the virgin suicides

posts about #thevirginsuicides more →
Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
No Sh-t: New Study Finds 'Virginity Pledges' Ineffective, Promoting Unsafe Sex

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

SisterRay73
07/22/09

In reply to Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
I've read Virgin Suicides a few times and every time it lets me down - I keep going back to it because I keep thinking "maybe I missed something", since it's a book that deals with things I relate to, but every time it leaves me kind of cold. But then I read Middlesex and it absolutely blew me away. Now THAT was an amazingly fantastic novel, definitely one of the best of recent memory.

Of course, now that I'm thinking about it again, I'm thinking "hmm, maybe I SHOULD read VS again". It will probably let me down again, but oh well.
Reply

Lolita Hazed promoted this comment SisterRay73 was starred SisterRay73 was unstarred

Lolita Hazed
07/22/09

@SisterRay73: I tried to read Middlesex and couldn't get through it the first time. I'll definitely try again. Which came first? Most likely, The Virgin Suicides, considering that's the one with the anniversary. Am I right?
Reply

Edited by Lolita Hazed at 07/22/09 2:09 PM Lolita Hazed was starred Lolita Hazed was unstarred

eri401
07/22/09

@SisterRay73: But I think that is part of the point of The Virgin Suicides. The entire story centers around absence - the impenetrable (heh) mystery of fetishized girlhood that everyone inadvertently reifies with each sigh. The narrating boys are themselves blind and the reader has to understand the story through that veil. There should not be satisfaction at the end of the novel - just a vague sense of loss.
Reply

ucelluccia promoted this comment eri401 was starred eri401 was unstarred

Vivi21
07/22/09

In reply to Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
I've never read "The Virgin Suicides" (although I saw the movie), but "Middlesex" was unbelievable. It's one of the few books I've read lately that has really stuck with me. He is an extremely talented writer, and it is inspiring to me that a fellow Greek could write something so interesting about a period of Greek history that is not talked about much. He inspires me to write...
Reply

nessalicious promoted this comment Vivi21 was starred Vivi21 was unstarred

labelsdown
07/22/09

In reply to Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
This is such a beautifully written book, but it always struck me as being more about boys than girls. I thought Eugenides did in incredible job capturing that sweet and wistful part of adolescent boys that often gets overlooked. Anyway, I thought that, that was the ultimate failure of the movie.
Reply

hortense promoted this comment labelsdown was starred labelsdown was unstarred

girl.of.your.dreams
07/22/09

@labelsdown: I always thought the real genius of the book was that it was written in first person plural, from the p.o.v. of the boys in the town. I think the movie could have really benefited from letting that remain the focus.
Reply

cait98
07/22/09

In reply to Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
I count him among my favorite writers even though to my knowledge he has only written two novels.

What I love about Middlesex especially is that it's such a... whole book. Like full characters, all loose ends tied up, so good.
Reply

hortense promoted this comment cait98 was starred cait98 was unstarred

la.donna.pietra
07/22/09

@cait98: He wrote a wonderful short story for the New Yorker recently, too: http://www.newyorker.com/fiction/features/2008/03/31/080331fi_fiction_eugenides
Reply

la.donna.pietra was starred la.donna.pietra was unstarred

chicaferoza
07/22/09

In reply to Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
He is truly a master of his craft, but beyond that, I always wondered how he was able to get into the minds of adolescent girls so well. This book- along with Middlesex- is just so right on about the complicated feminine psyche and dealing with what it means to grow up as a woman.
Reply

maybeimamazed02 promoted this comment chicaferoza was starred chicaferoza was unstarred

Lolita Hazed
07/22/09

In reply to Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
It really is such a beautiful book, I need to re-read it. So mature and sexy and unbelievably poetic. I always adored Cecelia, she's my favorite Lisbon girl! Such a shame she's gone so quick.
Reply

Lolita Hazed was starred Lolita Hazed was unstarred

EkaterinaBallerina
07/22/09

In reply to Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
This is still to this day, my favorite book. I wrote my sophomore research paper in high school about teen suicide because of it.

He lives in my hometown, Princeton, now and his daughter goes to my old school, where my mom currently works. She's seen him a couple times, but like that time we saw Joyce Carol Oates in the market, we can't seem to work up the nerve to say anything.
Reply

EkaterinaBallerina was starred

nessalicious
07/22/09

In reply to Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
The last lines of this book are some of the most beautiful I have ever read, every time I feel uninspired as a writer I return to them and they make me realise how much I need to create.
Reply

nessalicious was starred nessalicious was unstarred

maybeimamazed02
07/22/09

@nessalicious: I was just thinking the other day about the scene where the girls have a party and invite the neighborhood boys. I haven't read the book in nine years, and that scene is still burned in my mind--it's that beautifully written.

Middlesex is also very inspiring to wannabe writers such as myself.
Reply

maybeimamazed02 was starred maybeimamazed02 was unstarred

thereisn0try
07/22/09

In reply to Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
If you haven't read it, I highly recommend another book of his, Middlesex
Reply

maybeimamazed02 promoted this comment thereisn0try was starred thereisn0try was unstarred

PilgrimSoul
07/22/09

In reply to Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
This was the first piece of contemporary literary fiction I ever read, and it has a special place in my heart because of that. But I tried to reread it recently, and had a lot harder time with it; the idealization of the girls, their total blankness, I found hard to understand. I know that this is the classic expression of the male gaze in contemporary lit now, but nonetheless, I feel like I see something there that is troubling now. The girls are ciphers for the boys, they don't exist as anything but symbols of innocence and purity and sexuality. And I guess I want more for young women from young men.

But the movie was terrible, horrible, no good, very bad thing.
Reply

PilgrimSoul was starred PilgrimSoul was unstarred

Khrushchev
07/22/09

@PilgrimSoul: I agree (shocker!). I read this even before I had any degree of feminist awareness at all, and I remember feeling uneasy about the characters of the girls. I didn't hate the movie (it had such a great soundtrack!), but I think it exacerbated the blankness of those characters while at the same time making that blankness almost enviable, or fashionable.
Reply

Khrushchev was starred Khrushchev was unstarred

HistoricUpstart
07/22/09

@PilgrimSoul: Yeah, I'm embarrassed to say I never got around to reading the book because I was so turned off by the movie. The "blankness" of the girls is the perfect way to describe it. And that was the beginning of the world discovering the "edginess" of Sophia Coppola too. Ugghhh.
Reply

HistoricUpstart was starred HistoricUpstart was unstarred

Elizabth_Bennet
07/22/09

@PilgrimSoul: Wow. I love love love the movie and the book...and I think it's much more about the boys being limited in understanding the girls than them being blank. It's about being able to be so close and not being able to know someone or what's really going on no matter how much you observe it from the outside. Also the relationship between the parents and the girls is most interesting to me, the limitations they place on them (because they're girls!) and the result.
Reply

HistoricUpstart promoted this comment Elizabth_Bennet was starred Elizabth_Bennet was unstarred

PilgrimSoul
07/22/09

@Elizabth_Bennet: I'm not saying I dislike the book. But there was something more fundamental than point of view going on in that book with respect to the girls, at least the way I read it now. I am under no illusions that Eugenides is deliberately focusing on the way young men perceive/relate to young women. And I guess all I'm saying is that reading the book now, I am disturbed by what I see.
Reply

PilgrimSoul was starred PilgrimSoul was unstarred

J.D.Regent
07/22/09

@PilgrimSoul: Yeah I agree, but don't you think that was made explicit in the book? The girls are only understood through the male gaze, and that's why they are so mysterious. It's really a book about boys, not girls. If you take it in that way it's less offensive. Kind of. Or at least in a different way.
Reply

J.D.Regent was starred J.D.Regent was unstarred

J.D.Regent
07/22/09

@PilgrimSoul: wait, are you saying you think he WAS deliberately focusing on the way young men relate to young women, or he wasn't? I think it is disturbing, and it is directly related to their suicides, and that the book is for me a lot about the violence of boys' distance from girls, and parents distance from children. I mean I think it is supposed to be disturbing in that way, that the idealization of the girls is directly linked to their suicides.
Reply

J.D.Regent was starred J.D.Regent was unstarred

tea_for_two
07/22/09

@PilgrimSoul: I think it's meant to be disturbing--I see this book as a record of how the boys (who don't even have names and narrate collectively) objectify the girls and view them as saints and symbols to be worshipped rather than to be loved. The boys essentially stand by and allow the girls to destroy themselves because they don't know how to really respond to their cries for help. It's essentially about the dangers of, as you put it, the male gaze.
Reply

J.D.Regent promoted this comment tea_for_two was starred tea_for_two was unstarred

J.D.Regent
07/22/09

@tea_for_two: right, that's what i meant to say but better.
Reply

J.D.Regent was starred J.D.Regent was unstarred

eri401
07/22/09

@J.D.Regent: Exactly! The girls are tragic because they are idealized, even in their deaths. And the boys are so busy projecting their fantasies onto the girls, how they will become their protectors and saviors etc, that they end up idling by as the girls kills themselves.

It isn't just the boys that gaze in wonder at the lipstick and blond hair and mysterious giggling -- it is the parents that suffocate their daughters in an effort to "protect" them. It is also the neighbors who simply cluck in a hands-off sympathy for the sisters.

The film did a good job in mocking a larger society as well -- the blond newscaster out to exploit an idealized image of the grieving sisters. etc.

There is that odd conclusion of the girls sealing themselves into un-knowable-ness by killing themselves. In a final protest to be acknowledged as agents and not dissected objects, they kill themselves in pretty unromantic and gruesome ways. Yet with this, they oddly seal themselves away into the very mystery that they wanted to conceal.

I love the book. It is brilliant.
Reply

PilgrimSoul promoted this comment Edited by eri401 at 07/22/09 2:23 PM eri401 was starred eri401 was unstarred

dreamweave
07/22/09

In reply to Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
Sometimes I wonder if the Jezebels post things to make me feel 100 years old with malicious intent.

uh-oh. Questioning the motives - bad DreamWeave! :)
Reply

dreamweave was starred dreamweave was unstarred

FashionShowAtLunch
07/22/09

In reply to Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
I wish I got paid that much for my private exercises of self-pleasure.
Reply

FashionShowAtLunch was starred

BiteMeMitchell!
07/22/09

@FashionShowAtLunch: You could try performing them online.
Reply

onthecornerofparkerandwoolf promoted this comment BiteMeMitchell! was starred BiteMeMitchell! was unstarred

Madlenka
07/22/09

In reply to Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
Sadly, none of my private exercises to please myself have been this thought-provoking or successful.
Reply

nessalicious promoted this comment Madlenka was starred Madlenka was unstarred

stacyinbean
07/22/09

In reply to Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary
When is he going to write a new novel though?!!?!! Such an amazing writer.
Reply

stacyinbean was starred stacyinbean was unstarred

bananastand
07/22/09

@stacyinbean: He's a slow writer. I think Middlesex took him, what, ten years?
Reply

bananastand was starred bananastand was unstarred

BellaTricks
07/22/09

@stacyinbean: I agree! I read Middlesex shortly after I finished The Virgin Suicides. I believe he's done short stories, but I'd love to read another full-length novel of his.
Reply

BellaTricks was starred BellaTricks was unstarred

BiteMeMitchell!
07/22/09

@BellaTricks: I picked up Middlesex in my building's free book swap and it's patiently waiting on my shelf for me to pick it up. Should I get to it in a hurry? Is it amazing? I have about another 5 books waiting to be read and I'm never sure which to go for next!
Reply

nessalicious promoted this comment BiteMeMitchell! was starred BiteMeMitchell! was unstarred

GeorgeFayne
07/22/09

@stacyinbean: In the article, he says in another 2 or 3 years. You're killing me, Eugenides!
Reply

GeorgeFayne was starred GeorgeFayne was unstarred

BellaTricks
07/22/09

@BiteMeMitchell!: It's amazing. It's certainly not a quick read, but the language and treatment of subject matter are just incredible. I highly recommend it, if you have the time and inclination.
Reply

BellaTricks was starred BellaTricks was unstarred

GeorgeFayne
07/22/09

@BiteMeMitchell!: It's fantastic. It's epic. It also took me 3 tries to get through, but it was so worth it.
Reply

GeorgeFayne was starred GeorgeFayne was unstarred

LolaQuinn is full of beans
07/22/09

@BiteMeMitchell!: It is SUCH a good book. It deals with so many different themes that it will blow your mind. It wasn't just an enjoyable story...I felt like I really learned things (life in the Ford motor plants, the burning of Smyrna, etc).
Reply

stacyinbean
07/22/09

@BiteMeMitchell!: Absolutely, I've had a friend or two who have had to start it a few times to really get into it, but oh my goodness it is just an exquisite piece of writing. I will fully admit the beginning IS slow but the care with which this man handles details is truly amazing.
Reply

stacyinbean was starred stacyinbean was unstarred

stacyinbean
07/22/09

@GeorgeFayne: GAH, YEARS? I guess I know why the books are so good now!
Reply

stacyinbean was starred stacyinbean was unstarred

LadySoprano is a Fat-Fighting Superwoman
12/29/08

In reply to No Sh-t: New Study Finds 'Virginity Pledges' Ineffective, Promoting Unsafe Sex
My parents gave me the most effective sex talk ever, when I was about 14. They told me that they believed sex should be reserved for two people who are in a loving, committed relationship, and that they hoped I would wait until I was old enough to know what I was getting into.

They knew long before I did that I am quick to get emotionally involved with people, so casual sex is almost impossible for me--I'll always find some way to get in over my head.

Instead of saying, "DON'T HAVE SEX!!!" they told me, "If you make the decision to have sex, for heaven's sake, come to us--we won't judge, but we will get you on the Pill, and get you some condoms."

This conversation was effective in keeping me a virgin for a long time.

P.S. Religion was never a factor in our house.
Reply

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#thevirginsuicides

Jezebel

SUBSCRIBE TO Jezebel

Virgin Suicides Writer Contemplates Book's Sixteenth Anniversary

No Sh-t: New Study Finds 'Virginity Pledges' Ineffective, Promoting Unsafe Sex

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment