unitedstates - Jezebel

posts about #unitedstates more →
"Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
Many Egyptian Men Think Women Deserve To Be Harassed

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

girl.of.your.dreams
04/30/09

In reply to "Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
A friend of mine made a film about these specific women: [thehouseofsharing.com]

They are a fascinating, brave group of women.
Reply

hello.kitty
04/30/09

@girl.of.your.dreams: Kudos to your friend.
Reply

hello.kitty was starred hello.kitty was unstarred

maneki neko
04/30/09

In reply to "Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
I'm writing a research paper on this very subject right now, and it's so incredibly difficult to wrap my mind around.

On the one hand, I can understand that the Japanese people today wouldn't want to be blamed for atrocities like what was done to these women, or the Nanjing massacre, or any of the other horrible crimes, any more than I would want to be blamed for the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki as an American. But at the same time, these atrocities didn't just happen, someone did them. The USA takes responsibility for the atom bombs, although I have my doubts about the common sentiment that they were necessary to prevent a land invasion.

In order for these women to get the justice they deserve, shouldn't somebody take responsibility for it, acknowledging that their suffering occurred and it was wrong? But whose responsibility is it? I'm guessing the Japanese would argue that those who are responsible are long dead...
Reply

maneki neko was starred maneki neko was unstarred

topsy
04/30/09

@maneki neko: That's what pisses me off the most. All the Japanese have to say is 'Hiroshima' and that's the end of the discussion. Hiroshima was an atrocity but as you mentioned, the US has taken responsibility for it (the more I've studied the Japanese involvement in WWII the more credence I give to the land invasion argument). Germany has taken responsibility for the Holocaust. Yet the Japanese refuse to own up to its many, many war crimes. Maybe it's because most of the victims weren't white. The UK has never hesitated to discuss what the Japanese did to white members of the Commonwealth (A Town Called Alice anyone) but ignores anything else. These women will die and never, ever, get the justice and the apology they deserve. Shame on Japan and shame on us for letting Japan get away with it.
Reply

topsy was starred topsy was unstarred

hello.kitty
04/30/09

In reply to "Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
The government--and other responsible parties--will not apologize for this atrocity. Not during these women's life times.

They won't apologize because they feel their actions were justified. Did plantation owners who abused their female slaves apologize?

As roodles already posted: "I'm pretty sure the Japanese government is just waiting until these women die."

But h*lla yes for those women who continue to protest outside the embassy. Keep making noise, show the world you cannot be silenced.
Reply

hello.kitty was starred hello.kitty was unstarred

gobblegirl
04/30/09

In reply to "Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
This is really neat, and heartwarming in an odd way. I learned about the comfort women in high school, and it's such a sad story. I'm glad these women have some comfort of their own now, no pun intended.
Reply

gobblegirl was starred gobblegirl was unstarred

gobblegirl
04/30/09

@gobblegirl: Material comfort at least.
Reply

gobblegirl was starred gobblegirl was unstarred

mayfly
04/30/09

In reply to "Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
What the fuck, Japanese government? How hard it it to apologize for something so completely heinous? Are you too busy playing RapePlay to even address this?
Reply

mayfly was starred mayfly was unstarred

gobblegirl
04/30/09

@mayfly: Anything to do with the Japanese actions in WWII is extremely politically contentious in Japan, for obvious reasons. The government has been criticized for decades on their behaviour after the American occupation, because in many ways the official line has been to move on and forget about it. School textbooks print lies and deliberate omissions, and as a society their ties to recent history are fuzzy and complex, I think.

It's really interesting from a history/political science point of view to compare the post-war attitude toward "war guilt" in Japan and Germany, as it's been very different in both countries.

Anyway, I think to compare an incredibly complex cultural identity issue (and I'm not saying they shouldn't apologize, because they should) with the fact that Japan happens to export a lot of weird and scary porn is way missing the point.
Reply

gobblegirl was starred gobblegirl was unstarred

maneki neko
04/30/09

@gobblegirl: Very well said. There are dozens upon dozens of books that have been written about Japanese War guilt. It's an extremely contentious issue, and the answer to the question "Why don't they apologize?" is going to be a hard one to answer. (I'm actually doing research on this right now, so I'm pretty interested by this post.)

Part of it has to do with the fact that the Japanese government now doesn't see themselves of a continuation of the wartime government, based on the presence of the anti-war Article 9 in their constitution, and the general tendency of the culture to separate itself or blame everything on the military. But it's a hell of a lot more complicated than that...
Reply

maneki neko was starred maneki neko was unstarred

Sputnik_Sweetheart
04/30/09

In reply to "Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
I saw a group of former comfort women protesting in front of the Japanese embassy in South Korea. It makes me so sad that the Japanese government refuses to give theses women any closure or dignity. All that many of them want is just an apology. I saw signs taped up in Seoul that said "As long as Japan exists, there will never be peace." There is so much anger still, I wish Japan would try to make some amends.
Reply

Sputnik_Sweetheart was starred

samethingwedoeverynightpinky
04/30/09

In reply to "Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
These women are amazing.
Reply

cupscake
04/30/09

In reply to "Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
they would also need to appologize to the Filipina Comfort Women too!
Reply

cupscake was starred cupscake was unstarred

hello.kitty
04/30/09

@cupscake: Yes indeed!
Reply

hello.kitty was starred hello.kitty was unstarred

roodles
04/30/09

In reply to "Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
I'm pretty sure the Japanese government is just waiting until these women die b/c they will never apologize for it. I think this was the first year that the president didn't visit Yasukuni to basically pay homage to dead Japanese war criminals that did horrible things in Korea and Manchuria so regret and restitution are not at the forefront of the Japanese government's collective mind.
Reply

roodles was starred roodles was unstarred

happysquid
04/30/09

In reply to "Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
I was reading about this in the newspaper this morning, along with some incredibly depressing story about this heinous rapist that targeted senior citizens in the 1970s and 80s who only recently got caught. Eugh. World fail.
Reply

happysquid was starred happysquid was unstarred

Evil.Stubs
04/30/09

In reply to "Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
I saw The Vagina Monologues this year and there is a monologue that is supposed to be from the perspective of comfort women.It made me cry.

The Japanese government needs to make their public apology. I can't even imagine all the terrible experiences these women endured.

It is admirable that these women are speaking out.
Reply

Evil.Stubs was starred Evil.Stubs was unstarred

Majrhoulihan
04/30/09

@Evil.Stubs: The year that Comfort Women were the spotlight monologue, Eve was under a lot of pressute to pick something more timely. She refused - precisely because she thought they women had waited too long.
Reply

Majrhoulihan was starred Majrhoulihan was unstarred

Kali Mama
04/30/09

@Evil.Stubs: There have been efforts underway for decades to get the Japanese to fess up and apologize for the sex slavery, the railroad slaves, and the Indonesian internment camps, let alone get them to prosecute the officials involved.

It's never ever going to happen.
Reply

Kali Mama was starred Kali Mama was unstarred

misspell
04/30/09

In reply to "Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
That's incredible. It's a shame that the thing that brought them together was so painful and cruel, but the level of community and security that these women have together is something that most people can only hope for.
Reply

misspell was starred misspell was unstarred

morninggloria
04/30/09

In reply to "Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
I hope that someday, humans evolve slammable vaginas.
Reply

morninggloria was starred morninggloria was unstarred

Jello Mix
04/30/09

@morninggloria: Or penises that snap off like lizard's tails. Don't worry, boys! It'll grow back in two to three months.
Reply

Jello Mix was starred Jello Mix was unstarred

notheretomakefriends
04/30/09

@morninggloria: or detachable , like Wanda suggested.

My fear is the government will only officially recognize it in 20 years from now, when they have passed away and there is no fear of monetary reparations.

But then again, i'm a cynic
Reply

tailfeather
04/30/09

@morninggloria: Re: Slammable vaginas.

And your prayers were soon answered! In a way...

[jezebel.com]
Reply

tailfeather was starred tailfeather was unstarred

angelheadedhipster
04/30/09

In reply to "Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort
Um, the Golden Girls WERE adamant activists...

of cheesecake.
Reply

angelheadedhipster was starred

serreca
04/30/09

@angelheadedhipster: And CONDOMS! CONDOMS! CONDOMS!
Reply

serreca was starred serreca was unstarred

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#unitedstates

Jezebel

SUBSCRIBE TO Jezebel

"Comfort Women" Seek Their Own Comfort

Many Egyptian Men Think Women Deserve To Be Harassed

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment