@PersonalBest: Maybe they think by keeping them close, they know where they are and won't be found? I'm sure there are other reasons but it could be a matter of not wanting to be caught.
There is a woman in the town I live in who had two of her children in her freezer. A third girl escaped the house and neighbors found her, injured and abused. When cops searched the mother's house they found the other two girls. The mother actually killed the girls earlier and moved across the state with them in the freezer. The weird part in this sick story is that they were all adopted. Can you get post-partum when you adopt children?
@linnyt is a walking cliché: PPD isn't the only reason why some women kill their kids though, you know? There are plenty of other mental illnesses that could drive women to do something like this. I would guess a woman that killed her adopted kids had other problems, besides PPD.
@linnyt is a walking cliché: Wow, that is fucked up. Reminds me of Sylvia Likens' case. Or that family who had 'natural' children and foster children, and starved and abused the foster children so the teenagers looked like they were maybe 9 years old.
I don't even know what to say... How could the husband be so totally oblivious? You're supposed to be married to your partner. That, to me, is the most disturbing part. But so fucking tragic all around.
I would imagine that doing this three times over the course of several years and multiple pregnancies is going to get a LOT of people who otherwise would have been sympathetic more hostile.
@Eleanor Ramilly: Its ridiculous, but it does make it easier to understand their position.
I'm hoping that they find some serious mental illness, because I don't want to believe a fully healthy person would give birth, then murder her own children.
The problem is: how do you detect this? How do you know which woman might be susceptible? Guys are not the most observant creatures in the world; even I had trouble tracking what my wife went through when she was pregnant with our daughter.
What still has me astounded is that the husband never knew. Maybe it was more like he didn't want to know.
@NefariousNewt: He might be the type who doesn't even know what type of birth control his partner takes. Yes, they exist, in blissful ignorance (emphasis on the latter)
I just can't believe the husband didn't suspect something was up.
Your wife is preganant (and you don't know), gives birth (and you don't know), kills babies (and you don't know), and hides them in the freezer (and you don't know)?
@dianersb was bit by a zombie: However, he did call the police after discovering the bodies (thinking that a visitor had left them there), which would be a strange thing to do if he were complicit.
@PersonalBest: True. I just have a hard time with the whole thing. I mean, this happened three times? I realize that most of us can be pretty oblivious, but that's some serious non-observation right there.
@dianersb was bit by a zombie: This is such a strange, strange case. I mean, even upon finding frozen bodies in my freezer, I'd really have a hard time thinking that a visitor to my house, someone that I knew, and had left them there without thinking that they would eventually be discovered and the police would be called.
@PersonalBest: Denial is a very powerful thing. Sometimes Mr. Denial -- who lives in the back of your brain -- steps forward while Mr. Logic tries to make sense of all the shit that's happening.
@gherkinfiend: Okay, the travelling thing does help explain it more. I had assumed he was at home throughout the pregnancies. That helps explain how he could not have known what was going on.
The article from the Independent is just disturbing. I never knew this happened so often!
@PersonalBest: Thinking a visitor left them there? What, like someone came over for tea with an extra-large handbag and stuffed a body in the freezer while the wife was in the bathroom? I guess it's possible it just seems so absurd.
@Penny_Esq has a new job!: Well, if the alternatives are a visitor or the woman you love, you'll go with the visitor, even if it is crazy. Admitting loved ones can do horrible things is very hard for a lot of people.
I also don't like that an immediate line is drawn from murdering a child to PPD. PPD is incredibly serious and it certainly does not mean that a woman who kills her baby must have it. Co-morbidity aside, drawing these immediate conclusions further stigmatizes PPD.
@Santos L Halper: It's really bizarre to feel the need to be flip about something like that. Like, Oh, I'm so unaffected by children, I can make jokes about their deaths. It's gross.
@GirlSailor: I think in a lot of cases it's a sort of "Whistling past the graveyard" response: it's so horrible that people don't know exactly how to react, and so some people will make jokes, because it's too hard to really engage with the horror of it. (I say this as someone with serious inappropriate laughter syndrome; I giggle like a lunatic when I'm horrified).
@debo matar la zombi goldberry83: I know what you mean. However, we're not like in a social setting here. Inappropriate laughter is one thing; I've had it happen myself. If you want, write out the joke, have a good chuckle to relieve the tension. And then hit that little "x." I just question whether these jokes would be made in real life, and that's probably the litmus test of good taste.
@Santos L Halper: I commented on this in the above thread trying to explain/justify why I made a joke. As someone on this thread said, for me this kind of dark humor is a coping mechanism for confronting horrible things - like murdering babies. I think part of my mistake in doing this is not in the making a joke at all, but making it in a forum of strangers who don't know me or the psychology behind my behavior.
It's also true - and I don't know why this is - that if the story were about toddlers or older, I probably wouldn't have made a joke - I guess because babies are easier to de-personalize? I'm not saying this is rational, just noting it because now I'm all curious about what IS the line for dark humor? Because it's used a lot around here, but apparently there's an invisible line... I imagine it varies from person to person.....
@PreposterousHypothesis: @JessJess: Yeah, you're right: there's way less excuse for that sort of knee-jerk, "Oh shit, that's awful, here's a joke so I can deflect it" reaction when you're typing out your comment instead of blurting it into a conversation at an unfortunate moment.
@dreamweave: That's a good question, and maybe one Hortense/the editors could help with. My personal litmus test is "would I tell this joke in a mixed crowd?" Of course Jezebel is somewhat of a like-minded community, so some things are going to fly better here than in real life...I won't go off-topic anymore, but it is something worth discussing I think.
But anyway, infanticide is extremely common in nature. Animals kill their young if there isn't enough food around at that moment, if it's sickly-seeming, if a new male comes around...any number of reasons. We can think we've evolved past that all we want but the fact remains the impulse is still there for some people, for whatever reason, and they often DO know better and don't WANT to do it. Help need to be more available
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
(But seriously this story freaks me out).
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
I'm hoping that they find some serious mental illness, because I don't want to believe a fully healthy person would give birth, then murder her own children.
06/16/09
To clarify, that's not my belief, but I think for some anti-choice individuals, that's exactly the issue.
06/16/09
06/16/09
What still has me astounded is that the husband never knew. Maybe it was more like he didn't want to know.
06/16/09
06/16/09
Your wife is preganant (and you don't know), gives birth (and you don't know), kills babies (and you don't know), and hides them in the freezer (and you don't know)?
This just doesn't add up.
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
[news.bbc.co.uk]
There was also a similar case (but involving more babies) in Germany a few years ago that suggests the whole scenario is more common that thought
[www.independent.co.uk]
06/16/09
The article from the Independent is just disturbing. I never knew this happened so often!
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/17/09
[news.bbc.co.uk]
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
Then again, the opportunities for dead baby jokes are so rare...
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
It's also true - and I don't know why this is - that if the story were about toddlers or older, I probably wouldn't have made a joke - I guess because babies are easier to de-personalize? I'm not saying this is rational, just noting it because now I'm all curious about what IS the line for dark humor? Because it's used a lot around here, but apparently there's an invisible line... I imagine it varies from person to person.....
Just thinking.
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
But anyway, infanticide is extremely common in nature. Animals kill their young if there isn't enough food around at that moment, if it's sickly-seeming, if a new male comes around...any number of reasons. We can think we've evolved past that all we want but the fact remains the impulse is still there for some people, for whatever reason, and they often DO know better and don't WANT to do it. Help need to be more available