I'm both bored and disgusted by the torture porn that has taken over the horror genre in recent years. I love being scared, but I'm a lot more impressed by the skill it takes to scare someone with suspense than just showing some crazy person hacking people up.
And I just cannot watch rape scenes in movies or tv. They really freak me out, and stick in my mind forever. The scene from North County where the teenaged Charlize Theron is raped by her teacher is burned into my brain, even years later. And the sexual assault from last season's Law&Order: SVU finale still makes me sick to think about it. And those scenes are tame in comparison to what is shown in horror films nowadays.
I am a huge fan of horror. It is even a dream of mine to make horror movies (not any of this torture porn junk, though). Movies like this, however, I can't stomach.
And if Kyle Smith thinks that rape is a "taboo" then I don't think he's seen very many horror movies. Sexual violence is practically guaranteed in this genre. Especially if the movie has sexy female characters.
Watch the documentary "This Film is Not Yet Rated," and you'll understand why the ratings system in this country is so fucked up. Netflix it. Recommended!
i wish somebody who's a fan of these kinds of movies could explain to me why they're entertained by other people being murdered in horrific ways. i just really don't get it. i just hear the screaming and i turn off... i don't even have to see the visuals. it's a visceral reaction i have.
The fear caused by the movie makes my adrenaline rush which is exhilarating to me. I don't get sexually excited by any of it, I don't find humor in it, I just enjoy the feeling of being scared. It is like sky diving or doing a dare that you don't think that you can do. Once it is over you feel giddy because you "survived".
hmm. interesting. i can understand how this plugs into the whole adrenaline-rush sensation and feeling like you survived.
i think there's a difference in the reaction i have, for sure. i'm not scared by these types of movies. not at all. i'm a pretty brave person, if i say so myself. instead i'm revolted... disgusted. to me i can't compartmentalize this type of depiction into an entertainment category. i can't get past how angry... i guess that's the emotion i feel. anger that something so horrible is being trivialized. i immediately make the leap and feel too much for real humans who have actually gone through something like this in their lifetime.
@msAnthrope: Understandable, not every genre is meant to appeal to every person! I have a hard time finding the entertainment in movies like The Notebook for example. Granted, those movies don't have the argument of trivializing horrific experiences! Overall, it is just a different strokes for different folks scenario. I can't make green your favorite color just because it is mine :)
@msAnthrope: I think horror movies are like the bear-baiting and public execution of our time. A lot of people would bring picnics and enjoy themselves watching criminals get drawn and quartered. I can't imagine not being shaken to my core watching torture and death on screen.
@msAnthrope: That's how it is for me. I don't get remotely scared. I just get grossed out and pissed off and want to do violence to the people who made the movie - which in turn makes me feel like an asshole to boot.
Does anyone Jezzie-sleuth know where I can read the 13th century ballad? (Nerd alert). This just reminds me of Neil Gaiman and The White Road--his short story based on the fairy tale about the men that lure women to their home and then butcher them and eat them. I'd be curious to read the ballad that started it all.
i know, i'd like to know why movies like this aren't rated X anymore? because any movie rated X supposedly won't get released at the multiplex theaters and the movie will fail. at least that's my understanding.
I saw this trailer over and over again while watching BSG on the Sci-Fi channel. I immidiatly started muting it and changing screens while it ran. Im no prudebut just from the preview I could tell this was glorifying violence against women and was for the purpose of getting off on the rape of a young girl. It was torture porn and I really resented having to watch it 6 times or so throughout my show.
@KentuckyBabe: Sigh. This movie is not torture porn. The rape is not for getting off. This is one of the best horror movies ever made, and whether or not this remake will live up to the original (which is also VERY graphic), this is a real film, not just a bunch of violent scenes edited together.
Um, so why isn't Musgrave barking about this? This is what I don't get - Christians freak out about gay marriage but not torture porn being sold to their children.
I think the most disturbing film I've seen lately is the documentary This Film Is Not Yet Rated, which is a real tear-down of the MPAA and how they make their arbitrary decisions.
I saw Kevin Smith speak last month and he spoke for a while about the MPAA and the trouble he's had with them (they originally gave "Zak and Miri make a porno" an NC-17) rating because of a couple of scenes. He fought it, had to basically hold a debate with the head of MPAA infront of a jury of MPAA members, and they decided it was actually an R.
It just shocks me that he was getting screwed over cause he showed people having consensual sex, and a (pretty gross) poop scene, but THIS! this is ok for kids to see.
"Last House on the Left" is among my favorite horror movies of all time (the original, at least -- clearly I haven't seen this yet, as it's not out). It's terrifying, unbelievably disturbing, and yet it leaves you with such satisfaction, watcthing these creeps get what is coming to them.
I'm reading a lot of comments by people who are not fans of horror as a genre. Well, then this movie isn't for you. And while I think most of my favorite horror films tend to be of the Hitchcock-ian and King-like persuesion (a lot of suspense, not necessarily lots of blood), LHotL is one of the true classics of the genre.
The Manson family-style rapes and murders that take place at the beginning were meant to hit on a specific cultural point that was extremely relevant in the early 1970s, shortly after the real Manson murders took place, and at a time when hippies -- who had spent a decade trying to portray themselves as peace-loving, acid-dropping, open-minded teddy bears -- were being lured into lurid lifestyles as they were exposed to narcotics and/or became acid casualties. The end of the 1960's counterculture left behind some very dark and very dangerous residue, and the result was groups of lost and lonely kids wandering around the country, doing anything and everything they could to get high and try to live out this weird ideal that had proven unsustainable. It was about the death of optimism.
That's why seeing what happens to these girls after such an innocent night -- a concert, and, man, who doesn't want to get a little stoned after a concert? -- is so disturbing and so scary. That's why the rape and murder is so graphic and so in your face; these girls didn't do anything wrong, or even anything out of the oridnary, and yet here they are, preyed upon by such evil, lost and soulless people.
And that's why the parents' revenge over the rest of the movie is so fun to watch. Because when they start to dole out their revenge, every cell in your body wants nothing more than to see these horrible, evil people be destroyed as painfully and remorselessly as they wasted these two young innocent girls.
Horror is hard to watch for many people because it forces you to confront the absolutely darkness that lurks in everyone, held back by a thinner and weaker barrier than many of us want to admit. LHotL is not like torture porn -- there is not pain and blood just for schock value. And LHotL has never romanticized the actions of a rapist or murderer. Instead, it shows us the horror of rape and murder without blinking... and then allows us to see justice that our justice system rarely affords us.
You cannot hate the antagonists of this film properly without that kind of rape and murder scene. And that hate is why, whenever I re-watch the original with friends (who have or haven't seen it) we are cheering by the end.
God, I can't wait for this. I really, really hope it's good.
@stoprobbers: Your point is well made. Your comment only reinforces, at least to me, the whole point of this post.
Which is that you're an adult, you can choose to see this movie (or not) and you will respond to the scene in your way. What's NOT ok is that the MPAA gave it an R-Rating.
@TheGintheCity: I definitly see the point about the R rating. And I agree, it's totally hypocritical. But I do think that having this rape be this graphic is an essential part of the storytelling process for this film -- it creates an emotional response in the audience that the movie depends upon. And so I guess I can see why the MPAA would give it such an incredibly hypocritical rating.
Not excusing the hypocrisy, just understanding it.
Also, any parent who takes their kid to a movie like this is a horrible person.
@stoprobbers: Yay for another horror lover! That was a perfect post breaking down why one can love the horror genre and not be a dark scary person who has lost sensitivity to rape or murder.
As for not getting an NC-17 rating, it bothers me that children WILL go to this but on the same hand I would be really pissed off about theaters not showing it because of the rating, blockbuster not having it because of the rating, etc. I think that R should be treated like NC-17 and that restrictions for carrying NC-17 should no longer exist.
@stoprobbers: The original "Last House" was a straight-up exploitation movie in "socially conscious" drag. Sure, Craven basically made statements about the dark side of the counter-culture's libertinism in the form of "Little Red Riding Hood," but the rape and murder scenes were his money shots. Check out the trailer, its tagline was "Repeat to yourself, it's just a movie," which basically tried to present the movie as a cool spookhouse ride at the amusement park than a serious statement about American society. It's a little like how "I Spit On Your Grave" was tauted as a "feminist" movie.
@Cam/ron: I don't purport that LHotL is anything other than a horror movie. I don't say it's a serious film. But the potency of the horror comes from the audience's identification with the characters in the film, and in 1972 the Manson family murders and the death of the counterculture were still very much haunting society. Craven exercised precise and gruesome judgment when incorporating those things into his film.
But as a horror movie, it has to scare you. And rape and murder are scary, scary thngs, as many here will attest. If you don't like this kind of horror, you don't like this kind of horror. But LHotL is one of the classics of its genre; it is not torture porn, it is not rape for rape's sake, and it doesn't deserve to be treated with such derision.
@Cam/ron: I'm quite sure that the company that released the movie did want it to be seen as a "cool spookhouse ride at the amusement park", they also released it as a double bill with a movie called "Don't Go Into The Basement" and the tagline was meant for both films. That doesn't mean that Wes Craven's statements about what he intended the movie to represent are false.
I know I'm going to be the one lone voice, but, I love this movie. I love the original. I would say it's my favorite horror movie of all time. I hate romantic movies, I hate comedies, I live for horror films. Frankly, the torture porn crap that has been coming out ever since Saw (I) has been boring me. When I heard they were remaking this movie I got nervous that they would ruin it, but frankly I think it looks like it is going to be amazing. I'm sorry if you guys are getting grossed out by it, I suppose I can understand, but frankly, I am already heading over to fandango to pick up my ticket for tonight. I can not wait.
@wooden_shoes: Can I go to Fandango with you? I am excited as well for the movie. I think the point of the movie is to horrify and outrage you so obviously based on the other comments, it is doing its job.
@wooden_shoes: I'm right there with you, babe. I might not be seeing it tonight, but I LOVE LOVE LOVE horror movies, horror books, horror comics, the whole shebang. I'm super psyched to see this, and I think so many of the people here are taking offense to something they know nothing about.
@gold_gato: oh thats funny. my roommate just rented that last week and she was all excited to watch it and then later was like it was HORRIBLE! are you my roommate?
@bluebears: No believe it or not I saw it in the theatre. The rape scenes were so excessive that everytime it happened my friends and I were like, JESUS ENOUGH IS ENOUGH, and at one point someone else in the theatre yelled out "WE GET IT ALREADY!" It left a sick feeling in my stomach.
@gold_gato: Well, the rapes were in the book as well. I found the rapes in the book much harder to deal with than in the movie. They were discussed in graphic detail and reoccurred multiple times. But the story is all about the destruction of society and morality, what is it that makes us human, etc. As you can imagine, it is not a pretty picture. Good read though.
@ZombieApocalypse: I didn't read the book. I'm a very avid reader, and in my opinion, not everything should be put on the big screen, even if the book is a good read. There's something about seeing it acted out in front of your eyes that makes it more real, and literal.
03/13/09
And I just cannot watch rape scenes in movies or tv. They really freak me out, and stick in my mind forever. The scene from North County where the teenaged Charlize Theron is raped by her teacher is burned into my brain, even years later. And the sexual assault from last season's Law&Order: SVU finale still makes me sick to think about it. And those scenes are tame in comparison to what is shown in horror films nowadays.
03/13/09
And if Kyle Smith thinks that rape is a "taboo" then I don't think he's seen very many horror movies. Sexual violence is practically guaranteed in this genre. Especially if the movie has sexy female characters.
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
The fear caused by the movie makes my adrenaline rush which is exhilarating to me. I don't get sexually excited by any of it, I don't find humor in it, I just enjoy the feeling of being scared. It is like sky diving or doing a dare that you don't think that you can do. Once it is over you feel giddy because you "survived".
03/13/09
hmm. interesting. i can understand how this plugs into the whole adrenaline-rush sensation and feeling like you survived.
i think there's a difference in the reaction i have, for sure. i'm not scared by these types of movies. not at all. i'm a pretty brave person, if i say so myself. instead i'm revolted... disgusted. to me i can't compartmentalize this type of depiction into an entertainment category. i can't get past how angry... i guess that's the emotion i feel. anger that something so horrible is being trivialized. i immediately make the leap and feel too much for real humans who have actually gone through something like this in their lifetime.
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
07/09/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
[en.wikipedia.org]
03/13/09
03/13/09
i know, i'd like to know why movies like this aren't rated X anymore? because any movie rated X supposedly won't get released at the multiplex theaters and the movie will fail. at least that's my understanding.
03/13/09
I love horror movies.
This sounds like a good one. Scary. Probably should be NC-17, but...sounds like a scary movie to me. (the original is pretty damn good too.)
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
It just shocks me that he was getting screwed over cause he showed people having consensual sex, and a (pretty gross) poop scene, but THIS! this is ok for kids to see.
03/13/09
I'm reading a lot of comments by people who are not fans of horror as a genre. Well, then this movie isn't for you. And while I think most of my favorite horror films tend to be of the Hitchcock-ian and King-like persuesion (a lot of suspense, not necessarily lots of blood), LHotL is one of the true classics of the genre.
The Manson family-style rapes and murders that take place at the beginning were meant to hit on a specific cultural point that was extremely relevant in the early 1970s, shortly after the real Manson murders took place, and at a time when hippies -- who had spent a decade trying to portray themselves as peace-loving, acid-dropping, open-minded teddy bears -- were being lured into lurid lifestyles as they were exposed to narcotics and/or became acid casualties. The end of the 1960's counterculture left behind some very dark and very dangerous residue, and the result was groups of lost and lonely kids wandering around the country, doing anything and everything they could to get high and try to live out this weird ideal that had proven unsustainable. It was about the death of optimism.
That's why seeing what happens to these girls after such an innocent night -- a concert, and, man, who doesn't want to get a little stoned after a concert? -- is so disturbing and so scary. That's why the rape and murder is so graphic and so in your face; these girls didn't do anything wrong, or even anything out of the oridnary, and yet here they are, preyed upon by such evil, lost and soulless people.
And that's why the parents' revenge over the rest of the movie is so fun to watch. Because when they start to dole out their revenge, every cell in your body wants nothing more than to see these horrible, evil people be destroyed as painfully and remorselessly as they wasted these two young innocent girls.
Horror is hard to watch for many people because it forces you to confront the absolutely darkness that lurks in everyone, held back by a thinner and weaker barrier than many of us want to admit. LHotL is not like torture porn -- there is not pain and blood just for schock value. And LHotL has never romanticized the actions of a rapist or murderer. Instead, it shows us the horror of rape and murder without blinking... and then allows us to see justice that our justice system rarely affords us.
You cannot hate the antagonists of this film properly without that kind of rape and murder scene. And that hate is why, whenever I re-watch the original with friends (who have or haven't seen it) we are cheering by the end.
God, I can't wait for this. I really, really hope it's good.
03/13/09
Which is that you're an adult, you can choose to see this movie (or not) and you will respond to the scene in your way. What's NOT ok is that the MPAA gave it an R-Rating.
03/13/09
Not excusing the hypocrisy, just understanding it.
Also, any parent who takes their kid to a movie like this is a horrible person.
03/13/09
As for not getting an NC-17 rating, it bothers me that children WILL go to this but on the same hand I would be really pissed off about theaters not showing it because of the rating, blockbuster not having it because of the rating, etc. I think that R should be treated like NC-17 and that restrictions for carrying NC-17 should no longer exist.
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
But as a horror movie, it has to scare you. And rape and murder are scary, scary thngs, as many here will attest. If you don't like this kind of horror, you don't like this kind of horror. But LHotL is one of the classics of its genre; it is not torture porn, it is not rape for rape's sake, and it doesn't deserve to be treated with such derision.
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09
03/13/09