Obviously, Rein is making a huge mistake in only promoting people who ask for promotions, he's probably missing some great talent.
But I do think women need to think about promotions and wage increases more.
At my first post college job, the salary was set and unmovable but being fresh undergrads I don't think we knew that. Only one person out of the 12 people I knew tried to negotiate at all, and he was one of the three guys at my level.
I negotiated my way into that job my playing a job offer elsewhere off an interview, but it didn't occur to me to bargain. I've seen a lot of comments in the open threads where people don't even try for a raise or worse still, stay at a job that won't promote them without looking elsewhere. You can often get more money as a new employee.
I know that women are looked down on for this behavior, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't do it. Your co-workers and bosses don't actually have to like you. It is a risk, but asking for more isn't a bad idea.
I think men need to grow up if they can't handle women not dressing like dowdy school marms at the work place. What the hell difference should it make in how we dress as long as it's tasteful? Are there infinite articles for men on how they should tuck in their shirts and not where Spiderman ties to work if THEY want to be taken seriously?
The one and only time I got fired from a job was because my boss thought I was too pushy, when I was actually way less pushy than the guys who did similar jobs. When asked to cite an example, he talked about how by answering a question I had cut so-and-so off at a specific meeting... that so-and-so wasn't even at. Oh, I was also told that because I was overweight, I needed to be quieter and more careful than other people, because I could be perceived as threatening because of my size, when someone smaller wouldn't be perceived that way. This was framed as something *I* needed to deal with, rather than a problem on the part of the asshole with perception problems.
I was stupid and embarrassed, and I should have sued their asses, but I didn't. (That last part was never put in writing and he denied saying it later when I brought it up with HR.)
I think far from paying less attention to the abortion issue, feminists need to start framing our efforts to make life more fully livable for mothers and better access to health care as an important abortion reduction strategy. I'm sure there are many women considering abortion who might be swayed to the side of keeping the baby if that didn't entail economic ruin, social stigma, and disastrous health consequences for both mother and child.
@pesematology: I don't get "reducing abortions" as an end in itself. Reducing unplanned pregnancies, sure - that's a good idea, I could get behind it. Making life more liveable for mothers (particularly working mothers), I can get behind that as well. These are both very admirable goals, and fewer abortions may be a side effect, but I don't think it has merit as a goal on its own.
You do have to recognize, no matter how attractive and "easy" you make it, raising a child is tough, and pregnancy is tough, and not everyone wants to do it, and not everyone, even with the best benefits evar, will "choose life." I mean, at this point in my life, I don't want a baby. i am using birth control, but birth control sometimes fails; this is a reality. And you could offer me one year of fully paid maternity leave and put in a fully-subsidized daycare center in my office - I'm still not having that baby. And I'll never apologize for having that opinion or making that decision, if FSM forbid I would have to.
@That_little_attention_whore: Yeah but you have to agree that a lot of people want to reduce the number of abortions and a lot of these same people don't seem to give two sh*ts about the actual issues involved with carrying, birthing, and raising a child. So it would make sense for these people and other, more mainstream feminists such as ourselves to meet in the middle by working together to make life not f*cking suck for everyone.
And while I'm not in any position to judge your personal choice, I can say that there are many people, myself included, who do actually want a baby, or are at least considering it for some point in their lives. People in this category are the "swing voters" so to speak, and might decide that even an accidental pregnancy might be worth carrying to term if it can be made viable for their lives, economically and health-wise.
I am absolutely not in favor of forcing any woman to bear a child she does not want to carry. I am also not in favor of allowing women to be in a situation where they feel they have to choose between their own lives and the life of a fetus. My solution to this would be health care, health education, and birth control for everyone, good adoption and foster care systems, paid maternity leave and child care, adequate schools, and, as a last resort, safe, legal, and non-judgemental abortion available to anyone in need of it.
My evidence is only anecdotal but so far my male bosses have understood the need for work-life balance at a far greater rate than my female bosses. I haven't had a female boss yet who thought any such balance was necessary. But yeah, that's just me and I'm sure they're not all like that.
I actually eventually left my last job because I was in a constant silent rage.
Why?
Because the guy who'd been hired the same day as me was promoted. Why? He'd asked for it.
I think the Washington Post guy kind of left out something important:
Men are socialized to demand things. Women are not. The work place is designed for how men socialize/relate to each other. It makes it far harder to advance, because for many women, they have to learn a new way of acting. For most men, it's far more easy to adjust, because that's more how they relate.
@sybann: "I am going to push the issue as hard as I can without jeopardizing my job."
I know nothing of your work environment, or your situation, but it might be possible that you keep getting turned down because they know you'll only push so far, and then they won't have to "deal with you" for awhile. Have you considered pushing the issue just a smidge over the line of job jeopardization?
@sybann: I think the better option is to start quietly sending out your resume. You might have to wait until the economy recovers more, but I think it is a huge mistake to stay with a company that won't promote you/increase your pay. The strongest place to ask for a salary increase is when you are getting hired but already have a job.
@clevernamehere: I agree. And that's exactly what I did when my company thought that I needed to "wait like everybody else" to get promoted even though I'd gone above & beyond & have been doing the higher position for 2 years. I started sending out resumes & got a great offer.
Here's my experience in the corporate world: sometimes people go in the boss's office and "ask for a raise/promotion" but it usually happens more casually. It comes up in conversation (as in, "I could see myself running that department after Joe leaves") at lunch or on a Starbucks run or over drinks on a business trip. Which with male bosses can happen mostly with male subordinates, because it can start office rumors when a male boss and female subordinate go out alone together. I've known a few men who make sure there are always multiple people around when they have dinner with a woman who works for them, for example. Just tossing out why that conversation might happen more conveniently with men than women. A woman often doesn't get as much of her boss's ear.
And ultimately - if you know men are more likely to ask and you then make asking a requirement, you've just knowingly swayed the promotion process in men's favor.
Ok, so we don't try to fight abortion restrictions. What happens if I lose my access to an abortion, and I'm forced to quit to care for a child that has severe birth defects? Or I'm forced to quit because my health jeopardized due to the pregnancy? Workplace reform will do fuck all for me in that case.
Not to say we don't need reforms, because YES it's sorely needed, but it makes me extra double dose stabby when it's argued that we can't focus our energies on more than one area at a time. My poor lady brain just can't handle multitasking...how patronizing.
@Jessika: AND it's bullshit. Women can multitask better than any man. Or the species would have died out by now because the toddlers would have all walked into the cooking fire while we banged our furs on rocks.
I have no work life balance. Seriously. The only time in my day that I get to myself is when I come and read Jezebel. It's gotten to the point this last week where there were days I literally forgot to go to the bathroom from eight in the morning until eight at night. On Friday last week, I didn't eat the whole day because I worked the entire day. Work/life balance is something that my department talks about but there is no support for people in my position to have that. When I talk about the need to delegate things to other people, the response I get is that I should be doing that, not others. I'm really frustrated right now with everything that's on me and I feel like I have no support or recourse to talk about how difficult it is for me to work through this.
@Jenloveshercurves: I'm not sure what line of work you're in but have you spoken with an HR person about it? I know it's always a delicate situation, taking things to HR, but you have said that it's been discussed to no avail. Just wondering.
@Jenloveshercurves: Yes, I second shorty's comment. Surely what you're doing is not legal and somehow your employer is violating wage and hour laws by not giving you breaks.
I'd start documenting, every 20 minutes, exactly what you do every day, every task. That gives you ammunition to go to your boss and tell him you can't physically keep up this pace and proof that you aren't just complaining, you are doing far too much work.
@shorty63136: I work in residence life for a university, so in essence I live where I work. This means that when there is an emergency, since I live here or just an obnoxious parent/student, they come literally to my house to have me deal with it. Also, since my job is about such strange hours yet I'm still expected to keep some semblance of regular office hours to deal with people in the main office who have 8am to 5pm jobs. So, there are times I'm working from 9am until midnight, actually, I like to call that time Tuesday. I'm not over-exaggerating. This is just my life. Also, my boss just said to me, "We don't have any other responsibilities like work or school or spouses so we can do the work that needs to be done here." I may not have those things, but my time is just as important. I don't think that I should have to sacrifice my physical and emotional well-being for my job, but this is the lesson that I'm learning.
@Jenloveshercurves: ah yes, the "single people's lives aren't worth anything" excuse. I've been there (pretty much the same hours, actually) and just ended up having to quit. But that was in the 1999 job market. *sigh*
The only advice I can give you is that sometimes it can help to start incrementally lowering expectations. If you think something will take you an hour, tell them it will be an hour and a half. Try not to get rattled by other people's "right now right now!", since a lot of people are just being silly panic monkeys anyway (or they need you right now because they let their own shit get behind). It will help you find little buffer zones of time, bit by bit, and then you can work on enlarging them and gaining control over your time. Maybe it's only 15 minutes here or there at first, but that's time to pee or have a sandwich (both if you're a brave multitasker!).
@kkatt: It's that old excuse about men asking for raises and promotions more often and being better negotiators. Even if that's true, which I doubt, it's bullshit.
Sometimes it's really, really hard to remember that your employer does not, in fact, own you. My husband falls into that box pretty easily, where "work wants..." becomes the priority he has to adhere to. Sometimes he's really surprised when I remind him, "you have the right to say 'no' sometimes."
My boss, on the other hand, is literally the company's champion for work / life balance (I work under HR right now) so I've got it easy for the time being. But at my last job, they seemed to be of the opinion since that I was the one without kids, I had no right to want to go home from work at 5...
@Etoiles: I hate the whole assumption that my childless time is less important than those with children's. Everyone makes decisions in life and must live with them, not get special breaks because of it. Like, oh hi, just because I don't have to rush out for Little Timmy's x activity/put dinner on the table, doesn't mean that I don't have other things that I'd rather be doing than covering for the people who have chosen to procreate. My cat needs me!
@Grim Reaper of the Forest: Sounds like there are probably a lot of people who work for him that could very possibly be better at ASKING for a better job than DOING a better job.
Way to take charge as a manager and choose your leaders for yourself.
@la_periodista: Word on both this and the comment you're responding to. Maybe I'm living in a dream world, but I've always been too busy working to brown nose and have still managed to get promoted (though always by women).
@Grim Reaper of the Forest: I wondered about that. In my life, I've asked for a raise twice. Once I got it, the other time I was denied it. I wonder if this guy only gave raises when asked, which is crappy. Giving someone a raise because you recognize their work makes them feel better. If they have to ask for one, they feel like you don't notice what they do or don't pay attention to them.
@Red-headed bookworm: I've never asked for a raise or a promotion, but fortunately have had very supportive managers who have given me both. I do think women need to do a better job of asking for promotion, raises, and higher starting salaries. But, a good manager shouldn't be responding to that alone.
@Grim Reaper of the Forest: My boss is like that. He's a nice guy, but I swear he doesn't notice anything if it's not in front of him and even then you have to remind him every five minutes. I was working 12-hour days for three months before I got up the nerve to ask for more money. He kind of looked at me like he was seeing me for the first time, and snapped to. "Oh yeah, you have been working pretty hard lately." And I got my bonus (not as good as a raise, but in this economy, I was surprised he had any money left for even that).
It helped that his boss had been hearing from my subordinates how many hours I was actually working. So it wasn't like my boss had to argue very hard for the extra money for me.
@all: reading these comments make me feel better about working in the public sector. sure, there is some inequality in my line of work, but it skewed more towards married/married with kids vs single people than it is by gender. but that's also an issue in the private sector, but manifests itself in different ways...
I am totally ready to sign up for a new feminist labor agenda for a post-industrial workplace. I just don't know where to find it, it's so hard to organize when everyone's workplace looks so different. Is it in the unions, in feminist groups? Where is the critical mass for this kind of reform?
@J.D.Regent: health care and all other sorts of social programs that no one every wants their tax dollars to go towards (head start). Not necessarily dealing with employment, just in general programs that help working women.
12/16/09
But I do think women need to think about promotions and wage increases more.
At my first post college job, the salary was set and unmovable but being fresh undergrads I don't think we knew that. Only one person out of the 12 people I knew tried to negotiate at all, and he was one of the three guys at my level.
I negotiated my way into that job my playing a job offer elsewhere off an interview, but it didn't occur to me to bargain. I've seen a lot of comments in the open threads where people don't even try for a raise or worse still, stay at a job that won't promote them without looking elsewhere. You can often get more money as a new employee.
I know that women are looked down on for this behavior, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't do it. Your co-workers and bosses don't actually have to like you. It is a risk, but asking for more isn't a bad idea.
12/16/09
I think men need to grow up if they can't handle women not dressing like dowdy school marms at the work place. What the hell difference should it make in how we dress as long as it's tasteful? Are there infinite articles for men on how they should tuck in their shirts and not where Spiderman ties to work if THEY want to be taken seriously?
12/15/09
I was stupid and embarrassed, and I should have sued their asses, but I didn't. (That last part was never put in writing and he denied saying it later when I brought it up with HR.)
12/15/09
12/16/09
You do have to recognize, no matter how attractive and "easy" you make it, raising a child is tough, and pregnancy is tough, and not everyone wants to do it, and not everyone, even with the best benefits evar, will "choose life." I mean, at this point in my life, I don't want a baby. i am using birth control, but birth control sometimes fails; this is a reality. And you could offer me one year of fully paid maternity leave and put in a fully-subsidized daycare center in my office - I'm still not having that baby. And I'll never apologize for having that opinion or making that decision, if FSM forbid I would have to.
12/17/09
And while I'm not in any position to judge your personal choice, I can say that there are many people, myself included, who do actually want a baby, or are at least considering it for some point in their lives. People in this category are the "swing voters" so to speak, and might decide that even an accidental pregnancy might be worth carrying to term if it can be made viable for their lives, economically and health-wise.
I am absolutely not in favor of forcing any woman to bear a child she does not want to carry. I am also not in favor of allowing women to be in a situation where they feel they have to choose between their own lives and the life of a fetus. My solution to this would be health care, health education, and birth control for everyone, good adoption and foster care systems, paid maternity leave and child care, adequate schools, and, as a last resort, safe, legal, and non-judgemental abortion available to anyone in need of it.
That's what my utopia looks like.
12/15/09
12/15/09
Why?
Because the guy who'd been hired the same day as me was promoted. Why? He'd asked for it.
I think the Washington Post guy kind of left out something important:
Men are socialized to demand things. Women are not. The work place is designed for how men socialize/relate to each other. It makes it far harder to advance, because for many women, they have to learn a new way of acting. For most men, it's far more easy to adjust, because that's more how they relate.
12/15/09
But women are punished for doing such that - they are considered stupid for doing that.
12/15/09
But guess who'll be doing the job anyway? For the fourth time for the same company.
I am going to push the issue as hard as I can without jeopardizing my job.
12/15/09
I know nothing of your work environment, or your situation, but it might be possible that you keep getting turned down because they know you'll only push so far, and then they won't have to "deal with you" for awhile. Have you considered pushing the issue just a smidge over the line of job jeopardization?
12/16/09
12/16/09
12/16/09
12/16/09
12/16/09
12/15/09
And ultimately - if you know men are more likely to ask and you then make asking a requirement, you've just knowingly swayed the promotion process in men's favor.
12/15/09
Not to say we don't need reforms, because YES it's sorely needed, but it makes me extra double dose stabby when it's argued that we can't focus our energies on more than one area at a time. My poor lady brain just can't handle multitasking...how patronizing.
12/15/09
12/15/09
12/15/09
12/15/09
I'd start documenting, every 20 minutes, exactly what you do every day, every task. That gives you ammunition to go to your boss and tell him you can't physically keep up this pace and proof that you aren't just complaining, you are doing far too much work.
12/15/09
12/15/09
The only advice I can give you is that sometimes it can help to start incrementally lowering expectations. If you think something will take you an hour, tell them it will be an hour and a half. Try not to get rattled by other people's "right now right now!", since a lot of people are just being silly panic monkeys anyway (or they need you right now because they let their own shit get behind). It will help you find little buffer zones of time, bit by bit, and then you can work on enlarging them and gaining control over your time. Maybe it's only 15 minutes here or there at first, but that's time to pee or have a sandwich (both if you're a brave multitasker!).
12/15/09
12/15/09
12/15/09
12/15/09
My boss, on the other hand, is literally the company's champion for work / life balance (I work under HR right now) so I've got it easy for the time being. But at my last job, they seemed to be of the opinion since that I was the one without kids, I had no right to want to go home from work at 5...
12/15/09
12/15/09
12/15/09
Way to take charge as a manager and choose your leaders for yourself.
12/15/09
12/15/09
12/15/09
12/15/09
It helped that his boss had been hearing from my subordinates how many hours I was actually working. So it wasn't like my boss had to argue very hard for the extra money for me.
12/16/09
12/15/09
12/15/09
eta: and frankly the trend is AWAY from workers rights, not towards them.
12/15/09
12/15/09