haroldandmaude - Jezebel

posts about #haroldandmaude more →
Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?
Chemistry Lessons

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

cirocco
07/13/09

In reply to Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?
"Why can't we instead realize that the same rigidity of roles that we deplore could hurt not just women, but men, and find that not a source of satisfaction, but of sorrow?"

Because I can only feel so much sorrow on any given day, and I prefer to reserve it for parties who were involuntarily disenfranchised in their own homes, not expend it on men who never learned to cook because they sneeringly dismissed it as "women's work." It's not like men feel sympathy for women who lack traditional "male" skills such as automotive repair. Men will loudly tell us we're blithering idiots if we don't know how to change a tire.
Reply

cirocco was starred cirocco was unstarred

rednrowdy
07/13/09

In reply to Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?
wouldn't it stand to reason that the quality and length of the marriage prior to the spouse dying would play a factor in this, too? what about spouses who become fulltime caregivers prior to widow/widower status? many folks far younger than the AARP age stay in bad marriages or loveless marriages for many reasons. i can see someone stuck in a bad marriage would feel free once their spouse dies. on the flipside, if someone has been married happily for more than 45 years and their spouse dies, you don't just jump back in the saddle the next day, especially if you have been the primary caregiver for that spouse prior to their death.
Reply

rednrowdy was starred rednrowdy was unstarred

Eric Northman is mine
07/13/09

In reply to Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?
In terms of widows/widowers. Have you noticed in older couples that men tend pass away after their wives have passed but women tend to live on for a lot longer after their spouses’ death. Of course this is based on anecdotal evidence but my grandfather passed away 1 year after my grandmother passed away and I noticed a similar trend with my friend's grandparents. Something about men being more dependent on women for care/companionship and women being better able to fend for themselves allows women to continue to live on and adapt but men feel like they can’t go on or completely lost without their spouse.
Reply

Fridge Hussy : Is finally heading back to uni!
07/13/09

In reply to Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?
I know a bit about the decline in diet if a husband loses his wife. My father can prepare meals, but if my mum goes away for even a few days, my dad only eats baked beans, bread, sardines and onions. Usually at the same time!
Reply

Edited by Fridge Hussy : Is finally heading back to uni! at 07/13/09 4:05 PM

AmericanSplendor
07/13/09

@Fridge Hussy : Is finally heading back to uni!:

My dad's the one that cooks, and so my mom subsists on Trader Joe's tabouli and digiorno pizza. That's of course that's the one night a week she'll eat at home if my dad's gone, because when he leaves I can set my watch by the fact my mom will call by 6 and pick me up to go to dinner.
Reply

AmericanSplendor was starred AmericanSplendor was unstarred

doodley is not amused
07/13/09

@Fridge Hussy : Is finally heading back to uni!: We seriously question that my father knows how to find the grocery store. Actually, the one closest to my parents' house recently closed for remodeling, and I suspect that my dad could not easily find an alternate if pressed to do so.
Reply

andBegorrah
07/13/09

In reply to Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?
The solution is clearly to let elderly single ladies use their "independence" to entertain lonely gentlemen callers, and if, in their aged wisdom, they decide that the poor dears would be better off in a nice quiet grave in the cellar, then it's their prerogative to add one teaspoon full of arsenic, a half a teaspoon full of strychnine, and just a pinch of cyanide to the elderberry wine.
Reply

andBegorrah was starred andBegorrah was unstarred

Sputnik_Sweetheart
07/13/09

@andBegorrah: Yes, but how does Teddy Roosevelt and Boris Karloff fit in?
Reply

Sputnik_Sweetheart was starred

doodley is not amused
07/13/09

@andBegorrah: If you put it in tea, it has a distinct odor, you know.
Reply

mbot says Spock yeah!
07/13/09

@andBegorrah: These older ladies will be examples of a new type of woman, henceforth known as saber-tooth tigers.
Reply

Edited by mbot says Spock yeah! at 07/13/09 4:23 PM

NerD: Blattella
07/13/09

In reply to Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?
My grandfather on my father's side died at 83. My grandma immediately became very independent, living another 15 and dying at 97.

One thing that made that work was that essentially after living together for 60+ years they were roommates. They loved each other, but both led separate lives. They both managed to live well together, but his death didn't limit her options in life, and I am sure being with her prolonged his.

My other grandfather, who was a cranky old single son of a bitch, divorced young, died early, and nobody missed him much when he left.

There is no moral here.
Reply

NerD: Blattella was starred NerD: Blattella was unstarred

TheFormerJuneBronson
07/13/09

@NerD!!! - R.O.A.C.H.: My maternal grandparents went the same way. My grandfather, a chronic alcoholic, made it to 78 before he died. That was twelve years ago, and though my grandmother missed him, she is still going strong at 88, living on her own, with a big circle of friends and family. I want to be just like her when I'm old.
Reply

AmericanSplendor
07/13/09

In reply to Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?
My mother came very close to being a widow last year, but the pops perservered (thank you thank you, thank you Jesus). Believe me, my mother would have been able to cook for herself and clean, but she knows NOTHING about personal finance, except what my dad explains to her. She would have been SOL when it came to retirement.

Is this true for others? I know that many woman handle home finances, but aren't long term investments usually the domain of men? What do widows do in the long run when they have to keep their funds alive during retirement? I think this could be one (of many) reasons you see that an unfair portion of elderly women are dependent almost solely on social security, because they don't know enough about investing to keep their private funds going. There's probably a lot going into that issue, but that seems reasonable to think it could be part of it.

So, in the end, gender roles hurt everyone, at every age. No poetic justice about that.
Reply

AmericanSplendor was starred AmericanSplendor was unstarred

Penny
07/13/09

@AmericanSplendor: In the case of my parents, my mom handles the money (because my dad can't be trusted....like me), but my boyfriend's parents are the opposite. His father does all the finances and his mom simply passes all receipts to him. But, he's retired, so he has more time.

I really do think this is more generational, as I said below. I don't see this being a huge issue with couples my age in 50 years.
Reply

Penny was starred Penny was unstarred

AmericanSplendor
07/13/09

@Penny:

I sure hope so. I can barely handle my own finances, and I've spent entire semesters on retirement planning and social security. If I have to plan two people's retirements, I'll probably burst into flames from frustration. I need to find me an hombre who will share all duties fairly, because I ain't organizing his IRA, that's for f''ing sure.
Reply

AmericanSplendor was starred AmericanSplendor was unstarred

Flackette Goes Retro
07/13/09

@AmericanSplendor: My dad had a health scare last month, and it threw into sharp relief for me how much my mom's financial situation would change without him. While he receives a pension, if something were to happen to him she would receive only half of that pension as his survivor. She is not old enough for Social Security, and what she's eligible for is as a spouse, not a worker herself. And they are in the midst of trying to sell either one or both houses. She is very organized, but he has been the one to keep most of the finances, and his files are not in very good order at all (more like stacks of paper on a desk). She is educated, with a graduate degree, but they fell into very traditional gender roles when we were little kids and just never really stopped.

Because of all this, my mom realizes her own financial vulnerability, and has been on me nonstop for some years to invest for myself. She nagged me until I started a retirement account at 25, and now at 29 she is my cheerleader as I buy a house in my own name, with no cosigner. She says she is so very proud of me just for being a self-sufficient woman who pays all her own bills and manages her own money. And heck, I'm kind of proud of me too. I just don't want to find myself in my late 50s realizing I don't have any assets for retirement in my own name.
Reply

AmericanSplendor
07/13/09

@Flackette Goes Retro:

Haha, that's so true. Honestly, saving for retirement is the greatest gift you can give yourself, because we're all reluctant to do it until it's too late. I plan on starting a retirement account as soon as I get a real (read: first out of college) job. My parents are wonderful people, but they told me that saving for their retirement is important to them, and that if I went to a fancy school, I would have to pay some of it, because you can take out loans for school, but you can't take loans out for retirement.
Reply

AmericanSplendor was starred AmericanSplendor was unstarred

thegogglesdonothing
07/13/09

In reply to Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?
Fun fact: the reason that older adults have the highest suicide rate of any age group is nearly entirely due to increases in suicide among males. Older females are not at a substantially higher risk for suicide than females of other age groups. I'm sure that the gap in domestic self-sufficiency in past generations and the 'widower effect' are a big part of this.
Reply

PilgrimSoul
07/13/09

In reply to Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?
Why can't we instead realize that the same rigidity of roles that we deplore could hurt not just women, but men, and find that not a source of satisfaction, but of sorrow?

Because, in short, we have a hard enough time getting people to recognize that the rigidity of these roles DOES hurt women that we lack time or resources to move on to men.

I'm not sure I think that's so bad.
Reply

PilgrimSoul was starred PilgrimSoul was unstarred

andBegorrah
07/13/09

@PilgrimSoul: I find it somewhat easier to explain the how and why of those roles' rigidity and pervasive coerciveness by pointing out "The way this hurts me is also hurting you in distinct but inherently connected ways." Sure, it's appealing to the other person's innate selfishness as a way of eliciting empathy, and I'm not trying to play pity poker on who the patriarchy hurts more, but it's an intervention that's inclusive. Group hug!!
Reply

andBegorrah was starred andBegorrah was unstarred

TheFormerJuneBronson
07/13/09

In reply to Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?
I agree that the problem with this paradigm is the desire to generalize. Nobody knows how they'll handle the death of their spouse; it's one of those things that you can't quite understand until you're there and see who you've become and when it happens and what your needs and desires for the future will be.

Besides that, though, the idea of losing my spouse, aside from the grief of losing him, makes me worry about being untethered in a bad way. I'm not the world's most social person, so I don't envision this social life they describe. I think I'd be alone a lot. One of the things I like best about being married is being able to have a family life that is less subject to the vagaries of friendship. But I really don't know.

I think Mr. JB would move back in with his parents immediately if I died. He hated dating.
Reply

cocobanal
07/13/09

In reply to Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?
Nice post. The whole idea of getting older and being lonely is something I've been thinking about a lot lately. I am lonely and I know other people who are. The thing is, with all the people in the world, why are we having so much trouble getting together? Why are there so many lonely people? I could write more and pontificate on this subject because I have been married twice and have experience both with being married for long periods and being single for long periods, but ultimately the fact that people are lonely and isolated and grasping for connections just makes me sad, and that's all.
Reply

cocobanal was starred cocobanal was unstarred

TheFormerJuneBronson
07/13/09

@cocobanal: I've noticed as I get older that people have a strong tendency to close ranks, make fewer new friends, rely more heavily on their families, and become more hostile to strangers. I've basically given up on finding a new local bestie; nobody's interested. Maybe as my son gets older, I'll meet people through his school or something. I don't know what it is. I hate to blame it on something vague like the pace of modern life, but I suspect that has something to do with it. Nobody is home, everybody is tired, everybody has non-people-centered means of entertainment. Whatever forced people to entertain each other over their newfangled toasters during the Depression is gone now.
Reply

PilgrimSoul
07/13/09

@TheFormerJuneBronson: I don't know. This is something I think about a lot too, as I think I might be too independent to ever marry anyone, and certainly too much so to bear any children, but I've managed. In the face of not having a very functional immediate family, even, I've managed.

I think that what I've learned is that I have to be a bit of a pest about maintaining non-familial personal relationships, because nothing is taken for granted in them, but it's been completely worth it to build this network. And I don't think it's been made more difficult by technology; I think it's been made easier.
Reply

PilgrimSoul was starred PilgrimSoul was unstarred

elliebean
07/13/09

In reply to Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?
I think this article (the Jezebel one) makes an excellent point. Traditional gender roles, as we age, may sort of have the effect of crippling one's ability to be an adult alone, since these roles exclude a certain skill set in a lot of cases. Men might never have had to deal with domestic chores, or women with financial records (as an example). When I think about my parents as they age, regardless of their gender, I want them to have a sense of independence, self-sufficiency, and a social support network already in place to help create that resilience that the widows described in the article seem to have.
Reply

elliebean was starred elliebean was unstarred

Sadie
07/13/09

@elliebean: The financial corollary is a very good one, I think - I know some older ladies who'd been told never to worry their heads about it - and then had to...
Reply

Sadie was starred Sadie was unstarred

Penny
07/13/09

In reply to Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?
My love for Harold & Maude knows no bounds.

I think this is a generational thing. When I think about the people in my life who are my parents age and older, I can see the married women dealing better on their own than the married men. I mean, my mom was away last week and my dad survived on canned soup and Hostess Snowballs.

Reply

Penny was starred Penny was unstarred

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#haroldandmaude

Jezebel

SUBSCRIBE TO Jezebel

Merry Widows, Sad Guys: Do Women Finally Have It Better?

Chemistry Lessons

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment