peppermintpatty

posts about #peppermintpatty more →
Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

rhymeswithfeather
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
BAAAAAAHHHH MY ROOMMATE CALLS EVERYTHING 'GAY' IN A DEROGATORY WAY. She is 25 years old, and even has gay friends, but no matter HOW many times I pull out the "dude, NOT cool to say that" lecture, she just doesn't get it.

Sample conversation:

Roommate: Omg, I fucking hate my ex-boyfriend, he's so gay.

Heather: YOU CAN'T SAY THAT.

Roommate: Oops. I mean, he's such a FAG.

This conversation happened, word for work, and there was not even a trace of irony.
Reply

rhymeswithfeather was starred

Hiroine Protagonist
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
Oh dear, I watched that clip three times (missed it last night - wuz boning) and I am caught in a disconnect:

Marge: "Let's go on a family OUTING"
Bart: "Lisa is gay"

Isn't Bart therefore OUTING Lisa - although not really? Are they subtly joking about those who lecture people about using the term gay as a pejorative? I dunno.
Reply

gobblegirl
03/09/09

@Hiroine Protagonist: No, I really don't think so. South Park would do that, Simpsons wouldn't. Yeah, Bart's not saying "oh, that's so gay," he is saying she's gay as a way to make fun of her. She's not lecturing him about using the word gay as a synonym for "not good." She's saying "so what if I were gay? It's not a bad thing."
Reply

gobblegirl was starred gobblegirl was unstarred

Hiroine Protagonist
03/09/09

@gobblegirl: No, I know, it's just that he says it right after Marge says "family outing."
Reply

Maulleigh
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
That is pretty cool. I gotta say she's a better feminist than I am sometimes.

I like that she's a feminist and totally into Malibu Stacey as I am a feminist and was really into Barbie. I even joined the fan club in the fifth grade.
Reply

Maulleigh was starred Maulleigh was unstarred

erinoherin
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
i was walking down the hallway with a lesbian friend of mine in high school when we overheard two freshman boys talking about lacrosse tryouts and one of them called it gay.

so my friend is really intimidating...but especially so, i would imagine for these boys. she wheeled around and said "OH MY GOD. are they forcing you to have sex with the other boys at lacrosse tryouts?!" they were insanely flustered and didnt know what to say to this scary senior girl so they just stuttered and she said "oh okay, well i guess if thats what your into, thats cool. its pretty brave of you to be so open about it."

and walked away. it was BRILLIANT.
Reply

erinoherin was starred erinoherin was unstarred

Hana Maru, used up old slutbag on the pole
03/09/09

@erinoherin: That's awesome.
Reply

ALEXANDRA_SUPERTRAMP
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
Wasn't Sappho not actually a lesbian, she just wrote poetry about lesbians? I thought she killed herself over a man, or something.

Still cool though.
Reply

prestocaro fears the culling
03/09/09

@ALEXANDRA_SUPERTRAMP: She was from the isle of lesbos, so she's a lesbian, right?
Reply

Cam/ron
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
It was a pretty cool scene in an episode that was timely in a very eerie way. Its deciption of how many foreclosures happened was dead-on.
Reply

Cam/ron was starred Cam/ron was unstarred

Artemisia999
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
I also hate the word "awesome" when used to describe EVERYTHING!!! Come on, expand your vocabulary!! You are NOT a teenage boy!!
Reply

Artemisia999 was starred Artemisia999 was unstarred

kimbert
03/09/09

@Artemisia999: Ummm... That was me, sorry. I describe everything as "awesome". I used to use "neat", but then I was accused of being stuck in a 1950's timewarp. So now I use awesome, because the eighties were way more awesome than the 00's.
Reply

kimbert was starred kimbert was unstarred

gobblegirl
03/09/09

@kimbertly1: Radical!
Reply

gobblegirl was starred gobblegirl was unstarred

CDarklock
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
I've always thought calling something "gay" was intended to be ironic - rather than displaying the actual homophobic attitudes of schoolchildren, you're deliberately mocking your own negative opinion as being a silly and childish thing to think.

Yeah, I know, that's gay.
Reply

CDarklock was starred CDarklock was unstarred

Beat Girl
03/09/09

@CDarklock: It usually isn't said be people who are genuinely homophobic, in my experience. I don't think anyone is saying that, but it's the connotations it carries and passes on by its usage in this form. Also, irony is fucking lazy hipster nonsense, imho.
Reply

Beat Girl was starred Beat Girl was unstarred

prestocaro fears the culling
03/09/09

@CDarklock: I started saying "gay" as a joke and now it's invaded my real pattern of speech. It is very hard to stop and I frequently have to correct myself, but think of it this way: if people used other pejorative terms ironically, do they still offend?

"I can call black people niggers because I'm not really racist, I mean it ironically"

"well, I know that person with Downs feels bad, but calling him/her a retard was tongue in cheek"

"I respect your culture; I'm just joking when I call you a wetback"

Doesn't really work for me. Maybe it works for you.
Reply

Hana Maru, used up old slutbag on the pole
03/09/09

@CDarklock: Are you gay? Because that's the only way it's ironic when you say it. Otherwise you're just brandishing your straight privilege with no regard for the out and closeted gay people around you. It's not irony to take a lighthearted approach to denigrating language.
Reply

Andalucía
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
Now, if they can do something for "girly" I'd be in heaven. I hate it.

I was so pissed as a kid when I figured out that my very existence was an insult (e.g., "little girl").
Reply

Andalucía was starred Andalucía was unstarred

Hana Maru, used up old slutbag on the pole
03/09/09

@Andalucía: "Girly" "You're being a girl/woman" "You____ like a girl/woman" are everywhere. I once broke up with a guy after his friend teased him by calling him a woman and he was all "OMG worst insult ever!" right in front of me, and with no trace of irony. I start hating whomever says that shit.
Reply

sunoftheskye
03/09/09

@HanaMaru: Reminds me of an episode of Judge Alex or maybe Judge Mathis about a dispute between two ex-roommates, and the defendant said his reasoning for leaving was that his roommate was too much like a woman.

I thought to myself...why would that be a bad thing? Aren't females typically cleaner, less rambunctious, and more responsible?
Reply

sunoftheskye was starred sunoftheskye was unstarred

Hana Maru, used up old slutbag on the pole
03/09/09

@sunoftheskye: OMG. The flip side of that is how men and woman can be complimented by being associated with manliness "You took it like a man" "Manned up and did the right thing" "You've got balls" "One of the boys"(another great reason to hate Katy Perry)
Reply

Beat Girl
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
On a related note, why won't people own up to the fact that when they are saying this sort of thing, it's largely because they're afraid of homosexuality?

I can't begin to express my confusion about the fact that there are still people in the world afraid to catch THE GAY.
Reply

Beat Girl was starred Beat Girl was unstarred

Rocket Queen
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
List of gay heroes: FREDDIE MERCURY
Reply

Rocket Queen was starred Rocket Queen was unstarred

budholly101
03/09/09

@Rocket Queen: Oh Freddie Mercury! Anyone who knows me for any amount of time knows of my passion for Freddie. I will go to my grave regretting that I was too young to have ever seen him in concert. My dad did, and I'm so jealous.
Reply

budholly101 was starred budholly101 was unstarred

Beat Girl
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
I absolutely cannot stand this use of gay. It pains me to explain at length why it is offensive to me, and yet I have had to do it numerous times.

It shouldn't, but it pains me all the more to have done it to many young gay people too.
Reply

Beat Girl was starred Beat Girl was unstarred

yvanehtnioj
03/09/09

@Miss Carrie Nation: I used to work at a youth shelter. Every time a kid used "gay" or "retarded", I'd have to go through the whole thing.

"What, it's really happy? / Oh, it's developmentally disabled?"
"Oh, then why use that word?"
"Thanks, I think that's a better choice."

The kids generally thought I was a nice person, so they'd adjust their language around me. Honestly, I felt like my biggest accomplishment there was when a new kid used "retarded" on his first day and a kid that had been there longer said "We don't use that word here." Small victories.
Reply

yvanehtnioj was starred yvanehtnioj was unstarred

Beat Girl
03/09/09

@yvanehtnioj: Oh, that's lovely! I usually just say "Don't use that word, please. Or at least not around me to mean bad. Thanks". But it NEVER rests at that, they always need a reason. I think I'd feel better if it were kids, but it's always 20-somethings. Sigh!
Reply

Beat Girl was starred Beat Girl was unstarred

Liz11685
03/09/09

@yvanehtnioj: I use retarded, and blame it on my Boston upbringing, where "retahhhded" flows like water. I am trying to use these tactics on MYSELF. It really is a small victory when people stop using pejorative terms.
Reply

Liz11685 was starred Liz11685 was unstarred

ellaesther
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
...aaaannnnd cue lawsuit from the Schultz estate in 3... 2... 1....
Reply

ellaesther was starred ellaesther was unstarred

NefariousNewt
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
Remember when the word "gay" meant "happy?" Of course, back then women couldn't vote, Jim Crow laws were everywhere, and they banned liquor, but hey!!!
Reply

NefariousNewt was starred NefariousNewt was unstarred

kelsium
03/09/09

@NefariousNewt: Oh, and homosexuality was classified as a mental illness in the DSM.
Reply

kelsium was starred kelsium was unstarred

Liz11685
03/09/09

@NefariousNewt: I grew up on Gay Street, and we always said it meant happy!!
Reply

Liz11685 was starred Liz11685 was unstarred

prestocaro fears the culling
03/09/09

@Liz11685: There is a Gay car dealership in Dickenson, TX (near the town I live in). It's owned by an older lady, her last name is Gay.

[www.gaypontiacbuickgmc.com]

It makes me laugh because what if there were gay dealerships, like how there are gay bars?
Reply

westvillagegirl (exiled in chicago)
03/09/09

In reply to Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work
I'm know I might be failing as a feminazi bonerkiller, but who is pictured in the second photo? She looks like a badass. I can't listen to the video, and how does one google an image?
Reply

Dadadarling
03/09/09

@westvillagegirl (exiled in chicago): Susan Sontag
Reply

Dadadarling was starred Dadadarling was unstarred

arodriguez.romero
03/09/09

@westvillagegirl (exiled in chicago): figure out how to google an image and you'll be richer than Bill Gates
Reply

arodriguez.romero was starred

arodriguez.romero
03/09/09

@westvillagegirl (exiled in chicago):and it's Susan Sontag btw
Reply

arodriguez.romero was starred

arodriguez.romero
03/09/09

@Dadadarling: whoops sorry dept. of redundancy dept.
Reply

arodriguez.romero was starred

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#peppermintpatty

Jezebel

SUBSCRIBE TO Jezebel

Lisa Simpson On Why "Gay" As An Insult Doesn't Work

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment