It also says that they might not have wanted help.
The UK debate seems to be polarised by Laura Agustin ("it's all women with free agency, coming here to work by choice") and the Poppy Project ("they're all trafficked and abused"). Sex workers, and especially immigrant sex workers, just aren't a homogeneous population.
@sanibelly: That's not what I said. They're not ALL trafficked. Some of the women "liberated" by Operation Pentameter weren't trafficked. Some of them were.
I was presenting two sides of the UK debate. Here's a review of Agustin's book: [www.newstatesman.com]
There have been problems in the UK with campaigners claiming that most of the women in the UK sex trade are trafficked, when what they mean is that 75% of the women working in London are from overseas. Which doesn't necessarily mean trafficked. And it's just London, not the UK (countrywide, working girls are more likely to be British).
But the statistics are always problematic with sex work. And yes, women do get kidnapped and forced into sex work: [www.metro.co.uk]
Some of the women kidnapped and forced into sex work are even British.
@bowleserised: Thank you for the clarification. I know that's not what you said, which is why I asked that question. And thank you for admitting, however begrudgingly, that there are women who are forced into sex work. I know we like to think it's all those poor women who innocently chose sex work, but can we please put some urgency into locating and helping (and stopping, in the first place) women who are forced into this against their will? I can't think of anything more disgusting or horrifying and my heart goes out to those women who we shrug our shoulders at.
@sanibelly: I didn't admit it "begrudgingly" at all. That "slaughterhouse" case is horrific.
I've been working on and off for research on the subject for months now, using a variety of sources and talking to a lot of people involved. I just finished reading an account of one British woman's experience of being trafficked into Amsterdam...
BUT the police are also using things like Pentameter against women who have made the choice to do sex work: [www.prostitutescollective.net]
I was in Cambodia (Siam Reap) this summer for about two days. I knew that it had not recovered... well... from the genocide, and I know enough about how the government functions to know that what I saw was barely the tip of the iceberg.
This is great. Really, really great. Sex tourism is a painful, awful thing, and any opportunity to try to give more options to anyone is good. Especially if they are sustainable and affordable.
These women are really, really inspiring.
Nicholas Kristof over at the NYT has been writing articles on this topic for some time now - heartwrenching stuff. Reading about Alissa and Diana's work is a great antidote.
Link to Kristof's archives: [topics.nytimes.com]
One of the things that strikes me about this interview, is these are women who are not afraid to speak honestly and clearly about all they've accomplished. No false modesty, no pretending what they've done is no big deal. They own their awesomeness, which only increases their awesomeness to me.
Good. Something to link to when some American douche explains that his sex tourism is saving some poor young girl who has no other way to support herself.
Also, just bought a bag off the site! That's the trick – make it easy as heck to donate.
@IvyArbor: Oh lord yes, though I'll admit most are arguing behind the veil of internet anonymity. It's a bit like people who support slave labor, saying otherwise the workers would be forced into sexual slavery... as if a third option not involving any kind of slavery would be possible.
@IvyArbor: I've heard it as well. My sister is passionate about this cause and has been working to help, and was written up in the local paper for her efforts. Of course, some pedophile comments "But they make enough money to support like EVERYBODY THEY KNOW, and the one I went to said she thought it was a great opportunity!" I didn't trust myself to reply without burning the internets down with my white-hot rage, but luckily some other people gave him the beatdown immediately.
Absolutely amazing. I was JUST talking to co-workers about trafficking during lunch. This is an INCREDIBLE organization and good on you Alissa and Diana!
I hate to correct Getty again, but correct I must: It's not "a modern day form of slavery" -- it's slavery, plain and simple. No caveats, no modifiers. Slavery.
09/16/09
The UK debate seems to be polarised by Laura Agustin ("it's all women with free agency, coming here to work by choice") and the Poppy Project ("they're all trafficked and abused"). Sex workers, and especially immigrant sex workers, just aren't a homogeneous population.
09/16/09
09/16/09
I was presenting two sides of the UK debate. Here's a review of Agustin's book: [www.newstatesman.com]
And here's the Poppy Project:
[www.eaves4women.co.uk]
There have been problems in the UK with campaigners claiming that most of the women in the UK sex trade are trafficked, when what they mean is that 75% of the women working in London are from overseas. Which doesn't necessarily mean trafficked. And it's just London, not the UK (countrywide, working girls are more likely to be British).
But the statistics are always problematic with sex work. And yes, women do get kidnapped and forced into sex work:
[www.metro.co.uk]
Some of the women kidnapped and forced into sex work are even British.
09/16/09
09/16/09
I've been working on and off for research on the subject for months now, using a variety of sources and talking to a lot of people involved. I just finished reading an account of one British woman's experience of being trafficked into Amsterdam...
BUT the police are also using things like Pentameter against women who have made the choice to do sex work: [www.prostitutescollective.net]
09/01/09
This is great. Really, really great. Sex tourism is a painful, awful thing, and any opportunity to try to give more options to anyone is good. Especially if they are sustainable and affordable.
09/01/09
Nicholas Kristof over at the NYT has been writing articles on this topic for some time now - heartwrenching stuff. Reading about Alissa and Diana's work is a great antidote.
Link to Kristof's archives:
[topics.nytimes.com]
09/01/09
09/01/09
[www.thebodyshop.co.uk]
09/01/09
09/01/09
09/01/09
Also, just bought a bag off the site! That's the trick – make it easy as heck to donate.
09/01/09
09/01/09
09/01/09
09/01/09
09/01/09
08/20/09
08/20/09
08/20/09
08/20/09
08/20/09
08/20/09
08/20/09
@Skellatrix: Gee, why would you think that?
08/20/09
.
08/20/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
06/16/09
FIXED.
06/16/09