I think she'd have an argument if she could take the pitch of the grunt down from a shriek. I think the ladies have a tougher argument given that our voices pitch higher generally.
As one could probably tell from my comments in aggregate, I don't have a problem with the grunt in principle.
The complaints about grunting make no sense to me - when I did martial arts, we were encouraged to be as loud as we needed to be, because it helped to channel force and energy.
I didn't really buy into that for a while, but I got a hell of a lot louder when I actually learned how to put force behind my kicks and punches. It seems like it would be exactly the same for tennis - all your force is channeled into one particular move or strike.
Everyone at the office gives me a hard time about my grunting as I fill in complicated Excel spreadsheets, but you know what? I'm here to win. My grunting is for the better good.
06/24/09
[jezebel.com]
Careful there, Mr. Deford. Don't want to come up with an original thought or anything.
06/24/09
//sarcasm
06/24/09
06/24/09
06/24/09
06/24/09
06/24/09
06/23/09
As one could probably tell from my comments in aggregate, I don't have a problem with the grunt in principle.
06/23/09
I have to say, I do find it a bit excessive. But I think she knows that and I don't think they should HAVE to tell her to knock it off.
06/23/09
06/23/09
I think the appreciation for the sport could be drowned by the fact that silence must be maintained.
06/23/09
06/23/09
Case in point:

(No, I am not over his not being able to attempt to defend his title this year. Thank you for asking.)
06/23/09
06/23/09
I didn't really buy into that for a while, but I got a hell of a lot louder when I actually learned how to put force behind my kicks and punches. It seems like it would be exactly the same for tennis - all your force is channeled into one particular move or strike.
06/23/09
06/23/09
06/23/09
/hehehe
06/23/09