natalie pack - Jezebel

posts about #nataliepack more →
ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

prettycool
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
I've always had a theory that every three cycles a black girl wins ANTM no matter what. It's probably rude to assume its based on race, but looking back:

Cycle 3-Eva

Cycle 6- Danielle

Cycle 9-Saleisha

Cycle 12- Teyona ('cause she's getting a winner's edit)

I came up with it after Saleisha wrongfully won that cycle. And if Teyona does win, it'll be set in stone in my mind.(not that she isn't good though)
Reply

prettycool was starred prettycool was unstarred

garconne est grise
04/24/09

@prettycool: I actually read about a more complex pattern, which is: every 4 cycles there are 2 European destinations with white winners, an Asian destination with a black winner, and an other destination with an "other" winner (Naima, Jaslene).

Which has me completely convinced that Fo will take it. Or Teyona (this pattern is probably coincidence, but either way I know that they aren't going to have 3 white winners in a row).
Reply

garconne est grise was starred

prettycool
04/24/09

@garconne: I guess we'll have to see whose pattern will prevail. Also, I think we can both agree that Allison ain't gonna win this thing (though I'm sure she'll be in the top three if not the runner up)

@barb95: Please tell me you read Rich's blog?! It's so funny I snort like a mama pig every time.
Reply

prettycool was starred prettycool was unstarred

Hana Maru
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
How do you like your sour grapes, Natalie?

Aminat and Natalie both had bad pictures, but Natalie has more bad pictures overall; you can see it in the ending montage. She even has the exact same expression on her face, complete with the one raised eyebrow. She also did badly at the challenge. As far as her looking like a model, sure, she looks like a commercial model. She does not have the body for runway.

Is she really afraid that people will think she said all those rude and condescending things all at once in that montage? Of course they edited that together. She gave them enough material for the montage, plus more stank comments in almost every episode. And the other girls were talking about her bad attitude, too. I don't buy that it was fabricated.

Also, she is accusing Tyra of discriminating against her because of her race. She should just take responsibility for that opinion and not try to have it both ways.
Reply

Hana Maru was starred Hana Maru was unstarred

JinxyMcDeath
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
I really, really, really, hate pulling the race card here...but I do think Tyra has a certain favoritism towards the black models...though it may be subconcious. I mean Aminat and Teyona are NOT good models...and yet...
Reply

JinxyMcDeath was starred JinxyMcDeath was unstarred

Jackiewsu
04/24/09

@JinxyMcDeath: it's a panel of 5 judges so they would all have to playing favorites with black models.
Reply

Jackiewsu was starred Jackiewsu was unstarred

Hana Maru
04/24/09

@Jackiewsu: Yes Tyra only has one vote out of 5.
Reply

Hana Maru was starred Hana Maru was unstarred

raesanni
04/24/09

@JinxyMcDeath: actually, teyona's a great model!
Reply

raesanni was starred raesanni was unstarred

misspell
04/24/09

@raysanni: Yeah, totally. She's not always model-y when she's not doing a shoot, but her pictures always turn out gorgeous.
Reply

misspell was starred misspell was unstarred

AuntieBee
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
Hey, Natalie,

Sucks that you got canned, I hear ya. But you know, I have never actually managed to get my hands on the Unbiased Criteria by Which to Judge MODDLES Declaration before. Could you lend me your copy? Because I totally agree that there is some kind of preference being displayed.

Most sincerely,

AuntieBee

ps. I am not touching your "she's a racist but I am not actually calling her a racist, just expressing my opinion" comment with a ten foot pole.
Reply

AuntieBee was starred AuntieBee was unstarred

Uncommon Whore
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
Ah ha ha! That's what I said yesterday. Tyra and Jay don't even communicate anymore, much less click.
Reply

Uncommon Whore was starred Uncommon Whore was unstarred

fulanita
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
See also: Whitney, the girl with the Tootie haircut. It was clear almost from day one that they were going to win no matter what.
Reply

fulanita was starred fulanita was unstarred

fulanita
04/24/09

@fulanita: Whitney AND the girl with...

I could even add Jaslene and Naima to that list
Reply

fulanita was starred fulanita was unstarred

stoprobbers
04/24/09

@fulanita: Naima and Saleisha (tootie) are the two least deserving winners, at least that I can remember.

I can't believe Naima beat Kahlen. Kahlen looked like Carmen Kass! When you look like an already established supermodel, and can take good-to-great pictures, then you should win!
Reply

stoprobbers was starred stoprobbers was unstarred

Penny
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
It's a reality show, and one of the campiest ones at that, I am not entirely sure what she was expecting....
Reply

Penny was starred Penny was unstarred

casi nadie (loves MCC forever)
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
Really though, this is a television show. It's not a contest based on talent, it's a reality show contest based on entertainment values. Yes, there is a prize at the end - but it isn't won by the best model or most deserving girl, it's won by the one who somehow makes it to the end and gets chosen by the producers. People don't watch the show to watch girls learn how to model, they watch it for the ridiculous factor and the cool pictures, and it really surprises me that the girls auditioning for it don't realize that.
Reply

casi nadie (loves MCC forever)
04/24/09

!@o português é muito sexy é sozinha.: It seems sort of strange to me that everyone's comments are "I've heard rumors that tyra's really like this!" She's the producer of a TV show, she's going to do what gets her ratings. Ridiculousness and drama in ANTM . . . gets ratings. It doesn't seem like much of a surprise to me that - shocker - she makes choices in front of a camera and that may not be the same way she is when the camera is off!
Reply

casi nadie (loves MCC forever)
04/24/09

@o português é muito sexy é sozinha.: I should not have said everyone; I should have said that "oftentimes people say" . . .
Reply

Uncommon Whore
04/24/09

@o português é muito sexy é sozinha.: Next thing you're going to tell me Santa isn't real! Say it ain't so!
Reply

Uncommon Whore was starred Uncommon Whore was unstarred

the dodo, the cuckoo, and the nene
04/24/09

@o português é muito sexy é sozinha.: It's a reality competition. Of course Tyra will have favorites. There's no reason why it should be fair. And the women on the show should have realized that by now.
Reply

mharker
04/24/09

@o português é muito sexy é sozinha.: To be honest, I'm surprised you're not surprised. A lot of the girls seem to have delusions of grandeur. To them, the competition isn't fixed because they are going to win it.
Reply

mharker was starred mharker was unstarred

casi nadie (loves MCC forever)
04/24/09

@mharker: touche.
Reply

morninggloria
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
And I could be accused of acting racist-y for saying this, but I swear I'm not trying to be, but it seems that every single cycle there is a black girl who makes it to the final four or three who is kept for an inexplicably long time and really has no business being there, and I've always thought what Natalie said- that Tyra relates to being young, black, and struggling, and not cut any breaks, so she cuts them a few breaks. However, they never win. Except Danielle won, but that's because she straight up rocked.

Examples: Bianca, Keenya, Eugenia.
Reply

morninggloria was starred morninggloria was unstarred

Penny
04/24/09

@morninggloria: Eh, it's not racist to point out the obvious, just as it's not unusual or wrong for someone to have a personal bias.

Danielle did rock, it was the only season I watched. Man, I loved her.
Reply

Penny was starred Penny was unstarred

hfree
04/24/09

@morninggloria: Don't forget Saleisha. She won and probably shouldn't have. That was the most flagrant example of favoritism I've ever seen on this show.
Reply

hfree was starred hfree was unstarred

hfree
04/24/09

@hfree: Not to say that Danielle should not have won, I think Danielle's great.
Reply

hfree was starred hfree was unstarred

Evie Havok
04/24/09

@morninggloria: In a world were minorities never get breaks (deserved or not--lets face it white people get undeserved breaks, too, so let's not go there) I don't really care if Tyra gives them one. I'm glad that at least a person of color who has made it (Tyra) is making it easier for other people of color. *speaking as a person of color*
Reply

Evie Havok was starred Evie Havok was unstarred

Hana Maru
04/24/09

@morninggloria: Well Keenyah and Eugenia are working models, and Eugenia's doing runway. I don't know if Bianca is working currently or not, but she was actually doing well in the competition. I thought she deserved her spot, even if she had a stank personality.

As far as there always being a black girl who doesn't deserve to stay, that's likely to happen when the show starts with a higher proportion of black girls than you would normally see on television. Every season there's a white girl or two who inexplicably gets promoted along, and often ends up in the top 3 or 4, too. But no one would look at that as favoritism.
Reply

Hana Maru was starred Hana Maru was unstarred

ThatsJustLovely12
04/24/09

@afiunderground: Isn't Affirmative Action a little bit of a break for minorities?
Reply

ThatsJustLovely12 was starred

Hana Maru
04/24/09

@ThatsJustLovely12: No, it's not. It's attempting to level an unlevel playing field.
Reply

Hana Maru was starred Hana Maru was unstarred

Jessi Ramsey
04/24/09

@HanaMaru: Bianca is getting work. I've seen her on a few runways.

@afiunderground: word. And in this industry, where a brown girl is lucky to even be considered for a shoot outside of commercial/catalog work, it really does not bother me. Tyra of all people would know this, so it makes a lot of sense that she would want to keep a girl of color or two around for a bit longer. It's her show.
Reply

Jessi Ramsey was starred Jessi Ramsey was unstarred

Hana Maru
04/24/09

@Jessi Ramsey: "Bianca is getting work..." Well there you go. I'll eat my hat the day a white host is accused of playing race favorites for keeping white contestants around on the many, many shows that have few to nil contestants of color.
Reply

Hana Maru was starred Hana Maru was unstarred

AthertonMerriweather
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
Yeah well, she can kiss Tyra's FAT ASS!!
Reply

StarSquid
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
Aminat's photo was garbage this week.

Fo or Allison, FTW!!
Reply

StarSquid was starred StarSquid was unstarred

stoprobbers
04/24/09

@StarSquid: Fo's so boring. Like dishwater. And she's SHORT.

I know, I know, Kate Moss etc., but look: Models are tall. That's, like, half of being a model. Tall + Skinny = Moddle. Beauty can be manipulated by hair and makeup. But you MUST be tall and skinny.
Reply

stoprobbers was starred stoprobbers was unstarred

lilbobbytables
04/24/09

@StarSquid: Alison FTW! I am making t-shirts for next week. Mostly to annoy my anti-Alison ANTM watching friend.
Reply

lilbobbytables was starred lilbobbytables was unstarred

StarSquid
04/24/09

@stoprobbers: Really? I think Fo is one of the more interesting, fresh and "fierce" faces out of the bunch. She is short compared to the rest of the contestants, but in general I think all those girls are tall - there is a minimum height requirement to get onto ANTM.
Reply

StarSquid was starred StarSquid was unstarred

stoprobbers
04/24/09

@StarSquid: The minimum height requirement is, like, 5' 7". I'm unimpressed.

Fo is miles away from "fierce," not that I care about fierceness. Her freckles are nice, but she bores me to tears. Pictures of her bore me to tears. If I was flipping through a magazine, no way she'd make me stop.
Reply

stoprobbers was starred stoprobbers was unstarred

Jessi Ramsey
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
I don't doubt that Tyra plays favorites and is hella shady, but while Natalie is very pretty girl she doesn't truly have a model look. A lot of models come into my office for castings and I can't see someone booking her for editorial or runway.
Reply

Jessi Ramsey was starred Jessi Ramsey was unstarred

JessaFields
04/24/09

@Jessi Ramsey: Yeah, she's pretty but there's nothing extraordinary about her. She doesn't have the cheekbones that most models do.
Reply

JessaFields was starred JessaFields was unstarred

Hana Maru
04/24/09

@JessaFields: and she had the exact same face in every picture; you could see it in the montage at the end. She was incapable of doing anything else.
Reply

Hana Maru was starred Hana Maru was unstarred

BoozeInMyBlood[had lost her password]
04/24/09

@Jessi Ramsey: Can i have a job with your please? What sort of college do i need for that sort of thing?
Reply

Jessi Ramsey
04/24/09

@BoozeInMyBlood[is lusting over Seth Green]: I'll PM you.
Reply

Jessi Ramsey was starred Jessi Ramsey was unstarred

gobble_dee_goop
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
you know, i've heard rumours like these about tyra before. specifically regarding the way she treats audience members during taping. she apparently completely shuts off during the break, but when cameras begin to roll its the "tyra-show" all over again.
Reply

gobble_dee_goop was starred gobble_dee_goop was unstarred

EsmereldaFitzmonster
04/24/09

@gobble_dee_goop: I don't doubt it, but some TV personalities are very subdued off-camera so that they can keep their energy and chemistry fresh for the camera. Maybe that's what she does?
Reply

Hana Maru
04/24/09

@gobble_dee_goop: I think it makes a lot of sense to need to recharge and save your voice and energy during breaks. Most TV hosts aren't "on" when they're not on camera.
Reply

Hana Maru was starred Hana Maru was unstarred

lilbobbytables
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
On one hand, I can agree that Tyra's feelings towards the girls are not particularly hidden, and probably affect the outcome of the show. But on the other hand, if Tyra sent home people she because didn't like them, I think Celia would have been out weeks ago.

But yeah, I agree that the judging probably is probably not the most objective.
Reply

lilbobbytables was starred lilbobbytables was unstarred

stoprobbers
04/24/09

@lilbobbytables: I think Celia makes it all the way to the final three because the panel wants to see what she will wear. I want to see what she will wear. The job at Bergdoff seems to have seriously paid off.
Reply

stoprobbers was starred stoprobbers was unstarred

lilbobbytables
04/24/09

@stoprobbers: I think Celia will make the final 3, but I also suspect that Tyra wants to push her in front of the stretch hummer, after the Talia judging incident.

But yeah, Celia wears some awesome outfits.
Reply

lilbobbytables was starred lilbobbytables was unstarred

saintbernadette
04/24/09

In reply to ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"
News flash. But thanks anyway, Natalie.
Reply

saintbernadette was starred saintbernadette was unstarred

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#nataliepack

Jezebel

SUBSCRIBE TO Jezebel

ANTM Contestant Accuses Tyra Of Being "Shady"

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment