Chinese.
People bitch about anime characters looking white, but it's not really accurate. Someone said it better than I will, but! I will say it anyway. It's all ethnocentrism. I, as a white American, basically see the "neutral" face as white. It's me. It's my culture. You draw a face with two dots for eyes and a line for a mouth, and white Americans tend to see it as a white, male face. We make it non-white, non-male by making marks on the face: eyelashes, shading in skin color, changing the shape of the eyes, whathaveyou.
If you do this with Japanese people, they tend to see it as a Japanese face. Because "neutral" is them. So, crazy hair colors and giant eyes and long legs don't have to be marked to be Japanese, it's just assumed. People with light hair and eyes exist in Asian ethnicities, but are rare, so you don't see them often. So, when they want to represent something outside of Japanese ethnicity, they mark it. Not that Japan is a bastion of racial understanding and ethnicity, but it's just a different way of viewing the world. Ethnocentrically, since most of us are a little ethnocentric and you can't really even stop it.
Honestly, it feels like watching the episode where the heroes watch a live play version of their lives and everyone is cast terribly. Except this is real.
Any other ATLA fans out there that are just kinda disappointed in the whole shebang?
@boxspelunker: I feel like I'm on the complete opposite end of the spectrum. I'm gonna make myself look reeeeaaaal bad here, but I'm only planning on seeing the movie BECAUSE Jackson Rathbone's in it. But you're totally spot-on about everything you said--I had no idea his character was originally Inuit.
@boxspelunker: I cosign you on all levels! The cartoon has a boatload of diff asian ethnicities represented but in the chase for the almighty dollar the whole movie gets white washed! Urgh!
@boxspelunker: Meee! I yelled in my room when that happened and watched all the old episodes, which are now tinged with this stupid fucking decision. I've barred my brother from going and I plan on watching it online with angry fervor.
The most annoying thing is M. Night Shyamalon. Fuck you, dude. I can't believe I thought you were cool for making Stuart Little. That was all Michael J. Fox anyway. God, what a prick.
For more outrage, check out racialicious.
I also love how people like to say, "Well there are more white actors and if they wanted to pick the best actor it would probably end up being a white cos there's more of them..." Um, THAT'S NOT HOW IT WORKS. God, even in fucking New Moon they had a bunch of Native American actors to play Native Americans, and how Native American actors do you think there are in comparison to white actors??
Another thing that breaks my heart is how General Zhao and Zuko are played by Aasif Mandvi and Dev Patel. I love them both dearly, but honestly, those are the whitest characters in the show!!
And on your cultural "neutral" thing...that's not a white American thing, it's a fully American thing: the neutral is seen as white, heterosexual, and male, and any deviation from that norm is considered a qualifying characteristic in terms of the character/person.
@boxspelunker: I am more than disappointed. I am at red-alert levels of rage. When the first pics of the live-action cast in costume appeared online, I had to shut my laptop, I was so angry (look! a white kid in an Inuit outfit!). Even thinking about them now, I can feel my blood pressure go up.
I heard about the series only because of the "Aang ain't white" chatter on the race-focused blogs I read, and so many folks said it was awesome I decided to check it out. I watched all three seasons in about 3 weeks and LOVED it. I want to get box sets for all the little non-white kids (and hell, the white kids too) I know because it's SO RARE that non-white kids get to be the focus of a story/TV show/movie and are shown to be heroes that save the world. The TV show is so good, so funny, so exciting, and so OBVIOUSLY based on Asian and Inuit cultures. What the fucking fuck makes someone watch that and then decide to cast white actors? I mean, it's not even like The Last Samurai where we get some white character's story shoehorned into an Asian setting -- these characters ARE NOT WHITE (who did you see that seemed white? I didn't see anyone I read as white).
And I'm white! I can't imagine how enraging and painful it must be for Asian-Americans to watch this unfold -- the dominant culture is basically telling them they're unacceptable as anything other than a sidekick or stereotype, that only white people are important enough to get their own stories and that Asians can never, ever be the hero.
Seriously, I can't even talk about the movie. I'll probably have to self-medicate once the previews and posters start showing up everywhere.
@aclikeslater: I'm not gonna begrudge anyone a favorite actor or anything :D The casting is upsetting for so many reasons. I mean, it'll probably be a good movie, fun to watch, entertaining, all that. I just wish they'd used their powers for good, you know?
@Acolyte: I know! And how creepy is it that they made the Good Nations white and the Bad Nation dark? I understand wanting to make the nations ethnically homogeneous, since they were in the show, but now it's Dark Menace against White Purity :(
@ameliabearhart: OMG have you seen the casting calls? They are specifically skewed white for Sokka, Katara and Aang. Odd, I don't see Toph in there anywhere. Is she even going to be in the movie? She's kinda... important.
I can't believe how they've handled it. Video from casting calls/auditions are on YouTube, and there are tons of little Asian kids. This guy: [www.youtube.com]
His delivery is a little flat, but his skills are awesome. I mean, with training, he could probably get better comedic timing and more natural delivery. I think he would have been great.
I didn't want to generalize too much with the "default face" thing. I know I do it. But if you tell me, "No, that's a black girl," I say, "Okay," and there's no problem. It's hard to change your kneejerk reaction to what you've been socialized to believe is normal. I know that this face does not need any other marker to indicate that it is not white and male, but that's still the first thing I think of :( I know that's a lot of what anime is criticized on, and I had to argue it with people since... oh, forever.
@boxspelunker: I am, and *massively* disappointed. And hoping that when (WHEN, not if) this racefail catastrophe sinks at the box office, the media powers that be won't assume that the source material is unmarketable and shelve the series. Because nooooo, it's the *racefail* that's going to mess this up.
Gah. I share your frustration because I also hoped the racebend petition would have, you know, changed something. Come to their senses. Yeah.
Hollywood and it's dumbass ideas about how only white male heros can sell can go die in a FIRE and stuff. Seriously.
I'm not a Dragonball fan, but that sounds horrific. Son Goku is pretty damn Japanese. And it's really *special* how they always manage to keep the villains and more marginal characters non-white, if they absolutely must have non-white people at all.
Haaaaaaaaate.
Anyway, yeah. Avatar ruled so hard and this makes me sad right along with ya.
@greeneyedfem: I'm mostly out of rage, since it's so tiring, but then I read something and I'm all GRARBLARGLEBLAR.
I love the show for many reasons - great writing, good comedy, engaging characters and excellent pacing all make me want to watch the show. The jokes are still funny when you watch it through more than once, which is nice.
But one of the things that made me really appreciate it is that it treats so many "othered" people as normal. Toph is blind, and while it comes up often (usually her pointing out others' privilege, which I find really funny), she's not marginalized by her friends because of it - in fact, her parents' treatment of her is a big part of her anger and how she deals with people. Katara is quick to point out her brother's sexism, and Aang challenges a ton of gender and heroic norms - he's "younger" than everyone (a physical child), he's vegetarian, a pacifist, answers to the nickname "Twinkletoes", and makes jewelry for fun. It makes all these interesting, different characters from what we're used to seeing in American media, and doesn't focus in on that. Aang simply is. And on top of this, there's a bunch of ethnic/racial diversity! Katara being dark didn't make me relate to her any less. I appreciated her character, I related to her because she is like me, I am like her, in many ways.
Part of eradicating racism is to neutralize the way we think of race (good/bad, known/unknown dichotomies). Children growing up with heroes of different backgrounds and abilities than themselves can more easily relate to real people of different backgrounds, because they're used to it. They start to see others as "like them", and that's where curing racism can really gain a foothold. It's not erasing ethnic differences, it's promoting understanding between people and the similarities we have. Our skin color shouldn't make us incapable of relating to one another.
So this movie just takes that and smashes it all over the place - kids (white kids, they mean) don't want to see actors of color! So let's whitewash the whole thing. Except... wait, the show was huge, and the characters were not white.
I mean, I can almost see the argument for Aang, if you haven't seen the show, as he is very light-skinned, but then you look at his clothing and all that, and it's like, well, he's probably Asian. Maybe kids don't get that, but honestly, I think they do. Especially kids of color. They can recognize Aang as like them, and they probably like it.
It just enrages me that there is:
1. So little respect for the source material. When the creators disown your spinoff, that's bad.
2. So little respect for the wishes of the fans - they're the ones who are going to make your movie sink or swim, and they don't like what they see.
3. So little knowledge of the racist traditions of Hollywood, or, if they do know, the lack of initiative to do anything about it.
4. That Fire Nation people will now be dark-skinned, while the Air and Water Nations are white. Making it so that the evil dark people are coming after the good light people.
ARGH. I'm glad there are others that feel this way.
@indiciabrocade: I... didn't even think of that. If the movie fails, will the TV show sink along with it? I sure hope not. That would be awful. I appreciate that effort that the creators and director put into this. I want the TV show to be on Nick, and not disappear with the movie. Racefail, indeed :(
@boxspelunker: Even though that show was marketed towards kids, I found it remarkably intelligent and thoughtful. I'm really disappointed that it's going in this direction.
I'm consistently disappointed when American movies have white protagonists when it doesn't even make sense. This is a minor example, but I read the book Bringing Down the House, about a bunch of MIT students who outwitted casinos and made millions. Most of the students were Asian, and this actually was a significant plot point: the casinos were possibly less suspicious of them because they seemed like stereotypical studious Asian kids. However, in the movie, the main character was white. It was a really stupid change.
Another way movie studios do this is by having an entire cast of another ethnicity but still have a white central character. Look at The Last Samurai! It's about the beauty and honor in Japanese culture, but of course the hero is some white dude, because movie studios don't think white audiences will be able to relate to a non-white lead.
I can see it changing slowly, I think. I know The Princess and the Frog has its issues, but the fact is that it's a movie with an awesome black protagonist, and it's marketed towards kids of all backgrounds. I think this next generation is going to grow up to some extent feeling that it's normal and standard to relate to people of all races. Maybe the next generation or the one after that will no longer "need" a white protagonist to find a movie or character relatable.
@boxspelunker: I'm pretty sure the tv show still performs at high levels of win, gets ratings, works well in syndication, etc. So I don't think (cross fingers!) the movie fail will hurt it. Nemesis tanked, and the various Trek shows were still merrily in syndication. Hell, the X-files movie tanked too, and it's still around.
I'm just worried that this is the only Avatar movie we'll get. And it's such a stupid reason to ruin it too. I've heard too many stories of studio executives claiming that '(series) doesn't sell because (series movie with studio meddling FAIL added) tanked (because of FAIL).'
SADFACE.
But at least the show itself should remain untouched in it's awesome.
Edited by Teh Indiciiia, professional flower whore at 11/30/09 12:54 AM
Teh Indiciiia, professional flower whore was starred
Teh Indiciiia, professional flower whore was unstarred
@Oleander: I did, too. I enjoyed it a lot, and it's depressing to have something that I feel was so positive be kinda trounced on.
I had never heard of the MIT thing. That's really interesting.
I heard that many of the extras will be Asian or of other non-white descent. Which is a good start, but unfortunately doesn't address the main issue.
However, I hope that because of the giant racefail of this whole thing, maybe people will pay better attention to these sorts of things. Maybe this fight can't be won, but it can be used as reference to win future ones.
@indiciabrocade: Oh, yeah :( I would love to see a well-done ATLA movie. I think it would be great. Like I said to the poster above, maybe this film can be used as a reference as to why race matters in media. And then, future awesome can be preserved!
@Mr.Gawn: Yes, I will be offended. The characters in those movies/TV shows appear to have defined ethnic categories, and care should be taken to preserve what the characters are. Akira is a strongly Japanese story, and the characters should look like the characters in the original film.
Ghost in the Shell is a little more flexible, but the Major is intended to appear Japanese as well. She should look it in live-action, too.
Cowboy Bebop is the only one that I'm not sure if the characters have distinct ethnicities. With names like "Spike Spiegel" and "Faye Valentine", they may not be Japanese. With Keanu Reeves apparently playing Spike, they've already made that choice, I suppose.
These things need to be discussed before the studios make final decisions. Fans are the ones who will support the final product, so they matter.
@lalie (apologetic mess): Maybe he's avoiding carbs? Because that sounds like a baked potato without the potato. Also, minus the sour cream, like something I would totally do.
@girlscoutcookie is back from hiatus: Well, considering he also had three taco wraps (consisting of refried beans, rice, ground beef, and more cheese and sour cream) and some beer, I don't think that was the issue.
@missing_piece: Nope, but diabetes and having no colon definitely is. He just likes to pretend those don't exist. Bah!
@lalie (apologetic mess): I think this is inherently father behavior. Last Christmas, my bf's dad used Thai chili oil as a pasta topping after we ran out of spaghetti sauce. And I don't mean a polite tablespoon, I mean, the WHOLE jar. I had to physically take it away from him because I actually needed the stuff for a recipe and he wasn't leaving me any.
@lalie (apologetic mess): My dad eats tuna out of the can with lettuce and calls it a "salad". The man also puts Velveeta on a huge-ass mushroom, microwaves it until it smells like broiled ass, and eats it with Bacon Bits on top. He's like a 65 year old professor BTW
@salthegeek: Unpacking is so painful... I just do it as fast as I can right when I get to my place of destination, before I can think about having to do it and sulk.
@salthegeek: I do. I've been known to let suitcases untouched in the living room for weeks just because I don't feel like unpacking. And by weeks, I mean that last week I finally unpacked my baggage from a trip to Miami. Three weeks after I came back.
Procrastination is my imaginary middle name. And I honor it constantly.
@salthegeek: I still haven't entirely unpacked from visiting home on Thanksgiving. I just search for something and leave the other items totally intact.
@salthegeek: Both packing and unpacking give me anxiety. so does anything that resembles cleaning or organizing. I do a poor imitation of a responsible adult.
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
Anyway, I want to do something for him that will remind him of home. Is there anything specific that people in Georgia do for Thanksgiving? Or just some Georgia tradition, or dish, or thing, or whatever I can do to make him feel welcome and less homesick and less convinced that Canadians are shitty? (Because we're not -- just a little flaky and daft sometimes!)
Anyway, thoughts are appreciated. Otherwise, he's getting the Canadian rhymeswithfeather Thanksgiving specialty -- me, a case of cheap beer, a joint, two forks and a pumpkin pie (with real whipped cream, natch).
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
@All - Thanks so much! I love the random conjectures from a bunch of non-Georgians ;) Glad you're all as lost as me. Oh, and as for that 'sweet tea' nonsense, all iced tea is sweetened in the great white north, so maybe I'll just so some of that with straight up vodka. I dig, I dig! It will surely go nicely with pumpkin (or pecan!) pie.
11/30/09
11/30/09
@rhymeswithfeather: Sweet ice tea. Pecan pie. Biscuits. These are all typical Southern foods that most Southerners will appreciate. (Except me, because I'm weird. See above.) You should Google Paula Deen. She has a show on Food Network, and she's from Georgia. Her food looks amazing, and it might give you some ideas.
11/30/09
11/29/09
On the bright side, I got to drive through the 25E tunnel in the Cumberland Gap. It was AWESOME.
11/30/09
11/29/09
This isn't eating leftovers: she makes a second Thanksgiving dinner for the immediate family, complete with two different kinds of pie. It. Was. Epic.
11/29/09
11/29/09
Oink, baby.
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
Luckily, it may be next Thanksgiving before I see her. She won't ask me about it. But I take everyone's point and will wait a decorous amount of time.
11/29/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/29/09
What do you lovely folks listen to at the gym? Missy Elliott is my favorite work out music... but I think I need a little more variety!
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
[www.thehoodinternet.com]
Mash up artists. Great mixes. And all of their songs are free.
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/30/09
I made the list because I was hoping you might be open to other types of music, but I'm more used to being wrong about that. I'm the same way though- I go from Lady GaGa to Nattefrost without a second thought.
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/29/09
I'm hoping to benefit from any resources you may all know of for help treating depression. For me it's been a lifelong struggle - my depression pervades memories from early childhood - and so I'm beginning to suspect that it is physical and not situational. I'm going through a very extreme low right now, which has lasted almost a year. This week I actually began feeling better, and so I want to address my problem while I'm clear-headed (before a trigger sends me back to a place where I cannot reach out for help). I'm asking here if anyone knows of a good resource to get help. I have attempted to talk to counselors before without success, but am willing to try again if I can find a way to afford it (I'm not in school, and don't know of any community services near me). I want to talk to a doctor, but I'm afraid to answer the questions because I don't want them to believe I'm at risk for self-harm. I don't have anyone in my life right now who I trust enough to reach out to. Where should I go to get help? How do you bring up the topic of depression with a doctor?
Any advice, personal experience, links, etc. would be much appreciated. I'm in the L.A./Orange County area if that helps.
Thank you so much.
11/29/09
[vimeo.com]
I don't really know anything about the mental health services in that area however.
11/29/09
I pushed myself for a long time before my depression got bad enough to be hospitalized. Now with talk therapy and medication, I'm doing a lot better. The difference is night and day.
Also, remember that:
1) You might not connect with any given therapist. Don't give up on therapists altogether because of one bad one. I had an awful therapist in high school, but I have a great one now.
2) Medication is much better than it used to be. The one I'm on now basically just makes me feel more like myself, just without the crushing despair. I'm a little sleepier, but if it means the ability to feel joy, I'll take it.
3) You can do it! The biggest step is wanting to get better. Once you get over that hump, the rest is easy.
In terms of cost, one of my friends was doing a free clinic thing for a little while, but you get limited to a certain number of appointments, which isn't super helpful if you need more than that. Find out if your insurance covers this sort of thing, and if they have any recommended places.
Finally-- GOOD LUCK!
11/29/09
most likely they will simply test you and make recommendations but you must understand that if you show any real indicators of self harm, it may behoove you for them to take you into custody. the latter rarely happens.
But this doesn't mean you should delay any treatment so I'm glad you are showing interest.
back to the doctor visit:
you need to find out whether there are any nutritional deficiencies. I've posted several times, here, that i became severely depressed and suicidal over the course of a year and it was found I had severe B12 and vitamin D deficiencies. Nutrition, excercise and sleep habits play a big part in a lot of depression cases.
if all is well on the health front then you may want to reach out to this organization for referrals.
[www.mhaoc.org]
I would also recommend, if you haven't already, telling at least one person close to you about your battle - it is important to have someone who knows your situation, especially when you seem to go in and out of more serious episodes.
11/29/09
On that note, you should try to find something like that that makes you really happy. Singing (loudly) always makes me feel a lot more whole.
11/29/09
specific to that area, i saw a couple people at hope international university. it was just counseling, no medication, but they matched me pretty well.
you're doing good by taking that first step. i would also look around to see if there is anyone that you can trust. i know it's hard if you don't have anyone, but you might be surprised by how willing to help people are.
i would bring it up in any way that is comfortable with you. i would also focus things in a positive way, like if you've found that you don't have the energy for things you used to enjoy, say that you want to be able to go out and live your life. you could also say that you're tired of feeling crappy.
i know it's hard, but if you are at risk for self harm, that's something that you're going to have to address. they probably won't immediately lock you up somewhere, but it is a very real part of the illness and should be included in your treatment plan.
best of luck, i'll be sending positive energy your way.
11/29/09
I live in the LA area, but I have health insurance right now (I get the impression from your post that you don't). A quick search directed me to this site, which I remember seeing when I first moved to LA. I'm not sure that it's up-to-date, but this page has a whole list of free and low-cost mental health services in LA County:
[www.ihatemylife.us] (And yes, I know it's called "ihatemylife" which sounds very negative. But it's actually a blog about someone who got out of homelessness.)
Best of luck! xoxo
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
Thank you again for answering. You've helped so much.
11/29/09
you do need a formal evaluation and some health tests so I'm glad you are keen on doing that.
you are important and your life has value - don't ever forget that.
11/29/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/29/09
MS Word and MS Excel are the two most worthless pieces of crap in the world. Seriously, WTF, the 2003 and 2007 versions have major compatibility issues and I could also write a dissertation on the worthlessness of the equation editor.
And the only thing more annoying than MS Office is Open Office!
I want to spend the next several years of my life developing spreadsheet and word processing software that doesn't suck.
11/29/09
11/29/09
*Note: I am a spreadsheet dork.
11/29/09
11/29/09
@SomeAuthorGirl: Let's make jackets. I like that idea. Excel can do some awesome stuff, and it pisses me off way less than Word, but there are some things about it (like, it maxes out at 65,000 rows!--and I actually need more than that often) that really bug me.
11/29/09
This is such a first world problem.
11/29/09
11/30/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
You should probably yell at me.
11/29/09
Sorry, I just got off a shift that was way longer than it should've been and also it's like 75 degrees out here why the hell are people drinking coffee and it's Sunday so we were sold out of EVERYTHING and... yeah, I'm a little grumpy. But great good luck with your exams! I'm sure you'll do wonderfully.
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
I've only had office jobs before this one, and let me tell you it's taught me a LOT about our society. I feel like everyone should have a fast-food or retail job at some point in their lives just to learn about, like, common courtesy and the value of labor. And to tip more. Always tip, everybody!
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/30/09
11/29/09
Who are some interesting folks that you all follow?
11/29/09
Oh, you were asking about people who exist outside of television? I will just sit quietly, then.
11/29/09
I know it's all old news and business, but I was reading around on stuff about The Last Airbender movie, wondering if people had come to their senses and were like, "durr, maybe Jackson Rathbone isn't the best choice to play an Inuit kid..." but they haven't.
It makes me sad. Avatar: The Last Airbender is a great show. I really enjoyed it, and it's been ages since I actually watched a TV series in its entirety. I know, I know, it's a kid's show, it's just one show, whatever, but this is so common.
Did anyone see the Dragonball movie? I mean, they managed to find Asian people to play Bulma and Roshi, but apparently Goku was TOO MUCH. I mean, after all, he's an ALIEN, right? He could be anything! Therefore, he's white. Huh. Except his fucking name is Goku, referred to as "Son Goku" and is based off "Journey to the West" (I think). But LOLLITY LOL LOL, let's make him white! 'Cause that makes sense. A Chinese legend, a Japanese creator/writer/artist team, and a whitey mcwhiterson main dude.
ATLA is a really great TV show, with a fair amount of racial diversity. The majority of characters are East or Southeast Asian, but there are white people and First Nation people as well. The creators of the show don't support the film's casting and have distanced themselves from the project, repeating that they have nothing to do with it other than the original source material, which is owned by Nickelodeon, not them, if I remember correctly. It's so frustrating. This was a chance to show that race really didn't matter - Aang can save the world if he's Tibetan. Katara and Sokka are just as relevant to kids if they're Inuit. Toph is still a delightful jerk even if she's Chinese.
People bitch about anime characters looking white, but it's not really accurate. Someone said it better than I will, but! I will say it anyway. It's all ethnocentrism. I, as a white American, basically see the "neutral" face as white. It's me. It's my culture. You draw a face with two dots for eyes and a line for a mouth, and white Americans tend to see it as a white, male face. We make it non-white, non-male by making marks on the face: eyelashes, shading in skin color, changing the shape of the eyes, whathaveyou.
If you do this with Japanese people, they tend to see it as a Japanese face. Because "neutral" is them. So, crazy hair colors and giant eyes and long legs don't have to be marked to be Japanese, it's just assumed. People with light hair and eyes exist in Asian ethnicities, but are rare, so you don't see them often. So, when they want to represent something outside of Japanese ethnicity, they mark it. Not that Japan is a bastion of racial understanding and ethnicity, but it's just a different way of viewing the world. Ethnocentrically, since most of us are a little ethnocentric and you can't really even stop it.
Honestly, it feels like watching the episode where the heroes watch a live play version of their lives and everyone is cast terribly. Except this is real.
Any other ATLA fans out there that are just kinda disappointed in the whole shebang?
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
The most annoying thing is M. Night Shyamalon. Fuck you, dude. I can't believe I thought you were cool for making Stuart Little. That was all Michael J. Fox anyway. God, what a prick.
For more outrage, check out racialicious.
I also love how people like to say, "Well there are more white actors and if they wanted to pick the best actor it would probably end up being a white cos there's more of them..." Um, THAT'S NOT HOW IT WORKS. God, even in fucking New Moon they had a bunch of Native American actors to play Native Americans, and how Native American actors do you think there are in comparison to white actors??
Another thing that breaks my heart is how General Zhao and Zuko are played by Aasif Mandvi and Dev Patel. I love them both dearly, but honestly, those are the whitest characters in the show!!
And on your cultural "neutral" thing...that's not a white American thing, it's a fully American thing: the neutral is seen as white, heterosexual, and male, and any deviation from that norm is considered a qualifying characteristic in terms of the character/person.
11/29/09
I heard about the series only because of the "Aang ain't white" chatter on the race-focused blogs I read, and so many folks said it was awesome I decided to check it out. I watched all three seasons in about 3 weeks and LOVED it. I want to get box sets for all the little non-white kids (and hell, the white kids too) I know because it's SO RARE that non-white kids get to be the focus of a story/TV show/movie and are shown to be heroes that save the world. The TV show is so good, so funny, so exciting, and so OBVIOUSLY based on Asian and Inuit cultures. What the fucking fuck makes someone watch that and then decide to cast white actors? I mean, it's not even like The Last Samurai where we get some white character's story shoehorned into an Asian setting -- these characters ARE NOT WHITE (who did you see that seemed white? I didn't see anyone I read as white).
And I'm white! I can't imagine how enraging and painful it must be for Asian-Americans to watch this unfold -- the dominant culture is basically telling them they're unacceptable as anything other than a sidekick or stereotype, that only white people are important enough to get their own stories and that Asians can never, ever be the hero.
Seriously, I can't even talk about the movie. I'll probably have to self-medicate once the previews and posters start showing up everywhere.
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
I can't believe how they've handled it. Video from casting calls/auditions are on YouTube, and there are tons of little Asian kids. This guy: [www.youtube.com]
His delivery is a little flat, but his skills are awesome. I mean, with training, he could probably get better comedic timing and more natural delivery. I think he would have been great.
I didn't want to generalize too much with the "default face" thing. I know I do it. But if you tell me, "No, that's a black girl," I say, "Okay," and there's no problem. It's hard to change your kneejerk reaction to what you've been socialized to believe is normal. I know that this face does not need any other marker to indicate that it is not white and male, but that's still the first thing I think of :( I know that's a lot of what anime is criticized on, and I had to argue it with people since... oh, forever.
11/29/09
Gah. I share your frustration because I also hoped the racebend petition would have, you know, changed something. Come to their senses. Yeah.
Hollywood and it's dumbass ideas about how only white male heros can sell can go die in a FIRE and stuff. Seriously.
I'm not a Dragonball fan, but that sounds horrific. Son Goku is pretty damn Japanese. And it's really *special* how they always manage to keep the villains and more marginal characters non-white, if they absolutely must have non-white people at all.
Haaaaaaaaate.
Anyway, yeah. Avatar ruled so hard and this makes me sad right along with ya.
11/30/09
I love the show for many reasons - great writing, good comedy, engaging characters and excellent pacing all make me want to watch the show. The jokes are still funny when you watch it through more than once, which is nice.
But one of the things that made me really appreciate it is that it treats so many "othered" people as normal. Toph is blind, and while it comes up often (usually her pointing out others' privilege, which I find really funny), she's not marginalized by her friends because of it - in fact, her parents' treatment of her is a big part of her anger and how she deals with people. Katara is quick to point out her brother's sexism, and Aang challenges a ton of gender and heroic norms - he's "younger" than everyone (a physical child), he's vegetarian, a pacifist, answers to the nickname "Twinkletoes", and makes jewelry for fun. It makes all these interesting, different characters from what we're used to seeing in American media, and doesn't focus in on that. Aang simply is. And on top of this, there's a bunch of ethnic/racial diversity! Katara being dark didn't make me relate to her any less. I appreciated her character, I related to her because she is like me, I am like her, in many ways.
Part of eradicating racism is to neutralize the way we think of race (good/bad, known/unknown dichotomies). Children growing up with heroes of different backgrounds and abilities than themselves can more easily relate to real people of different backgrounds, because they're used to it. They start to see others as "like them", and that's where curing racism can really gain a foothold. It's not erasing ethnic differences, it's promoting understanding between people and the similarities we have. Our skin color shouldn't make us incapable of relating to one another.
So this movie just takes that and smashes it all over the place - kids (white kids, they mean) don't want to see actors of color! So let's whitewash the whole thing. Except... wait, the show was huge, and the characters were not white.
I mean, I can almost see the argument for Aang, if you haven't seen the show, as he is very light-skinned, but then you look at his clothing and all that, and it's like, well, he's probably Asian. Maybe kids don't get that, but honestly, I think they do. Especially kids of color. They can recognize Aang as like them, and they probably like it.
It just enrages me that there is:
1. So little respect for the source material. When the creators disown your spinoff, that's bad.
2. So little respect for the wishes of the fans - they're the ones who are going to make your movie sink or swim, and they don't like what they see.
3. So little knowledge of the racist traditions of Hollywood, or, if they do know, the lack of initiative to do anything about it.
4. That Fire Nation people will now be dark-skinned, while the Air and Water Nations are white. Making it so that the evil dark people are coming after the good light people.
ARGH. I'm glad there are others that feel this way.
11/30/09
11/30/09
I'm consistently disappointed when American movies have white protagonists when it doesn't even make sense. This is a minor example, but I read the book Bringing Down the House, about a bunch of MIT students who outwitted casinos and made millions. Most of the students were Asian, and this actually was a significant plot point: the casinos were possibly less suspicious of them because they seemed like stereotypical studious Asian kids. However, in the movie, the main character was white. It was a really stupid change.
Another way movie studios do this is by having an entire cast of another ethnicity but still have a white central character. Look at The Last Samurai! It's about the beauty and honor in Japanese culture, but of course the hero is some white dude, because movie studios don't think white audiences will be able to relate to a non-white lead.
I can see it changing slowly, I think. I know The Princess and the Frog has its issues, but the fact is that it's a movie with an awesome black protagonist, and it's marketed towards kids of all backgrounds. I think this next generation is going to grow up to some extent feeling that it's normal and standard to relate to people of all races. Maybe the next generation or the one after that will no longer "need" a white protagonist to find a movie or character relatable.
11/30/09
I'm just worried that this is the only Avatar movie we'll get. And it's such a stupid reason to ruin it too. I've heard too many stories of studio executives claiming that '(series) doesn't sell because (series movie with studio meddling FAIL added) tanked (because of FAIL).'
SADFACE.
But at least the show itself should remain untouched in it's awesome.
11/30/09
im sure it will EVENTUALLY HAPPEN....
but i feel ya
12/05/09
I had never heard of the MIT thing. That's really interesting.
I heard that many of the extras will be Asian or of other non-white descent. Which is a good start, but unfortunately doesn't address the main issue.
However, I hope that because of the giant racefail of this whole thing, maybe people will pay better attention to these sorts of things. Maybe this fight can't be won, but it can be used as reference to win future ones.
12/05/09
12/05/09
Ghost in the Shell is a little more flexible, but the Major is intended to appear Japanese as well. She should look it in live-action, too.
Cowboy Bebop is the only one that I'm not sure if the characters have distinct ethnicities. With names like "Spike Spiegel" and "Faye Valentine", they may not be Japanese. With Keanu Reeves apparently playing Spike, they've already made that choice, I suppose.
These things need to be discussed before the studios make final decisions. Fans are the ones who will support the final product, so they matter.
11/29/09
My father just ate an entire bowl of shredded cheddar with sour cream on top.
Sometimes I wonder if my dad is a real person or just a lifelong performance artist fucking with my entire perception of normalcy.
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
(seriously though, this made me chuckle)
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
@missing_piece: Nope, but diabetes and having no colon definitely is. He just likes to pretend those don't exist. Bah!
11/29/09
11/30/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
11/29/09
Procrastination is my imaginary middle name. And I honor it constantly.
11/29/09
11/29/09