I have a dear friend who after spending seven years in the military, capably handling emergencies such as cargo fires at 30,000 feet, having and raising a 5 y/o son, and running her own household, returned home to a mother who has such control over her that she can effectively tell her who to date, what to eat and how to raise her son. Her mother even went so far recently as to send the boy to stay with an estranged family member he'd never met...without his own mother's permission or consent.
My friend finds it easier to remain under the familiar misery of her mother's control than to face the unknown and fight for her freedom, probably because her mother has told her since birth that she isn't capable of taking care of herself. I've even offered to let her stay with me, but she can't seem to work up the courage to get away.
It boggles the mind how deeply a parent's lies can burrow inside their child's mind and warp their existence. Boggles the mind and breaks the heart.
I'm a 22 year old woman set to begin her first minimum wage job on Monday. I have a severe eating disorder, which I recently -- beat back enough to be functional, and one of the most haunting things my psychologist ever said to me was, "You need to get away from your mother more than anything, and your eating disorder is the thing that keeps you tied to her." That was motivation. It was motivation last time, too, at 17, when I abruptly hit remission, got into out of state universities, and applied for jobs left and right. But after my father's death and my mother's cancer diagnosis a year later (and my mother's response to my dream university yanking my aid, her kicking me out of the house in the immediate aftermath of my father's death), the constant abuse and undermining started to sink through.
It's very hard to explain, but when you grow up constantly being told that you have no friends, that you're too expensive to keep, that x/y/z/the other thing, that you're too stupid to find your way out of a building (no lie, that happened when I was sixteen), that you can't even vacuum properly: you find yourself more comfortable receiving and believing those messages than constantly fighting them off. In my case, anorexia was a great FUCK YOU to my mother, as being thin, eating less, exercising more: that was the one thing I could do that she never could. (Naturally, my mother asked me for tips.)
So my heart breaks for your friend. I want very much to join the Air Force, to acquire those skills and that kind of strength, and it makes me so sad that someone you describe as so capable and wonderful is fighting the same battle so many of us are. For what it's worth: I know that it is possible to win.
But it's not just freedom of the unknown, sometimes. In my case, it's not having any other family, extended or immediate. With the freedom gained in breaking away, there is a loss: nowhere to go at holidays; no more calls home with good news just in the hope that someone might care; the fact of it being your f'ing mother. I know that people think that I'm insane for still talking to her, even, at this point, let alone living with her, but when the mother-daughter bond changes from dysfunctional but pulsing to a true break, it's hard to contemplate. Harder still when you know the person on the other end would be willing to walk away, which makes you cling even harder in the hope of making this work, somehow. I don't know if that's an issue with your friend, but it's... definitely something that I struggle with, and it's very hard to explain to the outside, because, yes, I could 'cut my losses' but getting the hell out of Dodge, but I'll acquire a new set of small griefs. At least when my mother is reminding me that I'm worthless, I know how to deal with that. The fear of the 'unknown' in my case, at least, is the question of: 'How can I -- can I? -- cope with the fact of nowhere to go at the holidays? At least if I'm miserable, I'm connected, but to have silence as the proof of what I already am, totally alone, oh, God, I don't know, maybe I can just get through this....'
@franzen: Will one of the starred Sneetches please promote this? Jezzes will rally around franzen.
I'm sorry that you have to go through that. Being rejected by a parent can be crippling but it seems as though you recognize the pattern and will be strong enough to break it. Hopefully you can build a support network apart from your mother and rely on these friends and mentors to help you through. I wish you all the best. You write beautifully.
@franzen: My heart breaks for you both, and your insights will stay with me when I get frustrated with her for not leaving. Your stories, I think, are remarkably similar.
@franzen: Oh honey - big hug. We cannot help but love our mothers even when they are awful to us. Take comfort in the fact that all of us find it difficult to stand up for ourselves.
I told mine "no one is allowed to talk to me that way" finally. When I was 45.
What an interesting headline, both above and in the original article. Especially when the husband/father was living there as well (and seemed to be the only member of the family to have normal contact with the neighbors). Was he just really, really deluded? I doubt it.
@HeatherNumber1: I find the headline pretty interesting "Mom Charged with Starving Adult Daughter"...shouldn't that read "Parents charged"?!?! They BOTH acted like monsters, why is the focus on the mother?
@Calluna Vulgaris: As it says in the article at the link, only the mom was indicted this week. Her father already plead guilty to the same charge the mom is facing and he's been sentenced to probation and psychological evaluation.
@Margaret: Missed that they were focusing on this week. I know the father plead guilty to the same charge, but I was just wondering why they singled out the mother in the headline.
It's perplexing to believe that a person who's attending college and has the world open to her through her professors and other students cannot overcome the emotional and mental issues that confronted her at her home,
Dude, this kind of shit happens constantly to varying degrees, it's really not that "perplexing." You can be smart, you can be beautiful, you can be any number of wonderful things and still be controlled.
This mother is a total psycho--keeping her daughter in a crib during her toddler years? I hope she get jail time.
THAT DOES IT, WORLD. Between this and the little girl locked up for 18 years, me and my teddy bear are getting under the covers and hiding for the rest of the day. Week. YEAR. With chocolate. And my Barbies. And sparkle ponies. *ugh*
My God. That is the most weird and depressing thing I've heard in an already weird and depressing week. How horrible life must have been for her. I wish I could somehow help, and it's just too late.
This is an example of trusting that "Love" is what your parents give you, no matter how messed up it is. Pretty common among abused kids, but not to this degree and not by the time they become adults usually.
@SarahMC: The article sort of implied she was mentally ill. It sounds like her mother was very controlling, and perhaps caused an eating disorder, and controlled her with the eating disorder. Or I am way off base.
@SarahMC: I have a friend with two (!) masters degrees who lived in another country by herself once, and is now completely incapable of leaving her abusive husband because she is so brainwashed by him. Trust me, it happens.
@SarahMC: It sounds like this was a life-long thing, even being totally controlled in college. Going to a nearby college for four years can't always heal a lifetime of control and abuse.
@schweppes: The dad was bringing her meals daily at college. The mom was controlling what she ate. It sounds like she never had a chance to get away, even when she left the home.
@SarahMC: Financial dependence could be another factor. During the first few months after I graduated college, with less than three dollars in my bank account, if my parents decided not to feed me, I wouldn't have eaten.
@colormeroutine: The article says she was severely mentally and physically handicap which probably occurred over time. So considering she died of malnutrition and had been suffering from anorexia, I can see how that constitutes neglect. If they knew their daughter was handicapped and need extra care and did nothing, they are guilty of neglect.
@EkaterinaBallerina: I agree in principal, but legally speaking they would only have been responsible if they were court-appointed gaurdians and she had been legally declared incapable of taking care of herself.
@SarahMC: I don't know what the legal issues here are, but I also know someone with pretty psychologically abusive and controlling parents (not at this level, but still), who had trouble leaving an abusive relationship with a boyfriend who tried to convince her that she had psychiatric issues and that his drinking and cheating were not really going on -- oh, and she's also a Ph.D. candidate and one of the best in her program, and a lovely person to be around when she's not stressed out, regressing and reacting because of her family (who use an inheritance to reel her back in now and again).
@colormeroutine: Isn't the fact that they willingly took on the care of an emotionally and physically handicapped person enough to make them legally responsible for the neglect? I mean, she probably would have been better off if she'd been thrown on the street when she tried to return home, so it's clear that when her parents took her in, they were preventing her from getting real help. Especially with her dad cancelling her nutritionist appointments. Or is this concept only relevant in tort law?
And the father already plead guilty, so unless his attorney was total crap, it seems like the DA must have some case.
08/28/09
My friend finds it easier to remain under the familiar misery of her mother's control than to face the unknown and fight for her freedom, probably because her mother has told her since birth that she isn't capable of taking care of herself. I've even offered to let her stay with me, but she can't seem to work up the courage to get away.
It boggles the mind how deeply a parent's lies can burrow inside their child's mind and warp their existence. Boggles the mind and breaks the heart.
08/28/09
I'm a 22 year old woman set to begin her first minimum wage job on Monday. I have a severe eating disorder, which I recently -- beat back enough to be functional, and one of the most haunting things my psychologist ever said to me was, "You need to get away from your mother more than anything, and your eating disorder is the thing that keeps you tied to her." That was motivation. It was motivation last time, too, at 17, when I abruptly hit remission, got into out of state universities, and applied for jobs left and right. But after my father's death and my mother's cancer diagnosis a year later (and my mother's response to my dream university yanking my aid, her kicking me out of the house in the immediate aftermath of my father's death), the constant abuse and undermining started to sink through.
It's very hard to explain, but when you grow up constantly being told that you have no friends, that you're too expensive to keep, that x/y/z/the other thing, that you're too stupid to find your way out of a building (no lie, that happened when I was sixteen), that you can't even vacuum properly: you find yourself more comfortable receiving and believing those messages than constantly fighting them off. In my case, anorexia was a great FUCK YOU to my mother, as being thin, eating less, exercising more: that was the one thing I could do that she never could. (Naturally, my mother asked me for tips.)
So my heart breaks for your friend. I want very much to join the Air Force, to acquire those skills and that kind of strength, and it makes me so sad that someone you describe as so capable and wonderful is fighting the same battle so many of us are. For what it's worth: I know that it is possible to win.
But it's not just freedom of the unknown, sometimes. In my case, it's not having any other family, extended or immediate. With the freedom gained in breaking away, there is a loss: nowhere to go at holidays; no more calls home with good news just in the hope that someone might care; the fact of it being your f'ing mother. I know that people think that I'm insane for still talking to her, even, at this point, let alone living with her, but when the mother-daughter bond changes from dysfunctional but pulsing to a true break, it's hard to contemplate. Harder still when you know the person on the other end would be willing to walk away, which makes you cling even harder in the hope of making this work, somehow. I don't know if that's an issue with your friend, but it's... definitely something that I struggle with, and it's very hard to explain to the outside, because, yes, I could 'cut my losses' but getting the hell out of Dodge, but I'll acquire a new set of small griefs. At least when my mother is reminding me that I'm worthless, I know how to deal with that. The fear of the 'unknown' in my case, at least, is the question of: 'How can I -- can I? -- cope with the fact of nowhere to go at the holidays? At least if I'm miserable, I'm connected, but to have silence as the proof of what I already am, totally alone, oh, God, I don't know, maybe I can just get through this....'
08/28/09
08/28/09
I'm sorry that you have to go through that. Being rejected by a parent can be crippling but it seems as though you recognize the pattern and will be strong enough to break it. Hopefully you can build a support network apart from your mother and rely on these friends and mentors to help you through. I wish you all the best. You write beautifully.
08/28/09
I, too, wish you all the best.
08/28/09
I told mine "no one is allowed to talk to me that way" finally. When I was 45.
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
09/01/09
08/28/09
Dude, this kind of shit happens constantly to varying degrees, it's really not that "perplexing." You can be smart, you can be beautiful, you can be any number of wonderful things and still be controlled.
This mother is a total psycho--keeping her daughter in a crib during her toddler years? I hope she get jail time.
08/28/09
08/28/09
as creepy and horrific as this story is, the locale is too close to home for me as i don't live far from garwood.
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
[1heckofaguy.com]
08/28/09
ONLY FIVE YEARS?!
08/28/09
08/28/09
I don't know why they couldn't charge her with a more serious offense considering what this poor girl went through :(
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
Has anyone read The Almost Moon by Alice Sebold? I just finished it, and this story reminded me of the book.
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
08/28/09
And the father already plead guilty, so unless his attorney was total crap, it seems like the DA must have some case.