There weren't many black families in the town I grew up in. In fact we were one of the few minorities there. I made my first black friend in middle school. During one of our history classes I watched her redo her pony tails and asked her about her hair. I don't remember her exact response but since then I've always known it's a sensitive issue and I have no business playing 20 questions or touching any black persons hair.
I don't bullshit about how pretty their hair is. I don't complain about my hair.
As a minority I've had a wealth of experiences outside the norm, something other people just can't understand. And I've been on the other end where it's another's experience I can't relate to. I simply don't have the context to fully GET the issue, it's not mine. It's an uncomfortable realization to be had but very freeing once you get it.
Hey, just wanted to say this is a much needed comment. I'm a black woman with a weave who fully understands the "good hair/bad hair" issue, but I also have several Asian friends. I feel like many people don't even know it's possible for Asian women to have curly hair because so many of those who do feel compelled to straighten it to fit the mold of a "typical" Asian woman.
It just seems that no matter what, women are going to always have something about themselves that they don't like and would prefer to change. I have very curly hair and although I like it the majority of the time, I wasn't too thrilled when my pet canary, who had be sitting on my shoulder, got tangled up and stuck in my hair! When I pulled him out, he took a quite a few hairs with him. I could press it but I think I'll just get a hair cut instead. I still like it curly.
@taffy: I have the exact same thing going on, curly hair that traps birds as it gets longer. I see the problem as less the curly hair and more the enthusiasm of my avian friends though. They do love to walk around in my hair and preen it.
Can I just say that I have never, ever felt compelled to touch someone else's hair, no matter what it looked like? What is it with people thinking they can do that? I really don't understand. It's like touching a pregnant woman's belly - who do you think you are?!
@IngramDaboot: I know! I'm always so surprised when these stories come up and people talk about strangers touching their hair. I would be INTENSELY freaked out if a stranger touched my HEAD.
@greengrey: It only happened to me once, this dude reached up and was stroking my hair through a BUS WINDOW (I was on the bus, he was on the sidewalk next to it). It did in fact intensely freak me out.
@IngramDaboot: I possess the Hair of Privilege. The Marsha Brady type-stuff. It's been grabbed at a lot, especially when I was younger and it was closer to blond. The motivations and connotations around touching my hair are obviously quite different from the act of touching a black woman's hair. It's like being everyone's favorite Barbie doll, which is a weird combo of white privilege and dehumanization.
I'm a little tired of how the hair debate has been neatly packaged as a black women issue. Perhaps the issue is most obvious with black women, but that's not to say it's not prevalent across a wide variety of races.
As an Asian woman (full-blooded) with coarse/wavy hair, I've agonized over my hair for my entire life and know many others who have as well. Like the woman in the article, I grew up hearing my parents tell me that my sister was more beautiful than me because she had "pretty hair." There is a stereotype of Asian women having silky straight glossy tresses, so there is incredible pressure on Asian women who aren't blessed with that hair to somehow force their hair into conforming with everyone else. I'm sure many people have heard of Japanese and Brazilian hair straightening. I've spent 8 hours in a salon chair at a time, having chemicals burning into my scalp and my skin scalded over and over again, and all this to avoid people looking at me and saying "you're not a REAL Asian. I thought Asian women had beautiful hair." Or suffering through "nappy hair" comments or "frizzy hair" comments.
The hair discussion may be tired, but it's also too narrowly focused. There is much more to it than black women and weaves, and maybe the debate wouldn't be so tired if people began to take a more comprehensive look at it beyond what Tyra and Oprah can immediately relate to.
@Wassadamo: Yes, and let's extend this to Jewish women too. I often straighten my hair (and I hate my nose), but I wonder whether I'm hating myself for those characteristically Jewish features. I'm not sure that America still believes in a Sweet Valley Twins standard of beauty, but if I were to be cast in a movie, I would most certainly be a spunky sidekick.
@jatie: I have the Jewish version of "good hair" - naturally blonde, wavy not curly, and sleek. I grew up having my hair pulled and examined by my "friends" at Sunday School who then concluded that I couldn't really be Jewish because I didn't have Jewish hair.
I agree with everything said: This may be a most-visible issue for black women, but it extends to all women who aren't white, blonde and buxom.
And as for my nose... yeah, I'm right there with you. It's taken me 24 years to accept it, and I still haven't gotten around to liking it.
The story from the hairdresser is good to read because even if you have "good hair" that doesn't mean no one will take issue with it. I'm mostly black and I have long, loopy curly hair and I used to always go to the bathroom to brush my hair after lunch, just to keep flyaways under control, etc. One day, two of my fellow classmates walked in and said "Oh she think she too good for us with that hair." The other one responded with "Yeah she wouldn't think she was so pretty if someone just chopped it all off."
@quatrevingtquatre: Ditto on the mixed hair...in middle school packs of nasty, nappy little heifers would run up behind me and yank it really hard and accuse me of wearing a weave.
One of the reasons I am such a committed fan of millinery, is that I am yet to have a bad hat day. Occasionally I get the odd rude remark but generally I receive nothing but compliments. The fact that I can hide most of my hair under the crown of a hat is part of the charm and means I don’t have to worry what my hair looks like. Consequently, wearing a hat makes me feel confident and it is a damn sight less time consuming than having to iron/blow dry/set my hair every day.
@squeakel: @xgurl3eb: I used to get my hats from milliners but it was often hard to get a hat that fitted as I have a large head. Nowadays, my love affair with hats has gone to a completely new level thanks to vintage fairs and ebay. My favourites include a 1940s" K Howard Hodge from New York" and a "Craig’s of Houston" 1950s hat "as styled by Janet". The pride of my collection is a 1910 "Club woman" veiled hat. Most of my hats have cost less than twenty US dollars and therefore represent tremendous value.
One place I worked at brought in a dress code and banned hats,which I couldn’t help thinking was aimed at me as I wore hats TO work but took them off during business hours.
I'm glad they included that story from the hairstylist with naturally straight hair. As is often the case in life, even if you've got something supposedly good, especially when you've got something supposedly good, you're no better for it if it makes you a target. Whether it's 'good' hair, a 'perfect' body or the 'right' complexion, envy isn't that far from hatred.
Kind of reminds me of the thread on hating attractive women. Maybe they have privilege they're oblivious to – getting jobs early on in life, getting served at a bar r restaurant, having people smile at them on the street – but what's the us if it's outweighed by the cruel actions and words of people who assume they've got everything handed to them on a golden platter?
@HeatherNumber1: Where is this thread? and YES. I am often screaming for help and lonely as hell because everyone asumes I've got it together. Or that there is always somebody else somewhere else giving me whatever I need. Sorry to be off topic but I never see anyone talking about this and got excited.
When I was a teenager, I went to one of those generic mall front beauty salons to get my haircut.
One time, there was a black woman there who was getting her hair put into one of those updos (my experience with having black friends in high school tells me it was going to last her about a week). She was there before me and whatever chemical processes were going to take place had already happened, but since she was the only other person in there and my stylist wasn't talking to me, I spent the entire time just watching and listening to their conversation. I don't remember the conversation, but I do remember watching her hair being straightened by the hot irons and pinned into place. In hindsight, it was kind of rude for me to do (although I tend to eavesdrop anyway when I'm in the chair), but it had honestly never occurred to me that black girls had to do anything so difficult every week or that their routines were that different than mine.
@MizJenkins: I need to get a t-shirt bearing that magical star and logo. It's a great way to sign off on a conversation. I'd have to do a big arm wave, though, for the full effect.
I imagine one of the toughest parts of motherhood is consciously checking your own insecurity in order to provide a safe place for your daughter. Liz Nolan is amazing.
I'm interested in the difference between implicit and explicit modeling of attitudes and behavior in parenting. If your family tells you your hair is kinky or not as pretty as your cousins', you internalize it, but if your mom tells you your hair is gorgeous just as it is, but is constantly berating her own (that looks like yours!), the message is pretty confusing.
I think it's particularly relevant for minorities; you have less choice in the images you consume, so maybe the family role is even greater.
@funzette: YES. I thought of this in relation to Chris Rock's daughter who sparked the movie and the revitalization of the discussion.
I heard Malaak Compton-Rock (wife of Chris and mother of Zahra) bemoaning her daughter's insecurity and the atrocities society and media have caused in terms of Zahra's self esteem - all while wearing a long, straight weave.
The description of having hair straightened and jam lids placed over the hair to protect the hair, reminded me of the fact that when I went to a hairdressing salon as a child to have a shampoo and set, my ears would always be protected from the fierce heat of the hairdryer by pink plastic shells. I have never ever come across them as an adult so now I end up with overheated ears which, in terms of my ear lobes at least, is just so ageing.
Sadly, the people who made me self-conscious of my hair (growing up) were not friends/acquaintances/strangers; they were my family members. As for "good/bad hair," I was mocked by those who have hair like I do (cousins) and those who don't (my mom and sister). My mom is still hung up on the "good hair" thing -- I mean, she uses that term without the quotes!
@ClementinedeWinter: And I think that the funniest thing about my situation is that I don't like it when my hair is bone straight --- I prefer it the next day, when it's wavier. Go figure!
@ClementinedeWinter: Seriously, someone should write an essay collection about Moms and their daughters hair. I'd contribute, but I'd never hear the end of it.
Kind of like how I never hear the end of how I need to DO SOMETHING about my "terrible" hair now.
@Ratinski: Yes. My mom who has always been loving and supportive in every other way, used to tell me all the time that I looked like "a drowned rat" when I wore my hair pulled back and forced me several times to get my hair permed when I was 10-12. I know it is a different situation than the whole "good hair" debate, but mothers definitely project their own hair insecurities onto their daughters and perpetuate the cycle.
@ClementinedeWinter: "Sadly, the people who made me self-conscious of my hair (growing up) were not friends/acquaintances/strangers; they were my family members."
I read somewhere that of course family members will be the most adept at pushing our buttons -- they're the ones that installed them in the first place.
I have a vivid memory of a great-aunt who said "Look how pretty" and then pulled on my hair so hard my scalp hurt. For, like, half an hour.
@Ratinski: I have the "worst" hair on my mom's side of the family, and my mom is always making "suggestions" about different hairstyles, as many times as I've told her I want minimal futzing if for no other reasons than I work long hours and also work out a lot.
I finally turned to her one day and said "If you wanted me to have a different hair texture, you should have picked different genes for my other parent."
Her comments haven't stopped completely, but they have been ... abridged a fair amount.
LaToya: I really enjoy your writing and thank you for this though provoking entry. I hear you and agree with your points regarding some of this article's points and especially how it's a rehash of the same ole same ole "Black Women: Grab Your Cats and Your Vibrators" article.
BUT, is the article WRONG? I agree that some of the points are intended to whip people into hysteria, but black women *do* seem to have a harder time getting married than our non-white counterparts. What's the marriage rate for us right now? 30%? That's awful low and it's not for lack of wanting to get married either.
I'm a black woman in my early 30s. Just thinking about my friends/acquaintances/coworkers: the Black women are mostly single; the White & Asian women are mostly married. (I know this is anecdotal evidence, at best. I am not leaving out Latina sisters here, just don't know a lot of them.)
This statement: "African-American females, even with lots of education, do not fetch as much "value" in the marriage market" is incendiary but again, I'm not sure if it's "wrong" per se. We do seem to be the most de-valued by society (for a number of reasons).
I know I should not read these articles because honestly they just piss me off. But I think the reason they piss me off so much is both for the reasons you identify and the sad nugget of truth they contain.
Really, every American woman should just look into outsourcing for a fine European man - you thought you knew suave, I guarantee you, you don't. ;o)
Ok, in all seriousness, I do feel pressure to date within my race. Do I yield and date black men exclusively? hell no, because one 1) i'm fairly lucky in that my family happens to not care enough to ridicule/disown me, etc for "outdating" and 2) screw people that don't like the people I date - I don't like them anyway.....nanny nanny poo poo
Granted, the article is a bit simplistic and it would behoove us to examine the more significant nuances of this issue:
Why is there more pressure on Black women to date within the race than on men?
Who are these men marrying and what are the relationship dynamics they're seeking and not finding within their own communties?
That said, there are plenty of people who aren't engaged in this dialogue on any level. It is a crisis and it might be necessary to shock the conscience.
@MizJenkins: See, I don't think they said "date" I think they're going purely by marriage, which doesn't take into account long term relationships that don't result in marriage.
But I think the pressure comes from people who are incredulous to the idea that black woman are in fact viewed as attractive by men that aren't black whereas with white women the assumption is that her beauty is desired by everyone. So if the black woman were to date or marry outside her race, it disproves that assumption, which people aren't comfortable with having to have to change a longstanding view. Also, I think the pressure comes from the cultural assumptions that black women, being so strong and willful, need an equally strong or moreso partner which could only be a black man as they are viewed as hypermasculine enough to tame the shrew that is the American Black Woman.
It's funny cause it seems like there is nice population of professional black adults of both sexes who I am going to assume are straight but they both just assume that the other isn't out there. So black males are probably using the same excuse for dating outside their race that some black women are: "There aren't any (blank)."
So black males are probably using the same excuse for dating outside their race that some black women are: "There aren't any (blank)."
Naw homie...with the exception of Black men who haven't ever spent a lot of time in or exposed to the Black community, successful Black men know where to find their female counterparts. They're outnumbered by us about 70% to 30% the whole way up the ladder.
10/05/09
I don't bullshit about how pretty their hair is. I don't complain about my hair.
As a minority I've had a wealth of experiences outside the norm, something other people just can't understand. And I've been on the other end where it's another's experience I can't relate to. I simply don't have the context to fully GET the issue, it's not mine. It's an uncomfortable realization to be had but very freeing once you get it.
10/05/09
10/05/09
10/05/09
10/05/09
10/05/09
10/05/09
10/05/09
10/05/09
10/05/09
10/05/09
As an Asian woman (full-blooded) with coarse/wavy hair, I've agonized over my hair for my entire life and know many others who have as well. Like the woman in the article, I grew up hearing my parents tell me that my sister was more beautiful than me because she had "pretty hair." There is a stereotype of Asian women having silky straight glossy tresses, so there is incredible pressure on Asian women who aren't blessed with that hair to somehow force their hair into conforming with everyone else. I'm sure many people have heard of Japanese and Brazilian hair straightening. I've spent 8 hours in a salon chair at a time, having chemicals burning into my scalp and my skin scalded over and over again, and all this to avoid people looking at me and saying "you're not a REAL Asian. I thought Asian women had beautiful hair." Or suffering through "nappy hair" comments or "frizzy hair" comments.
The hair discussion may be tired, but it's also too narrowly focused. There is much more to it than black women and weaves, and maybe the debate wouldn't be so tired if people began to take a more comprehensive look at it beyond what Tyra and Oprah can immediately relate to.
10/05/09
10/05/09
I agree with everything said: This may be a most-visible issue for black women, but it extends to all women who aren't white, blonde and buxom.
And as for my nose... yeah, I'm right there with you. It's taken me 24 years to accept it, and I still haven't gotten around to liking it.
10/05/09
Never brushed my hair in the bathroom again.
10/05/09
10/05/09
Kind of gives new weight to the phrase "veiled threat."
Like, say, a thousand pounds worth.
10/05/09
That's, um, an ... interesting ... description, especially in the context of this discussion.
(Please don't think I'm disputing your claim that their behavior was evil.)
10/05/09
If the comb breaks...or something like that.
10/05/09
10/05/09
Smart. What kind of hat do you wear? Are you able to wear it at work?
I love hats, but finding one that fits and looks good on my big head is quite a task.
10/05/09
also, i have the opposite problem, i have a teeny tiny head. I buy winter hats in the childrens dept, they're the only ones that fit
10/05/09
One place I worked at brought in a dress code and banned hats,which I couldn’t help thinking was aimed at me as I wore hats TO work but took them off during business hours.
10/05/09
Kind of reminds me of the thread on hating attractive women. Maybe they have privilege they're oblivious to – getting jobs early on in life, getting served at a bar r restaurant, having people smile at them on the street – but what's the us if it's outweighed by the cruel actions and words of people who assume they've got everything handed to them on a golden platter?
10/05/09
10/05/09
[jezebel.com]
10/05/09
One time, there was a black woman there who was getting her hair put into one of those updos (my experience with having black friends in high school tells me it was going to last her about a week). She was there before me and whatever chemical processes were going to take place had already happened, but since she was the only other person in there and my stylist wasn't talking to me, I spent the entire time just watching and listening to their conversation. I don't remember the conversation, but I do remember watching her hair being straightened by the hot irons and pinned into place. In hindsight, it was kind of rude for me to do (although I tend to eavesdrop anyway when I'm in the chair), but it had honestly never occurred to me that black girls had to do anything so difficult every week or that their routines were that different than mine.
Of course, now I know.
10/05/09
@Zombie Ms. Skittles:
10/05/09
10/05/09
I'm interested in the difference between implicit and explicit modeling of attitudes and behavior in parenting. If your family tells you your hair is kinky or not as pretty as your cousins', you internalize it, but if your mom tells you your hair is gorgeous just as it is, but is constantly berating her own (that looks like yours!), the message is pretty confusing.
I think it's particularly relevant for minorities; you have less choice in the images you consume, so maybe the family role is even greater.
10/05/09
I heard Malaak Compton-Rock (wife of Chris and mother of Zahra) bemoaning her daughter's insecurity and the atrocities society and media have caused in terms of Zahra's self esteem - all while wearing a long, straight weave.
Just saying.
10/05/09
10/05/09
10/05/09
10/05/09
Kind of like how I never hear the end of how I need to DO SOMETHING about my "terrible" hair now.
10/05/09
10/05/09
I read somewhere that of course family members will be the most adept at pushing our buttons -- they're the ones that installed them in the first place.
I have a vivid memory of a great-aunt who said "Look how pretty" and then pulled on my hair so hard my scalp hurt. For, like, half an hour.
10/05/09
I finally turned to her one day and said "If you wanted me to have a different hair texture, you should have picked different genes for my other parent."
Her comments haven't stopped completely, but they have been ... abridged a fair amount.
08/13/09
BUT, is the article WRONG? I agree that some of the points are intended to whip people into hysteria, but black women *do* seem to have a harder time getting married than our non-white counterparts. What's the marriage rate for us right now? 30%? That's awful low and it's not for lack of wanting to get married either.
I'm a black woman in my early 30s. Just thinking about my friends/acquaintances/coworkers: the Black women are mostly single; the White & Asian women are mostly married. (I know this is anecdotal evidence, at best. I am not leaving out Latina sisters here, just don't know a lot of them.)
This statement: "African-American females, even with lots of education, do not fetch as much "value" in the marriage market" is incendiary but again, I'm not sure if it's "wrong" per se. We do seem to be the most de-valued by society (for a number of reasons).
I know I should not read these articles because honestly they just piss me off. But I think the reason they piss me off so much is both for the reasons you identify and the sad nugget of truth they contain.
08/13/09
Ok, in all seriousness, I do feel pressure to date within my race. Do I yield and date black men exclusively? hell no, because one 1) i'm fairly lucky in that my family happens to not care enough to ridicule/disown me, etc for "outdating" and 2) screw people that don't like the people I date - I don't like them anyway.....nanny nanny poo poo
08/13/09
Why is there more pressure on Black women to date within the race than on men?
Who are these men marrying and what are the relationship dynamics they're seeking and not finding within their own communties?
That said, there are plenty of people who aren't engaged in this dialogue on any level. It is a crisis and it might be necessary to shock the conscience.
08/13/09
But I think the pressure comes from people who are incredulous to the idea that black woman are in fact viewed as attractive by men that aren't black whereas with white women the assumption is that her beauty is desired by everyone. So if the black woman were to date or marry outside her race, it disproves that assumption, which people aren't comfortable with having to have to change a longstanding view. Also, I think the pressure comes from the cultural assumptions that black women, being so strong and willful, need an equally strong or moreso partner which could only be a black man as they are viewed as hypermasculine enough to tame the shrew that is the American Black Woman.
It's funny cause it seems like there is nice population of professional black adults of both sexes who I am going to assume are straight but they both just assume that the other isn't out there. So black males are probably using the same excuse for dating outside their race that some black women are: "There aren't any (blank)."
08/13/09
So black males are probably using the same excuse for dating outside their race that some black women are: "There aren't any (blank)."
Naw homie...with the exception of Black men who haven't ever spent a lot of time in or exposed to the Black community, successful Black men know where to find their female counterparts. They're outnumbered by us about 70% to 30% the whole way up the ladder.