It is awesomely hilarious, but I also kinda respect Palin for being so comfortable with the meat-making process that it wouldn't occur to her to move. Anyone who eats a turkey for Thanksgiving shouldn't be weirded out by seeing a turkey get killed.
I bet Martha, being so bad-ass, has wrung a few poultry necks. (But she's a master of PR, so she wouldn't pardon one with the cameras running while the ones behind her were being killed.)
You know, I find Ms. Palin to be a rich source of schadenfreude and general buffoonery, too, but I think those of us who eat turkey and other nicely-packaged meat from the grocery store should be a little less holier-than-thou about her conducting an interview while the unluckier, unpardoned birds were being ground to a pulp.
In other words, yes, killing meat to eat is repulsive, but I sure do like bacon. Not sure I can take the moral high ground over Miss Sarah here.
@otherginger: As a fellow bacon lover, I think the humor comes from the fact that she lacked the foresight to think that maybe turkeys being shoved into slaughtering machines is perhaps not the best backdrop for a Thanksgiving piece... or any piece, ever.
@otherginger: But see, they ASKED HER if she wanted to move. It wasn't just random chance that she ended up standing right there during turkey slaughter. I don't count myself as any better than her in regards to my meat eating habits. My choice of places to give an interview, however, would not include the front of the turkey guillotine.
@otherginger: I don't think most of us are shocked! shocked! to find turkey-killing going on at a turkey farm. For me, a lot of the humor comes from the irony that she made a huge photo-op media event of "pardoning" and ostenisbly "saving" a turkey. Then she's all smiles as one is slaughtered behind her.
@Gumbina80: See, I keep having people send it to me with a "oh that disgusting hunter Sarah" kind of messages and I had to say Well, that is What Happens to Turkey. But I live in a hotbed of rabid vegetarian judgmentalness so it may just be the zealots I surround myself with.
I grew up on a farm. It's a small, family-run operation--my dad and my grandpa both raise crops and beef cattle. It's not a factory farm by any means. No extra antibiotics, the cattle are grass-fed, they're free to roam great swathes of South Dakota prairie, acting like cows and eating whatever they like.
This may sound like a lofty ideal--animals being treated well! Lots of grass and sunshine!--but I've been getting the "OMG HUNTER SARAH IS HEARTLESS AND BLOODTHIRSTY LOL" things too, so I sympathize. This is what happens if you want to eat meat. Meat is made out of dead animals! If you eat meat, something died.
No matter how humane the method of killing, no matter how well that animal was treated, no matter how well that animal was cared for, no matter how easy and painless its existence: something died to feed you.
I am consciously aware of this. It doesn't turn my stomach to know that our food animals twitch and bleed unceremoniously as they expire. Hell, I've seen it.
Sarah Palin was completely tone-deaf and clueless, however, to choose to speak in front of a turkey execution. I know she hunts and kills her own food, so it might not bother her that a turkey is bleeding out not ten feet behind her, but for Pete's sakes, you don't give an interview in front of that if you have any clue how squeamish most people are about meat.
To be honest it didn't bother me that much. I'm fully aware of the lifecycle of most of my food. I won't defend Sarah Palin, because I find her absolutely reprehensible in other areas, but I just can't get too worked up about the turkey slaughter behind her. There's a big turkey breast thawing in my fridge. Its original owner probably suffered the same fate, bleeding and twitching. I'll still eat it happily.
Everyone who participated in this thread: thanks! Animal rights discussions here usually get nowhere, but I enjoyed this debate and appreciated everyone's input. Happy Thanksgiving everyone, I'm sure we can all agree on cranberry sauce and green-bean casserole...seemingly nasty but inexplicably addictive.
I'm on year 15 of not eating meat. Seeing this is reason number 20494059458 why I am happy I am not a hypocrite like so many meat eaters who freaked out about this.
@Lawyerette, FTW!: I think it's really cowardly of people to boohoo about SEEING turkey's killed, as long as they can stuff their face with said turkey a week later pretending the meat from the carcass came from I don't know a happy crunchy granola pain free tree or something. It just doesn't make sense to me for people who eat slaughtered animals every day crying because they see a turkey killed on tv. Oh wait, it does actually, because it's ok to scarf skin and guts as long as it's dressed pretty and they can pretend that all the animals were hugged to death to provide them with a meal. By the way I wasn;t bashing meat eaters (I think veggies who are extremist are idiots) I was making fun of meat eaters who acted all offended by the turkey videos. And yeah I will "bash other people's choices" of hypocrisy if they put themselves out there for ridicule. Not meat eaters but meat eater who pretend they have a conscience over dead turkeys.
I prefer raising livestock for meat, and it's best you'll ever have!
Not only can you eat them but you can use them as green alternatives for example:
Cows are natural lawnmowers and automatic fertilizers.
Pigs are natural garbage disposals.
Chickens are natural pest controls while the rooster provides home security.
I don't think I could be a vegetarian even though I have petted and fed my ribeye dinner. Oddly we did name him "Dinner" just as a reminder where he was gonna end up.
@Pyrovixen: We raised chickens for a while when I was a kid, and you're right, but holy freaking crap are they annoying. Or they were to me, anyway; all noisy and running around. I grew up on a cattle farm and was used to the big, slow-moving (generally), laid-back attitude they have; chickens were a shock to my system! :-)
11/24/08
11/24/08
11/24/08
11/24/08
11/24/08
/swoon/
11/24/08
11/24/08
11/24/08
11/24/08
11/24/08
11/24/08
11/24/08
11/24/08
In other words, yes, killing meat to eat is repulsive, but I sure do like bacon. Not sure I can take the moral high ground over Miss Sarah here.
11/24/08
11/24/08
11/24/08
11/24/08
11/24/08
I grew up on a farm. It's a small, family-run operation--my dad and my grandpa both raise crops and beef cattle. It's not a factory farm by any means. No extra antibiotics, the cattle are grass-fed, they're free to roam great swathes of South Dakota prairie, acting like cows and eating whatever they like.
This may sound like a lofty ideal--animals being treated well! Lots of grass and sunshine!--but I've been getting the "OMG HUNTER SARAH IS HEARTLESS AND BLOODTHIRSTY LOL" things too, so I sympathize. This is what happens if you want to eat meat. Meat is made out of dead animals! If you eat meat, something died.
No matter how humane the method of killing, no matter how well that animal was treated, no matter how well that animal was cared for, no matter how easy and painless its existence: something died to feed you.
I am consciously aware of this. It doesn't turn my stomach to know that our food animals twitch and bleed unceremoniously as they expire. Hell, I've seen it.
Sarah Palin was completely tone-deaf and clueless, however, to choose to speak in front of a turkey execution. I know she hunts and kills her own food, so it might not bother her that a turkey is bleeding out not ten feet behind her, but for Pete's sakes, you don't give an interview in front of that if you have any clue how squeamish most people are about meat.
To be honest it didn't bother me that much. I'm fully aware of the lifecycle of most of my food. I won't defend Sarah Palin, because I find her absolutely reprehensible in other areas, but I just can't get too worked up about the turkey slaughter behind her. There's a big turkey breast thawing in my fridge. Its original owner probably suffered the same fate, bleeding and twitching. I'll still eat it happily.
11/24/08
11/24/08
11/23/08
11/21/08
11/21/08
11/26/08
11/21/08
11/21/08
11/21/08
11/21/08
11/25/08
11/25/08
11/21/08
Not only can you eat them but you can use them as green alternatives for example:
Cows are natural lawnmowers and automatic fertilizers.
Pigs are natural garbage disposals.
Chickens are natural pest controls while the rooster provides home security.
I don't think I could be a vegetarian even though I have petted and fed my ribeye dinner. Oddly we did name him "Dinner" just as a reminder where he was gonna end up.
11/21/08