I have worked vigorously in the area of civil rights against arrestees. My personal slogan is that COPS LIE. Furthermore, our justice system is compromised.
Having said that, I'm still outraged that Polanski and his supporters feel that he can be excused from his crime.
The law is for everyone. It's not just for poor people, or brown people. It's for ex-President George Bush and for Dick Cheney. And it's for Roman Polanski.
The purpose of the law is to protect the innocent from those who are violent and predatory.
This is reason 1,000,000 I heart Jezebel. You are sensible and tenacious enough to be on the correct side of this issue and not afraid to write about it!
He drugged and sodomized a 13-year-old girl. He skipped the country to avoid prison time. Chinatown is one of my favorite movies, but Polanski gets NO sympathy from me. Yes, I know he experienced heart-breaking and horrible things when he was a boy, and for that, he has my compassion, but that does not give someone the right to rape a child.
It boggles my mind that the New York Times even allowed this story to appear in it's "Room for Debate" section, even though all but one person in the "debate" came down on the correct side of this issue. This was followed the next day by an opinion piece defending Polanksi. Why? Do they not have the integrity to live up to their own liberal ideals and standards? I know that those defending Polanksi are in the minority, but...wow...what a minority. Apparently a minority powerful enough to cause us to call into question the integrity and trustworthiness of the New York Times.
Can I just say how ridiculous I find that no one vocally came to the defense of Michael Jackson, a man who was ACQUITTED, yet the celebrities are coming out in droves to support a self-confessed rapist? Careful Hollywood, your white privilege is showing.
I just fucking don't get it. Regardless of what he did (which in my opinion is abhorrent) he EVADED THE LAW for thirty years. He had his chance with the legal system. He ran away. He doesn't get a free pass. This makes me nuts. I'm about as leftist as it gets and I just don't understand this.
I'm sure he's a decent person now and probably realizes it was horrible and whatnot and will forever have my pity over his childhood and the horrible Manson murders but he still EVADED THE LAW FOR THIRTY YEARS. I don't understand what part of this his supporters don't get. Making Chinatown does not give you a free pass on some pretty damn serious crimes.
Chris rock and Jay Leno are two major stars who have spoken out. I love the fact Chris Rock points out that in all of his years of touring "I ain't never seen a fine 13 year old girl!"
@KATE!: Oh thank goodness, I shouldn't have worried that John Stewart wouldn't support him I guess but as evidenced... it's shocking who is willing to publicly support him when so many celebrities claim to be so liberal.
@trikota: Because he fled to France 30 years ago and they refused to extradite him. He went to the Zurich for the film festival there a couple of days ago and when he entered Switzerland the Swiss decided to extradite him.
I don't think we should burn his films, cause hey, it's out, but I would never watch them.
It's one thing to keep loving them if you have already watched them, but if you haven't yet, why would you chose to watch the film of a known rapist, when there are so many, many, wonder filmmakers bout there who aren't rapists?
@JohnAgamemnon: Because Chinatown is one of the great films of all time, with one of the finest screenplays ever written. How is it fair to Robert Towne and everybody else who worked on it to write it out of history?
@JohnAgamemnon: Here's the thing. Separate. I think OJ Simpson is a wife beater and murderer and I suspect DEEPLY that Robert Wagner had something to do with Natalie Wood's death and Steve McQueen was a quite infamous misogynist but none of those things are gonna make me hate Towering Inferno.
I think there comes a point where you can recognize the artist separately from the art. I think Polanski needs to spend the rest of his natural life (which isn't much longer I suspect) in jail for his crime and evading it for so long. But his movies are good and worth watching. The Pianist from a few years ago was a very powerful film. Don't deprive yourself of good art because of the artist.
@sallysitwell: Between that and Good Hair, he is setting the bar pretty damn high for my other comedian crushes. David Cross had better be setting up an orphanage.
I'm a working screenwriter for TV and film, though nowhere near the level of the luminaries that have spoken out in defense of Polanski, and literally everyone I know in Hollywood is horrified by the guy and the apologias being written for him by our more famous colleagues. I first saw Harding's initial Salon piece on the facebook feed of a very successful screenwriter, and many others have echoed those sentiments. So please don't think that all of Hollywood approves of Polanski or excuses his crimes.
Seriously. I love Polanski's films and I don't think Hollywood has to now claim he is anything less than an artist. He doesn't have to give back the Oscar. But that doesn't make what he did ok.
And its not just about rape. If Meryl Streep raped someone in France and then fled to America to escape sentencing the world would be up in arms. It wouldn't matter that she is highly regarded. It would be seen as an example of American arrogance. An example of Americans thinking other countries laws don't apply to them.
I am not saying the American justice system deserves high praise. It is flawed in general and in this specific instance. But that could be said of any country. And if Americans trampled all over the laws of France without paying for it no one would think its ok.
He ran and he got caught. Its fine I am sure his past has given him a keen instinct for survival. But actions have consequences.
10/02/09
Having said that, I'm still outraged that Polanski and his supporters feel that he can be excused from his crime.
The law is for everyone. It's not just for poor people, or brown people. It's for ex-President George Bush and for Dick Cheney. And it's for Roman Polanski.
The purpose of the law is to protect the innocent from those who are violent and predatory.
10/02/09
10/02/09
10/02/09
10/02/09
10/02/09
10/02/09
I'm sure he's a decent person now and probably realizes it was horrible and whatnot and will forever have my pity over his childhood and the horrible Manson murders but he still EVADED THE LAW FOR THIRTY YEARS. I don't understand what part of this his supporters don't get. Making Chinatown does not give you a free pass on some pretty damn serious crimes.
10/01/09
10/01/09
10/02/09
10/02/09
10/01/09
10/02/09
10/01/09
It's one thing to keep loving them if you have already watched them, but if you haven't yet, why would you chose to watch the film of a known rapist, when there are so many, many, wonder filmmakers bout there who aren't rapists?
10/01/09
10/02/09
I think there comes a point where you can recognize the artist separately from the art. I think Polanski needs to spend the rest of his natural life (which isn't much longer I suspect) in jail for his crime and evading it for so long. But his movies are good and worth watching. The Pianist from a few years ago was a very powerful film. Don't deprive yourself of good art because of the artist.
10/01/09
He's pretty damn awesome. Chris Rock, I mean.
10/01/09
10/01/09
10/02/09
10/01/09
10/01/09
And its not just about rape. If Meryl Streep raped someone in France and then fled to America to escape sentencing the world would be up in arms. It wouldn't matter that she is highly regarded. It would be seen as an example of American arrogance. An example of Americans thinking other countries laws don't apply to them.
I am not saying the American justice system deserves high praise. It is flawed in general and in this specific instance. But that could be said of any country. And if Americans trampled all over the laws of France without paying for it no one would think its ok.
He ran and he got caught. Its fine I am sure his past has given him a keen instinct for survival. But actions have consequences.