I thought this was what people usually say about Hanukkah in general? It's basically an apocryphal holiday, and not even a particularly fun one unless you're merging it with Christmas, in which case all bets are off anyway.
@pesematology: Who says it's an apocryphal holiday? I think that's the wrong word usage. The Talmud is totally on board with the holiday. But what people complain about is the influence of Christmas that has resulted in heavy present-giving on the holiday.
I'm so sick of people representing my community making an issue out of something that isn't even a high holiday. The only reason Chanukah gets so much attention is because it's time coincides with Christmas.
Everyone knows Purim is the most fun holiday anyhow, lemme hear your clackers peeps! Can a brother get a Hamen up in this mug?
@logruszed: I love Purim and all its hamentaschen goodness. I still have a few clackers (why can I not remember what they're called? I just referenced them earlier this week) from 20+ years ago.
@andBegorrah: That's what I was thinking. Like wow, that's an awful lot of effort for a minor holiday... I only remembered to light candles this afternoon. Did it become a big deal in the US because it coincides roughly with Christmas, or what?
Edit to add: I'm actually more irritated by the fact that American Christians make a massive deal out of Chanukah for that reason. It's like, way to barely even attempt anything other than a cursory 'it's like Jewish Christmas'.
@rah29: Exactly. I'll be impressed when I see Joe Biden in a Purim costume. (And not just because of the slash fic I've already written involving that scenario.)
I sent my Jewish grandmother and aunt and uncle "holiday" cards a couple of years ago that simply depicted a bare pine tree and the text "season's greetings." I thought that was fine, but my mom (the non-Jewish parent) told me that was probably too Christmassy. It's a pine tree! Why does Christmas automatically get reign over pine trees? It's not like it had a bunch of tinsel drawn on it and big fucking star on top.
@FactCat: I wanted to buy my nephew a sweater with a penguin on it and my mom told me it was too Christmassy. I think that is stretching it a little. It's a cute penguin in a toque. How is that Christmas?
@EndangeredRed: The Clintons did Hannukah as well. I remember one of the little girls lighting the menorah accidentally caught her hair on fire. Bill Clinton himself rushed patted it out with his hands.
@ucelluccia: Ok, well those specifc penguins are on the Chrismas side, what with their being a baby Jesus penguin and all. But I'm pretty sure we can slap a yarmulke on a penguin too!
12/11/09
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!
12/11/09
I thought this was what people usually say about Hanukkah in general? It's basically an apocryphal holiday, and not even a particularly fun one unless you're merging it with Christmas, in which case all bets are off anyway.
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
Everyone knows Purim is the most fun holiday anyhow, lemme hear your clackers peeps! Can a brother get a Hamen up in this mug?
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
"Fill up my cup (Drank!)
Mazel tov (La chaim!)"
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
Edit to add: I'm actually more irritated by the fact that American Christians make a massive deal out of Chanukah for that reason. It's like, way to barely even attempt anything other than a cursory 'it's like Jewish Christmas'.
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
But also kind of amazing.
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
Goodname by the way.
12/13/09
12/14/09
I would toss out more hebrew but I've forgotten all sense of grammar haha. My Israeli friends pat me on the head.
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
Just throwing that out there.
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
I sent my Jewish grandmother and aunt and uncle "holiday" cards a couple of years ago that simply depicted a bare pine tree and the text "season's greetings." I thought that was fine, but my mom (the non-Jewish parent) told me that was probably too Christmassy. It's a pine tree! Why does Christmas automatically get reign over pine trees? It's not like it had a bunch of tinsel drawn on it and big fucking star on top.
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
12/11/09
10/26/09